Sabres Slide Is Raising A Bigger Question About This Team

Despite a promising roster, the Buffalo Sabres' season has unraveled into a disappointing struggle, igniting criticisms over their faltering form and concerns about leadership decisions.

The Buffalo Sabres are in a rough place, and one of the team’s most familiar voices didn’t try to soften it Thursday morning.

During an appearance on WGR 550 Radio with Jeremy White and Joe DiBiase, Sabres insider Paul Hamilton said Buffalo has reached a point where the label fits.

"Well, they are a bad team. Part of this, we've all been saying they shouldn't be losing to these teams.

You know, 'Buffalo's a better team, they shouldn't be losing to teams like this.' Well, you've lost four times to 'em.

I think it's time to call a spade a spade. Maybe the Sabres are these teams.

The Philadelphia Flyers. The Columbus Blue Jackets.

The Chicago Blackhawks.

They have beaten them twice. They did beat Columbus once and lose to them once.

They beat Chicago once and lost to them once. Lost to the Flyers twice.

Quite honestly, I just feel that the reason they're losing those games isn't because anything other than they are one of the worst teams in the NHL. They are with those teams.

They are not better than those teams, and the results are telling us that."

That’s the blunt read on a Buffalo team that no longer resembles the one that surged into the playoffs last season for the first time since 2011. Through 21 games, the Sabres sit 23rd in the overall standings with 20 points and an 8-9-4 record.

The numbers back up the ugly picture. Buffalo ranks 25th in goals scored per game at 2.76 and 24th in goals allowed per contest at 3.48. The deeper metrics aren’t much kinder, either: the Sabres are 21st in all-situations expected goal share at 48.9%, according to HockeyStats.com, and their .872 team save percentage ranks 27th.

So while the debate might be whether Buffalo is merely mediocre or sliding back toward the basement, the current results make it hard to argue they’ve been anything better than one of the league’s weakest clubs so far.

What makes the slide so frustrating is that this roster shouldn’t be this low in the standings on talent alone. There’s been plenty of attention on the departures of Alex Tuch and Bowen Byram, but Jack Quinn and Olen Zellweger have stepped in and filled those spots well enough.

The bigger issue has been the loss of the team’s identity. Last season’s late push was built on effort, with Buffalo outworking opponents, forechecking hard, backchecking with purpose and winning the dirty puck battles that decide games. That edge has been missing from the opening quarter of this season.

Instead, the Sabres have looked like a team expecting last year’s success to show up on its own. It hasn’t, and head coach Lindy Ruff has to keep driving that message home before the season gets away from them in a crowded Eastern Conference.

The front office has been searching for a jolt, too. General manager Jarmo Kekalainen passed on paying a king’s ransom for Connor Hellebuyck, who was eventually dealt from the Winnipeg Jets to the New Jersey Devils, and his attempts to land Detroit Red Wings center Dylan Larkin haven’t gone anywhere.

Big trades are hard to pull off, and nobody is pretending otherwise. But the larger concern is that Kekalainen, since taking over the front office last December, has run into the same problem that followed Kevyn Adams: when the moment calls for a decisive move, Buffalo hasn’t made one.

That sense of urgency was echoed by veteran goalie Alex Lyon after Saturday’s loss to the Dallas Stars.

"Can't bullshit the position we're in, to be honest with you," Lyon told reporters. "Kind of feels like we're on a precipice a little bit. Every team goes through these times throughout the course of the season, and good teams, mentally strong teams, find a way through it, these tough times."

If a major roster move doesn’t come, the next question is whether the Sabres would consider a coaching change as the push they need. Ruff would be the obvious candidate, even if it would be a harsh move after the work he did last season to help Buffalo finally end the longest postseason drought in league history.

There’s also been past talk about Ruff potentially moving into a front-office role, which would create a less direct path to a coaching change. That’s one possibility Kekalainen and owner Terry Pegula could weigh if the struggles keep piling up.

In Other News...

Former Sabres Are Giving Buffalo Fans A Painful Reminder Around The Metro

A familiar cast of former Sabres is making the rounds and, for Buffalo fans, the results have been hard to ignore. Mark Jankowski is on pace to top his career goal total with the Carolina Hurricanes, while Evan Rodrigues has remained a useful presence elsewhere in the Metro and Logan Stanley, James Reimer, Rasmus Ristolainen and Alex Tuch are all still carving out roles with their current clubs.

For a fan base still looking for more consistency from its own roster, seeing so many ex-Sabres settled into productive spots around the division can sting a little. It is not just one player having a nice stretch, either, but a cluster of familiar names contributing in different ways, which only sharpens the question of what Buffalo might have had if more of that talent had stuck around. [Read more 🡒]

Sabres May Need This Homegrown Defense Option Sooner Than Expected

Gavin McCarthy is giving the Sabres something to keep an eye on in Rochester. The 21-year-old defenseman, drafted by Buffalo in 2023, is working through his first full AHL season with the Americans and showing the kind of progress that can start to change a prospects timeline. Lindy Ruff has already made it clear he believes McCarthy has NHL potential, which matters for a Buffalo blue line that has needed more stability than it has found.

McCarthy is not supposed to be part of the Sabres immediate plans, but hockey timelines have a way of speeding up when a team is searching for answers. If his recent play keeps trending up and Buffalos defensive issues linger, the door could open sooner than expected for a call-up. For a club that could use more homegrown help on the back end, that makes his development worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]

Sabres Finally Delivered The Response Fans Had Been Waiting For

After five straight losses, the Sabres finally gave their fans the kind of response that had been missing, and they did it in convincing fashion with a 6-3 win over the Washington Capitals. Buffalo came out with urgency from the opening faceoff, putting up four goals in the first period and leaning on a power play that produced twice, a welcome sign for a team that had been searching for cleaner execution and a stronger start.

Jack Quinn led the scoring with two goals, including the empty-netter that put the game away, while Tage Thompson added a power-play goal in the second period to help keep the Capitals at arm's length. Even with some early penalties putting Buffalo under pressure, the Sabres managed to settle in and turn the night into the kind of complete effort that can matter just as much for confidence as it does in the standings. [Read more 🡒]