The Washington Capitals didn’t just bring in Alex Tuch in late June - they locked themselves into a massive bet on a player the market has already started to question.
Washington finalized the trade by handing Tuch an eight-year, $84 million extension worth $10.5 million annually, but one of the league’s sharpest contract analysts wasted little time putting that deal in an ugly light. Dom Luszczyszyn of The Athletic ranked it as the NHL’s ninth-worst contract, giving it just a 19% chance of positive value heading into the 2026-27 season.
“It’s difficult not to be an Alex Tuch fan after what he’s shown in Buffalo the past five years,” Luszczyszyn wrote Thursday. "...
The deal might look OK for the first couple of years, but things could get really ugly in the second half of it as Tuch approaches 35 and beyond. A lot of Tuch's comps had a relatively harsh age curve that could spell trouble for Washington."
That concern is exactly why Buffalo never budged to the level Tuch wanted, no matter whether Kevyn Adams or Jarmo Kekalainen was steering the front office. The Sabres were never going to cross into double-digit annual money on a max-term deal, and the final push from Kekalainen still wasn’t enough to bridge that gap.
Luszczyszyn’s projection is harsh for Washington. He estimates the Capitals will wind up paying $24 million in excess value over the life of the contract, and he has Tuch’s projected on-ice impact next season at just $8.7 million. In other words, the deal is expected to start underwater right away.
None of that changes what Tuch brings on the ice. The 6-foot-4 winger has been as reliable as they come, a true three-zone presence at 5-on-5 who also logged heavy work on both special teams for Buffalo. He just finished a season with 66 points, scoring 33 goals and adding 33 assists in 79 games.
For the Sabres, the departure hurts. Tuch’s production and versatility aren’t easy to replace, but Buffalo decided the price had reached its ceiling and chose to put that money elsewhere.
Now the Sabres are leaning hard into their younger core to absorb the loss.
Barring a late-offseason move, Buffalo is set to open training camp with 16 forwards competing for 13 spots, and the only summer addition in that group is Conor Sheary, who is more likely than not to begin the season with the AHL’s Rochester Americans.
That leaves the Sabres banking on internal growth around Tage Thompson, their offensive centerpiece. Their U25 group includes Zach Benson, Josh Doan, Jack Quinn, Noah Ostlund, Jiri Kulich and Konsta Helenius. None of them can simply step in and replace everything Tuch did, though Benson and Doan could eventually grow into that kind of role.
Lindy Ruff will have to sort out the rest as he goes. Quinn and Kulich should take on more offense, Ostlund could be used in more defensive situations, and Helenius brings a well-rounded game even if the Sabres probably won’t overload him early.
The result should be plenty of lineup shuffling and a lot of flexibility from night to night. Different forward combinations may show up depending on the period, the score and what Ruff sees working in the moment until he settles on groups he trusts.
That process probably won’t be smooth. Young players tend to have consistency issues even before they’re asked to handle bigger responsibilities, and Buffalo will almost certainly live through some mistakes.
The biggest area to monitor might be the penalty kill. The Sabres finished fourth in the NHL last season at 81.9%, with Tuch anchoring the first PK unit. Beck Malenstyn will be asked to shoulder more of that load, and Benson could also be part of the answer.
It’s the kind of move that makes sense over the long haul, even if it creates obvious short-term headaches. Buffalo gave up a dependable veteran and now has to solve the puzzle without him if it wants to make a second straight trip to the Stanley Cup Playoffs.
In Other News...
Sabres Offseason Verdict Feels Brutal After Long Awaited Breakthrough
After finally snapping a 15-year playoff drought, Buffalo entered the summer with a chance to build real momentum, but the front office has instead spent much of the offseason reshaping the roster around future assets. General manager Jarmo Keklinen has leaned into draft-pick accumulation and contract relief, with moves involving Michael Kesselring, Bowen Byram, Jordan Greenway, Alex Tuch and Devon Levi signaling a clear direction even if it is not the one fans had hoped would follow the breakthrough.
The quieter part is what has not happened since then. Buffalo explored bigger swings, including a run at Patrick Kane and an attempt to land goaltender Connor Hellebuyck, but neither pursuit came through, and the Sabres have been left without a move that clearly raises the ceiling of a team that just proved it can get back to the postseason. For a fan base that waited so long to get there, the pause has made this offseason feel a lot harsher than the spring celebration did. [Read more 🡒]
Sabres Prospects Are In The Spotlight As One Big Decision Looms
The World Junior Summer Showcase in Windsor, Ontario, is set to pull together some of the top young talent from the United States, Canada, Sweden and Finland, and two Sabres prospects will be right in the middle of the Canadian conversation. Samuel Meloche and Daxon Rudolph were among the 32 players named to Canadas roster, giving Buffalo another chance to watch its pipeline talent measured against the best age-group competition in the game.
Rudolph, the fourth overall pick in the 2026 NHL Draft, enters the week with a strong path toward making the Canadian squad, while Meloche is in the mix for a backup role as he competes with Jack Ivankovic, Lucas Beckman and William Lacelle. For the Sabres, the showcase is more than a summer checkpoint. It is another reminder that their prospects are starting to carry real weight on a stage where roster spots are earned quickly and every decision can ripple into the season ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Sabres Forced Into A New Free Agency Debate After Missing Out
The Sabres went into the summer needing more help up front, and the search for it only got more complicated after one of the markets biggest names came off the board. Buffalo had been tied to Patrick Kane, but with that path closed, the front office is back to weighing how best to add a winger who can bring both scoring touch and a little edge to a lineup that still needs more punch.
One name that has surfaced in that discussion is Eeli Tolvanen, who has built a reputation as a hard-working, physical forward with enough offensive skill to matter in a middle-six role. His recent seasons with Seattle showed a player who can chip in at even strength, contribute on the penalty kill and bring a heavier presence than some of the other options still available, which is exactly the kind of fit Buffalo has to sort through now. [Read more 🡒]