Sabres Fans Still Know This Goalie What-If Hurt More Than Expected

Despite early promise, Jhonas Enroth's stint with the Buffalo Sabres highlights the franchise's ongoing challenge to find a reliable goaltender after Ryan Miller.

The Buffalo Sabres have spent years searching for the next true anchor in net, and Jhonas Enroth was one of the first names to carry that weight. He came in as the immediate successor to Ryan Miller, spent multiple seasons as his backup, and then got pushed into a starting job on a team heading straight into a tank.

The promise was there. The payoff never quite came.

Buffalo had reason to believe in him from the start. The Sabres took Enroth in the second round of the 2006 draft, 46th overall, and he quickly started turning heads once he arrived in North America.

With the Portland Pirates, the Sabres’ AHL affiliate at the time, he put together three straight seasons of real consistency. He won 20 or more games in each of those years, topped out at 28 in 2009-10, and never posted worse than a .912 save percentage, with a high mark of .919% in 2009-10.

That kind of production earned him repeated call-ups and, by 2011-12, a full-time spot behind Miller.

His numbers in Buffalo didn’t always reflect the work he was putting in, but they still told the story of a goalie who could handle himself. Over his first three seasons as a full-time backup, Enroth appeared in 66 games and went 16-32-10 with a 2.71 goals-against average, a .916 save percentage, and two shutouts. Then came his first real chance to run with the job after Miller was traded, and the 2014-15 season changed the arc of his career.

In that first season as a starter, Enroth played 37 games and finished 13-21-2 with a 3.27 GAA and a .903 save percentage. Those weren’t the numbers anyone hoped for, but they were enough to get him moved to the Dallas Stars in February of 2015.

By then, Buffalo was deep into its tank, and a rebound season from Enroth wasn’t part of the plan. He wrapped up his Sabres run with 118 games played, 106 starts, a 38-56-14 record, a 2.92 GAA, a .910 save percentage, and four shutouts.

After leaving Buffalo, Enroth’s career kept moving, just not in the direction the Sabres once imagined. He spent time with the Stars, Kings, and Maple Leafs, playing 35 games across those stops before heading to the Kontinental Hockey League with Dinamo Minsk and then to the Swedish Hockey League with Orebro HK. His NHL career ended up at 153 games, 132 starts, a 50-69-16 record, a 2.84 GAA, a .909 save percentage, and seven shutouts.

In Europe, he found a much better fit. Enroth’s current SHL record sits at 122-107-3 with a 2.35 GAA, a .910 save percentage, and 18 shutouts. He has been a steady presence for Orebro HK since joining them in 2020, and the move clearly suited him better than the NHL grind did.

Now 38, Enroth is still playing in Sweden and has not announced his retirement. An NHL return isn’t expected, and probably isn’t realistic with how crowded creases are now. More likely, he finishes his career overseas and does it on his own terms.

He may not have become the Sabres’ long-term answer in goal, but Enroth was never really the problem by himself. The situation around him helped shape the outcome.

What he did give Buffalo was a bridge from the Ryan Miller era and a flash of hope that the next goalie in line might finally settle things down in the crease. That mattered, even if the ending didn’t turn out the way anyone in Buffalo wanted.

In Other News...

Sabres Fans Have Every Right To Be Furious Over Zach Benson Take

Zach Benson has already given the Sabres plenty to feel good about, which is why the latest outside evaluation is bound to rattle Buffalo fans. The young forward arrived with a big reputation after piling up 98 points in 60 games in his final WHL season, went 13th overall in the 2023 NHL draft, and has since shown enough at the NHL level to reach 101 points and land a seven-year, $52.5 million extension in June.

So when one ranking puts Benson behind some prospects with far less league experience, it is easy to see why the reaction in Buffalo would be sharp. Benson has not been treated like a fringe piece by the organization, and the debate around his place in the sport now stretches well beyond simple patience or projection, especially with the Sabres banking on him as part of their next core. [Read more 🡒]

Sabres Still Need Veteran Scoring Help As One Name Gains Steam

The Sabres are still working through how to replace the offense and presence they lost when Alex Tuch and Bowen Byram departed, and the search has a familiar summer feel: find veteran help, add some scoring touch and make sure the roster has a little more backbone for the stretch ahead. General manager Jarmo Kekalainen has been looking at players who can bring both production and leadership, and one name that has started to surface is veteran winger Smith.

Smiths fit is easy enough to understand from Buffalos side, especially with training camp approaching and the club weighing different roster paths before anything is finalized. He is one of several options being discussed, and the Sabres are still leaving themselves room to maneuver, with no signings or trades confirmed yet as they try to balance need, cost and competition from other teams. [Read more 🡒]

Mattias Samuelsson Gives Sabres Fans Real Reason To Believe Again

Mattias Samuelssons season gave Buffalo a much-needed reminder of what a steady top-four defenseman can look like over a full year. The Sabres blueliner played 78 games in 2025-26, set career highs in goals, assists and points, and logged 22:50 of ice time per night, the kind of workload that shows how heavily the team leaned on him. Alongside Owen Power and Rasmus Dahlin, he helped give Buffalo a defensive core it could actually build around.

Samuelssons importance also goes beyond one strong season, because his contract is already in place through 2029-30. For a Sabres team that has spent too long searching for dependable answers on the back end, that matters almost as much as the production itself. The bigger question now is whether this was the start of a lasting step forward or simply the first sign that Buffalo may finally have the kind of stability its blue line has lacked. [Read more 🡒]