There’s still plenty the Buffalo Bills won’t know about their 2026 defense for a while, but one thing is already coming into focus: Jim Leonhard may not be building the kind of pressure package people are expecting.
That’s the read NFL writer and analyst Doug Farrar offered during a recent appearance on “One Bills Live” with Chris Brown and Steve Tasker, and it paints Leonhard as a coach who was already leaning into some of the league’s most current defensive ideas long before they became trendy.
Leonhard, Buffalo’s new defensive coordinator, is taking over a unit that will need time to come together. Some of the roster will be carryover from Sean McDermott’s tenure, while other pieces will be newcomers from free agency and the 2026 NFL Draft.
That alone makes year one a work in progress. Add in the fact that Leonhard has never called an NFL defense, and the questions only grow.
But Farrar’s point was that Leonhard may be better aligned with where the NFL is headed than the label of “pressure-packed” defense suggests.
“The last two teams that won (the Super Bowl) created massive confusion for the opposing quarterback without blitzing.”
That, Farrar argued, is the lane modern defenses are driving toward - not just heat, but movement, disguise and timing disruption. And in his view, Leonhard was already doing that at Wisconsin in 2022.
“Players and defensive coaches right now, the overarching things with modern defense is that everything has to be connected to everything else: front, ‘backers, coverage. However you wanna line it up play to play - that’s the only way this post-snap movement, whether it’s stunts at the line, disguised coverage.”
Farrar said he was struck by how many current NFL concepts showed up in Leonhard’s college system years ago.
“It was really fascinating to me to see how many current NFL concepts (Leonhard) was using five years ago in college. This was a lot of four-man fronts, but a lot of stunts.
I mean, he ran hundreds of different, you know, almost 300 stunt plays. So your linemen are always creating games.”
He tied that directly to the way several top NFL defenses are operating now, pointing to the idea of moving fronts and forcing offenses into uncomfortable decisions.
“And I was talking to Mike McDonald about this for the Athlon NFL preview and he said: ‘We’re not necessarily trying to create pressure. What we’re doing is we’re moving the front.
We’re moving the protections. We’re forcing the offensive line to do things they don’t want to do, and we’re creating confusion in the mind of the quarterback.’
And that seems to be where defense is going both with the stunts and with the disguised coverages.”
For Farrar, the big payoff isn’t necessarily sacks on every snap. It’s the hesitation that comes before the throw.
“You know, you want, can you pressure the quarterback? Sure.
But if you can force the quarterback to hesitate just for a beat - like, ‘I’m not sure what I’m seeing’ - then the whole thing can fall apart. So, I was really intrigued to see Leonhard doing this in college, and it’s the subtle coverage disguises like, Brian Flores of the Vikings, you never know - that guy’s a petri dish.
You never know what you’re gonna get.”
He also linked Leonhard’s approach to the broader family of modern defensive systems.
“But it’s the Vic Fangio, the Jesse Minter, Mike McDonald (schemes). Most of it is two-high shell pre-snap.
And Leonhard was doing this, again, five years ago in college. You know, it’s subtle little twists of the knife over and over and over, and it just starts to peck away at the offense and all of a sudden the quarterback is in this weird nether world that he didn’t expect to be in.
So, I think Leonhard, you know, he had that experience with the Broncos - we can talk about certain things there as far as the five-man fronts and whatnot because there’s some things to note.”
What stood out most to Farrar was the fit between Leonhard’s ideas and the kind of players Buffalo has brought in.
“But I think he is uniquely attuned to modern NFL defense because he was doing that already. And then when you look at the defensive players they drafted and the free agents, I mean, all of these guys, and we can go down the list, they’re all functionally versatile.
They don’t just necessarily do one thing. So, Leonhard’s telling you with his personnel ‘I want guys who can be anywhere, and it’s not necessarily obvious - we’re just gonna move one guy or two guys - and the quarterback’s not going to know what to expect.”
That’s still a projection, not a finished product. And it will take patience for Bills Mafia to see how it all fits together. But the picture Farrar drew suggests Buffalo’s defense under Leonhard may be less about brute-force pressure and more about confusion, disguise and constant movement.
In Other News...
Bills Fans Have Every Right To Be Furious Over Christian Benford
Christian Benford has spent four seasons giving the Bills exactly the kind of steady outside play every defense needs, even if it has not always looked flashy enough to grab national attention. Since arriving as a 2022 draft pick, he has been a consistent starter, holding receivers to an average of 10.8 yards per catch while carving out a reputation as one of Buffalos more reliable defenders.
The frustrating part for Bills fans is that Benfords work has still not translated into the kind of recognition it deserves. He drew Defensive Player of the Year votes in 2024 and posted a career-best 54.4% completion rate allowed in 2025, but his name still seems to get lost in the bigger picture of a defense that has not always helped its top performers get their due. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Fans Are Split Over What PSLs Should Really Guarantee
The Bills decision to limit the annual Return of the Blue and Red practice at the new Highmark Stadium to season ticket members only has stirred up a familiar kind of fan debate in Buffalo: what, exactly, should a Personal Seat License buy you? For many supporters, PSLs are supposed to mean more than just a better chance at a seat on game day, and the reaction to this one-off restriction showed how closely fans are watching the line between premium access and team-wide goodwill.
Pete Guelli said the team heard the criticism and moved to add a second open practice on Aug. 18 for fans without PSLs, with Joe Brady helping push the idea along after discussions about giving more people a look at the new building. Even with that concession, the larger question lingers for Bills fans: should PSL ownership guarantee first crack at football-related events, while other stadium attractions stay more open to the public? [Read more 🡒]
Bills Face A Sneaky Roster Battle After Reggie Gilliams Exit
With Reggie Gilliam gone, the Bills have a little more room to sort out how they want to use the fullback spot, and Jackson Acker suddenly becomes a name worth watching. Signed as an undrafted free agent, Acker brings some real athletic upside from Wisconsin, where he showed enough as both a runner and receiver to suggest there could be more to his game than the usual lead-blocker profile.
For Acker, the path to the 53-man roster in 2026 looks tied to the unglamorous work that often decides these fringe battles. Ben VanSumeran gives Buffalo a veteran presence in the mix, so Acker will need to prove he can handle the dirty jobs well enough to stick, with special teams likely to be the area that tips the decision one way or the other. [Read more 🡒]