Stephen A. Smith isn’t buying the Buffalo Bills as the NFL’s second-favorite to win it all.
On Monday’s edition of ESPN’s "First Take," Smith was asked whether Buffalo deserved to sit with the second-shortest odds to win Super Bowl LXI. He didn’t dance around it.
“No,” Smith said. “No, I don’t.”
That doesn’t mean he’s down on Josh Allen. Smith made it clear he respects the quarterback and also pointed to new head coach Joe Brady, who previously handled Buffalo’s offense as coordinator.
He also acknowledged that the Bills have been one of the league’s most productive offenses under Brady. But that’s where the praise stopped.
The bigger issue, in Smith’s view, is what’s happening around Buffalo. The Los Angeles Rams currently have the shortest odds, with the Bills next, followed by the Baltimore Ravens and Seattle Seahawks. Smith had no problem putting the Rams atop the board; earlier in the segment, he projected Los Angeles to go 13-4 and grab the NFC’s top seed.
His reluctance with Buffalo had less to do with skepticism about Allen and more to do with how quickly other contenders are being brushed aside. He brought up Denver, which made it to the AFC Championship Game last season even after Bo Nix was injured late in the Broncos’ divisional-round win over Buffalo. Smith even said Denver would have reached the Super Bowl if Nix had stayed available.
Then there’s Kansas City, a team plenty of people seem ready to write off after a 6-11 season and a missed playoff berth. Patrick Mahomes was hurt during that rough year, but Smith wasn’t interested in treating one bad season like the end of the line for a franchise that has already won three championships and played in five Super Bowls with Mahomes.
“You can’t sleep on these brothers,” he said. “These are three-time champions who’ve been to five Super Bowls. They know what it takes.”
That’s the tension around Buffalo right now. The Bills are being priced on Allen’s ceiling, even though some of their rivals have either done more already or look stronger on paper around their quarterbacks.
Buffalo also has a defensive question hanging over it. Jason McCourty noted that new defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard plans to install a more aggressive system than the one Sean McDermott used before.
That might lighten the load on Allen, but it’s still just a plan until January shows whether it works.
None of that means Buffalo can’t win the AFC. Allen is good enough to carry a lot, and keeping Brady gives the offense continuity it can build on. Still, giving the Bills the second-shortest championship odds is a massive vote of confidence for a team that still has to prove it can finish the job.
Buffalo has been treated like a future champion for years. At some point, future has to become now.
In Other News...
Bills Have A Josh Allen Problem Fans Really Do Not Want
The Bills went into the 2026 offseason knowing the backup quarterback spot could matter more than usual, and Kyle Allen was brought in to provide insurance behind Josh Allen. Instead, early training camp reports have already made that job look shaky, which is the last thing Buffalo wants to hear with the season approaching. The concern is simple: if the starter misses time, the offense would be asking a quarterback with limited recent playing experience to keep everything on track.
Kyle Allens recent resume does not do much to calm those nerves, either. He spent 2025 with the Lions and barely saw the field, and his last meaningful starts came for Houston in 2022. For a Bills team built around Josh Allens ability to drive the offense, that leaves a real question lurking under camp optimism, because the gap between a dependable backup and a stopgap can change a lot very quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Dalton Kincaid Is Giving Josh Allen Something The Bills Need
Dalton Kincaid spent his offseason juggling training with the need to manage a knee injury, and the early signs at Bills camp suggest the tight end is arriving in a good place for his fourth season. Through the first four training camp practices, Kincaid has looked sharp enough to draw notice from Josh Allen, which matters in a Buffalo offense that always benefits when the quarterback has another dependable target working underneath and between the numbers.
The encouraging part for the Bills is not just that Kincaid is practicing, but that he is doing it well while coming off a summer built around staying healthy. Buffalo is also getting looks at other young pieces such as Tylan Grable, Jude Bowry and Landon Jackson, but Kincaids early camp form stands out because he has the kind of role that can quietly change the rhythm of the offense if it keeps building from here. [Read more 🡒]
Dalton Kincaid Gave Bills Fans A Scare They Could Not Ignore
Dalton Kincaid gave Bills fans a brief jolt during training camp practice when he went down after an awkward-looking hit, creating the kind of pause that instantly turns a routine rep into a worry. For a team counting on the tight end as an important offensive piece, any scare around a key player tends to hang over the rest of the day.
The concern eased quickly, though, and Kincaid was back on the field shortly after the incident. Entering his fourth season, he remains a central part of Buffalos offense, which is why even a short-lived setback drew immediate attention from everyone watching camp. [Read more 🡒]