The Athletic says its internal review of Dianna Russini found one thing plainly: her relationship with Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel crossed a line.
In a report released Thursday, the company said Russini’s connection with Vrabel “was in clear violation of The Athletic's standards.” The review covered roughly five months and looked at how that relationship may have intersected with her NFL coverage. While The Athletic said it found no clear bias in her reporting, it also said the relationship should have been disclosed.
The company’s investigation was wide-ranging. It reviewed 903 stories and 77 videos published under Russini’s byline, along with 204 podcast episodes and 25 off-platform appearances, plus interviews with multiple employees.
The Athletic said the issue was not whether the relationship was romantic, but that it was a breach either way and needed to be disclosed. The company pointed to photographs published by Page Six on April 7 and April 23, and by TMZ on April 23, saying they suggested a relationship that threatened The Athletic’s credibility and created the appearance of a conflict of interest.
The report also laid out how the situation unfolded. Russini first contacted company executives on April 7 to warn them about an upcoming article that “would suggest a romantic relationship between Russini and Mike Vrabel.” She acknowledged a close relationship with Vrabel but said it was “strictly professional,” and The Athletic initially stood behind her while it opened an internal review.
That review changed course when Russini resigned on April 14. The Athletic said it ended its investigation into her personal conduct after that, but kept examining her journalism.
Semel’s report said Russini should have told the company about the nature of her relationship with Vrabel so editors could decide what stories, if any, she should have handled. At the same time, the investigation said it did not find “a clear link to conclude that Russini used her platform to help promote Vrabel or help his teams during her time at The Athletic.” Still, Semel noted there were instances of her writing positively about Vrabel that, looking back, felt “awkward or even uncomfortable.”
“The vast majority of Russini's work for The Athletic had nothing to do with Vrabel, the teams he was coaching or the players the team was pursuing,” Semel wrote. “In interviews with editors and reporters with whom she worked most closely, it was clear Russini was sourced up around the NFL, not just with Vrabel or the Patriots.”
The report said there were no findings of inaccurate reporting except for one 2023 story that said Vrabel’s coaching job in Tennessee was safe less than two months before he was fired. Semel noted that “no other media [came] out as strongly about Vrabel's job security” at the time.
The Athletic said it has already added editor’s notes to two pieces of content and recommended more changes going forward, including a standards-editor meeting during onboarding, clearer conflict-of-interest guidance and tighter enforcement of sourcing standards.
Russini responded Thursday in a statement to The Athletic’s Andrew Marchand, saying she stands “by any and all reporting [she's] ever done in [her] career.”
Russini left The Athletic in April after photos surfaced of her and Vrabel at an Arizona hotel resort, prompting speculation about an extramarital affair. She denied those rumors and said the images were “misleading and lack essential context.”
After the company opened its investigation, she resigned on April 14. A week later, Page Six published additional photos that appeared to show Russini and Vrabel kissing at a New York City bar in 2020.
In Other News...
Josh Allens Top Target Suddenly Puts Buffalos Week 1 Stability In Doubt
Khalil Shakirs late-August absence has become one of the more notable storylines around Buffalos receiver room as the Bills work through the final stretch before their season opener against the Texans. Shakir has missed recent practices because of an undisclosed injury, and while the team has been careful not to spell out the issue, the tone around his status remains more reassuring than alarming.
For a passing game that leans on timing and trust, any missed reps from Josh Allens top target are worth watching this time of year. Buffalo still sounds optimistic Shakir will be available for Week 1, and the wider receiver outlook got a small lift with DJ Moore also expected to be ready after his own preseason injury scare. Still, with the opener approaching, the Bills are leaving themselves a little less certainty than they probably wanted. [Read more 🡒]
Josh Allen Just Gave Bills Fans A New Way To Join In
Josh Allen turned a sideline accessory into something with a much bigger purpose this week, teaming up with children at Golisano Children's Hospital of Buffalo to create eight one-of-a-kind Bills hats. Each design blends Allens hand-drawn logo with artwork from the kids, giving the project a personal touch that fits the quarterbacks long-running connection to the Buffalo community.
The hats will show up on Allen before each of the Bills eight regular-season home games, and fans can buy them as well, with proceeds going to the Patricia Allen Fund at the hospital. It is part of his partnership with New Era and a continuation of the charitable effort he started last season, a reminder that for Allen, the football season in Buffalo can still make room for something bigger than football. [Read more 🡒]
Josh Allen And Joe Brady Just Raised The Stakes In Buffalo
Three NFL.com writers all picked the Bills to win Super Bowl LXI, even if they could not agree on who would be waiting on the other sideline. That kind of preseason confidence is easy to dismiss in August, but it does speak to how much belief surrounds Buffalo after the front office went out and traded for D.J. Moore to give Josh Allen another proven target.
The bigger shift is on the sideline, where the 2026 season opens with Joe Brady in charge after Sean McDermott was fired and promoted out of the job. Allen has piled up the kind of career numbers that keep him in the leagues elite conversation, but he still has not gotten to the Super Bowl, which is why the pressure in Buffalo feels a little sharper now, and a little more real. [Read more 🡒]