Khalil Shakir Is Making A Stronger Case For A Bigger Bills Role

With the Buffalo Bills boasting an impressive start to the season, integrating Khalil Shakir more prominently into the passing offense could elevate their game to new heights.

The Bills are sitting at 8-1 and putting up 31.9 points per game, which is enough to make any offense look pretty complete. But there’s still a clear place Buffalo can squeeze out more: getting Khalil Shakir more involved in the passing game.

That idea may sound a little odd at first glance, especially after Shakir finished the Week 10 win over the Jets with two catches for 29 yards and three “runs” for 26 yards. Still, the case for a bigger role isn’t built on one game.

It ties back to Buffalo’s win in MetLife Stadium, to Amon-Ra St. Brown’s big day for the Lions against the Patriots in Germany, and to Parker Washington posting 152 receiving yards for the Jaguars, his most in a game since 2019.

It also lines up with the timing of Buffalo’s upcoming five-game stretch during the holiday season: vs. Chiefs, at Patriots, at Packers, vs.

Bears, and at Broncos.

The simplest argument is also the strongest one: Shakir has been the Bills’ most dependable receiver for going on four seasons.

Even in 2023, his second NFL season and one played alongside Stefon Diggs, Shakir’s yards per route run was 1.79, close to Diggs’ 1.89. His drop rate was much better too, 2.0% compared with Diggs’ 6.4%, and he averaged 7.0 yards after contact per reception to Diggs’ 3.9. Those numbers include the playoffs.

Yes, the sample size matters. Diggs was targeted 175 times that year, while Shakir got 56. That’s a huge gap.

But in the two playoff games that season, Shakir and Diggs both finished with 10 catches. Shakir had 75 yards to Diggs’ 73 and scored two touchdowns, while Diggs had none.

And if there was still any debate about who the more reliable option has been since then, 2024 and beyond have made the answer pretty straightforward. During Josh Allen’s MVP season in 2024, Shakir led Buffalo in targets with 100, receptions with 76, and receiving yards with 821 in the regular season. Correlation doesn’t prove everything on its own, but it’s hard to ignore Shakir being Buffalo’s de facto No. 1 receiver during a season when the offense was absurdly efficient.

He’s also not some under-the-radar grinder without the traits to match the production. The physical profile stacks up well next to other slot standouts like Amon-Ra St. Brown and Josh Downs.

Khalil Shakir Amon-Ra St. Brown* Josh Downs

Height / Weight 6’0” / 196 5’11” / 197 5’9” / 171

40-Yard 4.43 4.61 4.48

10-Yard 1.49 1.63 1.49

Vertical 34.5” 38.5” 38.5”

Broad 124 127” 131

Three-Cone 7.28 6.9 N/A

*testing figures at USC Pro Day

Shakir compares favorably with St. Brown and Downs there. Parker Washington was left out of that group because he didn’t work out before Jacksonville took him in the sixth round of the 2023 NFL Draft.

This season, the numbers keep pointing the same way. Shakir has produced efficiently despite getting a relatively modest share of Buffalo’s targets.

His target share is 18.1%, which means he has accounted for 18.1% of the Bills’ pass targets through nine games. That ranks 34th among 71 qualifying wide receivers. Yet he’s 20th in yards per route run at 2.00.

That’s the heart of the argument. He isn’t seeing the ball a ton, but when he’s on the field and running routes, he’s still generating strong production.

The comparison chart also shows Parker Washington at 24.9% target share, St. Brown above 30%, and Downs almost exactly where Shakir is at 18.0%.

There aren’t many other receivers sitting in that upper-left quadrant of the scatter plot either. The names there are Jameson Williams, Tre Tucker, Caleb Douglas, DeMario Douglas, Rome Odunze, and Nico Collins.

Shakir’s average depth of target is 4.7 yards right now. That’s up from 3.9 last season, though still below his 5.6 aDOT in 2024, when he posted a 2.15 yards-per-route-run mark.

St. Brown’s aDOT is 8.6, and he’s been above 8.0 in each of the last four seasons.

Washington’s is 13.1, the same as his breakout year last season.

And Shakir has shown he can create chunk plays and yards after the catch in the same way other slot producers do. His career yards after catch per reception is 8.1, ahead of St. Brown’s 4.9, Washington’s 4.5, and Downs’ 4.5.

His career rate of catches of 20-plus yards is 14.7%, compared with 14.3% for St. Brown, 23.9% for Washington, and 12.7% for Downs.

There’s also this: Shakir has at least one 50-plus yard reception in each of the last four seasons.

And if hands matter, he has those too. His career drop rate is 3.4%, better than St. Brown’s 2.9%, and ahead of Downs’ 5.2% and Washington’s 9.0%.

So the conclusion is pretty clear. Shakir should be a bigger part of Buffalo’s passing offense. He’s earned it, and the Bills would probably be better off if he were seeing more than five targets per game.

In Other News...

Former Bills Star Marcell Dareus Is Back In Troubling Headlines

Marcell Dareus, once one of the most recognizable defensive players in Buffalo, is back in troubling headlines after an arrest in Hoover, Alabama. Police say he was pulled over for erratic driving, then allegedly resisted arrest and assaulted an officer, turning what began as a traffic stop into a much more serious legal situation.

Officers also reported finding marijuana on Dareus after the arrest, and he was charged with multiple offenses, including aggravated assault on a police officer and marijuana possession. He was later released after posting bond, but the latest episode adds another difficult chapter to the former Bills star's post-Buffalo story. [Read more 🡒]

Bills Suddenly Have A Real Chance To Revisit Marquise Brown

Marquise Brown is back on the market after being waived by the Eagles and clearing waivers, and that immediately puts Buffalo back into the conversation. The Bills had previously been linked to Brown, and the fit still makes sense on paper for a team that has spent plenty of time trying to sort out the right mix at receiver while also keeping an eye on the practice squad for help.

Browns recent stops and production will be part of the evaluation, along with the fact that he has already shown he can be a useful piece in the right offense. For Buffalo, the question now is whether this is the moment to circle back on a player they once had interest in, or whether the receiver room is stable enough that they can let another opportunity pass. [Read more 🡒]

Ryan Clark Just Reopened A Frustrating Josh Allen MVP Debate

Josh Allens place in the MVP conversation is back under the microscope, even with the Bills rolling to an 8-1 start. Through nine games, Allen has piled up 2,223 passing yards, 13 passing touchdowns and 11 rushing touchdowns, production that usually keeps him near the center of the leagues most valuable player debate. But the conversation took a fresh turn when Ryan Clark said he does not view Allen as a top three MVP candidate for the 2026 NFL season.

Clark pointed to Allens touchdown totals and passing yardage while putting Joe Burrow, Brock Purdy and Trevor Lawrence ahead of him on his list. For Buffalo, it is the kind of outside critique that tends to linger because Allens value is tied so closely to how the Bills are winning, and because his numbers still invite a wide range of interpretations. The debate may not change what Allen is doing on the field, but it does ensure the MVP discussion around him stays lively. [Read more 🡒]