The NFL MVP race usually starts with one simple truth: if you’re not a quarterback, you’re already fighting uphill. A QB has taken home the award in each of the last 13 seasons, and Adrian Peterson’s win in 2012 is still the last time someone else broke through.
Last year’s trophy went to Matthew Stafford by the slimmest of margins, and repeat winners are almost never the story. So when camp opens, the real conversation is about which passers are positioned to stack wins, pile up production and stay healthy long enough to stay in the frame.
Five quarterbacks stand out above the rest.
Josh Allen is the cleanest bet on the board after Buffalo went out and gave him the kind of weapon he’s been missing. He’s coming off a 2025 season in which he finished with 4,247 total yards and 39 total touchdowns, and he was the only player in the league to clear both 3,000 passing yards and 500 rushing yards. His 104.3 passer rating also topped the mark from his MVP season.
Now the Bills have added DJ Moore, sending a second-round pick to Chicago for a receiver who gives Allen a true WR1 for the first time since Buffalo moved on from Stefon Diggs before the 2024 season. Moore also reunites with Joe Brady, who served as his offensive coordinator in Carolina and is now Buffalo’s head coach after Sean McDermott was fired following a Divisional Round exit.
The Bills are bringing back almost all of their 2025 starters, so the biggest changes voters will notice are Brady on the sideline and Moore on the outside. After that, the depth chart gets thin fast, with Khalil Shakir and second-year receiver Keon Coleman handling the rest of the perimeter work.
Lamar Jackson has a different kind of case, one built around scheme and the kind of efficiency that makes voters pay attention. He was already one vote away from a second unanimous MVP in 2024, and in 2025 he opened like a runaway train, throwing for 969 yards, 10 touchdowns and one interception through four weeks before a hamstring injury against Kansas City ended the momentum and helped send Baltimore out of the playoff picture.
This year brings a new offensive coordinator in Declan Doyle, who at 29 is the youngest coordinator in the league. The Ravens are installing a play-action-heavy system that fits the part of Jackson’s game that grades out best.
Baltimore also made major changes around him, hiring Jesse Minter to replace John Harbaugh, who left for the New York Giants, and overhauling much of the coaching staff in the process. Up front, the team rebuilt both guard spots and added Trey Hendrickson to a pass rush that was among the league’s worst a year ago, joining Kyle Hamilton and Roquan Smith.
The one spot that still needs sorting out is center, where an unproven player steps in after four years of Pro Bowl play from Tyler Linderbaum. That matters even more with Jackson expected to be under center more often.
Joe Burrow’s argument starts with health and ends with the roster around him. A turf toe injury limited him to eight starts in 2025, and Cincinnati stumbled to a 6-11 finish.
But when he’s been healthy enough to play full seasons, the numbers have been ridiculous: 4,611 yards, 4,475 yards and 4,918 yards over his three healthy 16-plus-game seasons, with that last one coming with a 43-to-9 touchdown-to-interception ratio. He also owns the NFL’s career completion percentage record at 68.5 percent and checked in at No. 4 among quarterbacks in ESPN’s survey of executives, coaches and scouts.
The Bengals did their part to clean up the other side of the ball, which had ranked 29th in defensive EPA over the previous three seasons. They traded for Dexter Lawrence and signed Jonathan Allen, Boye Mafe and Bryan Cook.
Offensively, everything is still in place: all 11 starters return, including Ja’Marr Chase, Tee Higgins and Chase Brown. Burrow has already called this the most talented group he’s played with, and Zac Taylor remains head coach with Burrow and the offensive core behind him.
The reason this matters is simple - Burrow’s production has not been the issue in Cincinnati. The defense and the overall team results have been.
Justin Herbert gets a fresh start with Mike McDaniel and a line that finally looks like it can hold up. Herbert threw for 3,727 yards and 26 touchdowns in 2025 and added a career-best 498 rushing yards, but he did it behind a line that allowed 54 sacks and led the league in pressure. That’s a brutal setup for any quarterback, no matter how talented.
McDaniel has already made a notable tweak, changing Herbert’s shotgun stance so his left foot is forward in an effort to speed up the release. The offense is built around timing, wide-zone concepts and yards after the catch, and the Chargers spent the offseason trying to match that vision.
They signed center Tyler Biadasz and got tackles Rashawn Slater and Joe Alt back to full health after Slater missed all of 2025 and Alt played only six games. Herbert also has a strong group of skill players to work with in Ladd McConkey, Omarion Hampton, Quentin Johnston and free-agent tight end David Njoku.
The challenge is obvious, though: the AFC West still runs through the Broncos and a Kansas City team that is trying to rebound, and Herbert’s 0-3 postseason record hangs over a team still chasing its first division title since 2009.
Patrick Mahomes rounds out the group, and his case begins with a single question: how quickly is he really coming back from the torn ACL that ended Kansas City’s season in December? The injury snapped the Chiefs’ streak of seven straight trips to at least the AFC Championship Game. Reports say he’s ahead of schedule and confident about being ready for Week 1 against Denver, but getting cleared and being fully himself are two different things.
The Chiefs tried to support him by adding Kenneth Walker III to an offense that leaned hard on Mahomes before the injury. They also return one of the league’s strongest interior lines in Creed Humphrey and Trey Smith.
There are still concerns around the skill group and the defense. Rashee Rice served a 30-day jail sentence this offseason after a felony street-racing conviction following a failed drug test, and the league has not said whether he will be suspended.
Behind Rice, the options thin out quickly with Xavier Worthy and an aging Travis Kelce. Kansas City also lost cornerbacks Trent McDuffie and Jaylen Watson.
Andy Reid and Mahomes haven’t entered a season with this much to prove since Mahomes became the starter, but that kind of pressure has also been the backdrop for some of his best years.
In Other News...
Doug Flutie Still Divides Bills Fans In One All-Time Debate
Doug Fluties place in Bills history has always been a little more complicated than a simple ranking exercise. He belongs in the same conversation with Jim Kelly, Josh Allen and Joe Ferguson as one of the franchises most memorable quarterbacks, and his path to Buffalo was unlike anyone elses, built on a long professional career that stretched across multiple leagues and included major success in Canada before he ever became a familiar name in Western New York.
Fluties legacy in Buffalo still carries a split-screen feel because of what he brought to the team in the late 1990s and what his arrival represented to fans who watched every snap. He helped push the Bills back into the playoffs in back-to-back seasons, but his time there also left behind one of the defining debates of that era, a reminder that even a quarterback with a strong rsum can leave a franchise with admiration, frustration and a few unanswered questions all at once. [Read more 🡒]
James Cooks Market Value Will Frustrate Bills Fans
Running back value around the NFL has been a tricky conversation for years, and James Cook is the latest reminder of how quickly the market can flatten out even for a productive player. ESPNs Bill Barnwell recently ran through theoretical trade values for a handful of Bills, and Cook landed in a tier that reflects the positions diminished standing leaguewide and the contract realities that come with it.
For Buffalo fans, the frustrating part is what that says about the return in any hypothetical deal. Cooks value is being dragged down by the same forces that have made running backs harder to move for premium picks, and Barnwells exercise put him alongside players who are more likely to be viewed as useful pieces than headline-grabbing assets. It is all academic for now, though, because the Bills are not shopping Cook and plan to keep him in the fold. [Read more 🡒]