Dalton Kincaid’s start to the season is forcing the Bills to think ahead, and maybe think a little harder than they expected.
Buffalo already made its move on the tight end’s rookie deal this offseason, picking up Kincaid’s fifth-year option even with the knee injury that had followed him since 2024 and the missed games that came with it over the last two seasons. It was a reasonable call, and one the Bills probably didn’t have to make if they wanted to leave themselves more flexibility. But they did, and that means Kincaid is now under team control through the 2027 season.
Right now, that looks like a smart bet on a player who has come out of the gate looking every bit like a difference-maker.
Through two games, Kincaid has been one of Buffalo’s most productive targets. He led the Bills in receiving yards against both the Texans and the Lions, piling up 130 yards against Houston and finishing just five yards shy of 100 against Detroit.
He also found the end zone against the Lions. For Buffalo’s offense, that’s the kind of early-season production that turns a tight end from a useful piece into a central problem for opposing defenses.
The bigger question is what happens if this keeps going.
A healthy Dalton Kincaid is a dangerous Dalton Kincaid, and that’s the version the Bills are getting right now. The talent has never really been in doubt.
The issue has been whether he could stay on the field long enough to fully show it. If he does that this season, he’s on a path toward All-Pro territory and the kind of status that puts him among the league’s best at the position.
That’s where the contract conversation gets real.
Buffalo wants Kincaid to keep rising. The problem is that the more he looks like a star, the more expensive this gets.
Spotrac has George Kittle as the highest-paid tight end in the league at $19.1 million per year, with Trey McBride right behind him at $19 million. Jake Ferguson and Cole Kmet are listed at $12.5 million per year to round out the top 10, while Spotrac pegs Kincaid’s market value at $16.3 million per year.
That number would already place him just outside the top five at the position. If he keeps playing at an elite level, though, it could climb even higher.
So the Bills are in a spot they’d rather be in than the alternative: Kincaid is producing, and producing at a level that makes him look worth every bit of attention he’s getting. But if this hot start turns into a full-season breakout, Buffalo may have to decide not just whether to extend him, but how much it’s willing to spend to keep him - and what else it might have to sacrifice to do it.
In Other News...
Bills Win Got Overshadowed By A Pregame Criticism Fans Will Debate
The Bills 41-31 win over the Lions at Highmark Stadium should have been the main talking point from Week 2, but a pregame gripe from Breiden Fehoko ended up pulling plenty of attention its own way. Before kickoff, Fehoko vented on Twitter about the Canadian national anthem being played, turning a routine bit of pregame ceremony into an unexpectedly noisy side story around a game Buffalo handled on the field.
Buffalos offense did its part to keep the focus on football, and the result only added to a strong early-season start for a team that still has plenty of bigger goals ahead. Even so, the debate around Fehokos comments is the kind of off-field flashpoint that lingers after a win, especially with the Bills moving on to a stretch that includes Joe Burrows Bengals and more chances for the conversation to shift back to what happens between the lines. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Win Just Sparked A Brutal Debate About Dan Campbell
The Lions 41-31 loss to the Bills in Week 2 did more than hand Buffalo another win. It also reopened a familiar conversation around Dan Campbell, with analyst Emmanuel Acho questioning how Detroit looks when it has to keep moving without former offensive coordinator Ben Johnson, who left after the 2025 season to coach the Bears.
For a team that has spent the past few years building an identity under Campbell, the timing of the criticism matters. Detroit now gets a quick chance to reset at Ford Field against the Jets in Week 3, and the pressure is only growing to show that the offense can still function at a high level even with Johnson no longer on the sideline. [Read more 🡒]
Bills 2-0 Start Is Hiding A Defensive Issue Jim Leonhard Sees
The Bills are 2-0 and the early conversation around Buffalo has centered on Josh Allen and an offense that has looked every bit like the engine of a contender. But inside the building, there is already a quieter concern taking shape on the other side of the ball, where a defense working under new playcaller Jim Leonhard has not yet found the same rhythm.
Leonhard has been blunt about the problem, describing the unit as boom or bust after stretches that have mixed impact plays with too many lapses. The growing pains are not unexpected with a new voice in charge, but the Bills also know the margin for error narrows quickly if the defense keeps giving away yards, points and avoidable penalties while trying to settle in. [Read more 🡒]