When it comes to NFL draft prospects, the spotlight often shines on players from powerhouse programs. But let's not forget the hidden gems from smaller colleges who can make a big splash in the league.
The Buffalo Bills, like any team, could benefit from uncovering these diamonds in the rough. Let's dive into five underrated prospects from smaller schools who might just be the game-changers the Bills need.
Five Underrated Smaller College Prospects for 2026
1. OT Caden Barnett (Wyoming)
The Bills are in the market for offensive line depth, and Caden Barnett from Wyoming could be the answer. Standing tall at 6-foot-5 and weighing in at 320 pounds, Barnett is a powerhouse in the run-blocking department. He’s a master at double-teaming defenders and was the Mountain West's top-graded guard in 2025.
With veteran left tackle Dion Dawkins nearing 32 and no new contract in sight, Barnett could be groomed as the heir apparent. Plus, having another Wyoming alum to protect Josh Allen’s blindside feels like a match made in football heaven.
2. QB Cole Payton (North Dakota State)
Cole Payton is a unique quarterback prospect with a compelling story. This 6-foot-2, 233-pound lefty boasts a cannon for an arm and impressive mobility. His ability to throw in cold weather makes him an ideal fit for Buffalo’s climate.
In 2025, Payton led his team to a 12-1 record, amassing 2,719 passing yards and 16 touchdowns, while adding 777 rushing yards and 13 scores on the ground. Though raw, his size, athleticism, and maturity make him an intriguing prospect for teams needing a strong-armed QB in winter conditions.
3. WR Bryce Lance (North Dakota State)
Bryce Lance, younger brother of NFL QB Trey Lance, is carving his own path as a wide receiver. At North Dakota State, he was a go-to target for Payton, recording back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons. Lance concluded his college career with 25 touchdown receptions and 2,157 receiving yards, making a significant mark in the school’s history.
For the Bills, Lance could seamlessly transition to the new stadium, with its intimate atmosphere reminiscent of his college days.
4. S Emmanuel McNeil-Warren (Toledo)
Among small college prospects, Emmanuel McNeil-Warren stands out. Known for his height and presence on the field, he recorded 77 tackles, two interceptions, and three forced fumbles over three years. McNeil-Warren is a pro-ready safety who fits perfectly into a 3-4 defensive scheme, poised to cause chaos for ball carriers.
His knack for creating turnovers could make him a valuable asset in the NFL.
5. E Michael Heldman (Central Michigan)
Michael Heldman is a sack artist, plain and simple. At Central Michigan, he tallied 10.5 sacks, even taking down opponents from powerhouse programs like Penn State. Heldman’s ability to dominate against top-tier competition makes him a standout prospect.
Whether any of these small-college stars will don a Bills jersey or shine elsewhere in the NFL remains to be seen. But one thing’s for sure: they’ve got the potential to make a significant impact.