The Buffalo Bills don’t have to make a final call just yet, but when it comes to tight end Dalton Kincaid’s fifth-year option, the writing’s already on the wall.
General manager Brandon Beane didn’t mince words when asked about the team’s plans for Kincaid’s 2027 option, saying, “I don’t see any reason why we wouldn’t pick that up.” That’s about as close to a done deal as you’ll hear in late January.
And really, it’s hard to argue with the logic. Kincaid, still on his rookie deal, has shown enough flashes to warrant the projected $8.75 million price tag for that fifth year. In a league where tight ends are increasingly asked to be hybrid weapons - part receiver, part blocker, part matchup nightmare - Kincaid is trending in the right direction.
He’s currently heading into the third year of a four-year, $14.49 million rookie contract, which includes a $7.54 million signing bonus. His 2026 cap hit is set at just over $4.27 million, making the potential fifth-year option a manageable step up in cost, especially if his production continues to climb.
Let’s talk about that production. In 2025, Kincaid suited up for 12 games and made the most of his opportunities.
He hauled in 39 receptions on 49 targets - a strong catch rate - for 571 yards and five touchdowns. That’s 14.6 yards per catch, a number that jumps off the page for a tight end.
It’s not just about volume; it’s about impact. Kincaid has shown the ability to stretch the field and create mismatches, and that’s a valuable trait in today’s NFL.
Before arriving in Buffalo, Kincaid carved out a unique collegiate path. He started at San Diego, where he earned third-team All-American honors, then transferred to Utah and repeated the feat - a rare accomplishment across two programs.
He also picked up an honorable mention All-Pac-12 nod in 2021. That blend of production and adaptability helped make him the No. 25 overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft.
Now, the Bills are seeing the return on that investment. Kincaid’s route running, hands, and ability to find soft spots in coverage have made him a reliable option in the passing game - and there’s still plenty of room for growth. With another offseason to build chemistry and refine his game, the ceiling remains high.
So while the official decision on the fifth-year option won’t come for a few more months, Beane’s comments - and Kincaid’s performance - make it clear: the Bills have every reason to keep this connection going through 2027.