The Buffalo Bills have built one of the league’s most productive offenses, but the shine is hiding a problem that keeps popping up at the worst times.
Joe Brady was promoted to head coach after Sean McDermott was fired, and while Brady kept control of the play-calling, Buffalo still filled out the staff by hiring Pete Carmichael Jr. Carmichael, who had previously worked with Brady in New Orleans under Sean Payton and also spent time with the Denver Broncos under Payton, came aboard to help with game preparation. Even with that support, Brady remains the one calling the plays.
On the field, the results have been strong. Buffalo owns the NFL’s fourth-ranked offense, leads the league in scoring, and sits second in rushing with more than 150 yards per game.
The addition of DJ Moore to the receiving corps has helped, but the bigger reason for the unit’s success is continuity. James Cook has given the ground game real juice, and Josh Allen under center changes everything.
Still, the offense keeps shooting itself in the foot.
Nick Suss of ESPN pointed to Buffalo’s pre-snap issues as a major concern, noting that the Bills are averaging close to three pre-snap offensive penalties per game. As Suss wrote:
" Pre-snap sloppiness is a recurring problem. Between false starts, illegal shifts, delays of game, offsides and too many men in the huddle calls, the Bills are averaging close to three pre-snap offensive penalties per game, and that’s not to mention the 132 yards the Bills have had nullified by holding penalties."
The penalty problem goes beyond those pre-snap mistakes. Buffalo has not had a game with fewer than five penalties, and it has already had multiple games with 10 or more, whether those flags came before the snap or during the play. That kind of sloppiness can be masked for a while when a team is winning and making explosive plays, but it is not something that disappears on its own.
At 8-1, the Bills have been good enough to survive the mess. But they have done it by leaning on high-level execution and timely plays, and that kind of margin does not last forever. If the penalties keep piling up, Buffalo could end up paying for them in a way its offense can’t outrun.
In Other News...
Josh Allen Is Entering NFL Territory No Quarterback Ever Reaches
Josh Allen keeps pushing the bounds of what a quarterback is supposed to do, and the numbers are starting to look more like a running backs resume than a passers. He is tied for the NFL lead with 11 rushing touchdowns this season, and he already owns the league record for career rushing touchdowns by a quarterback, a mark that keeps moving further out of reach for anyone else at the position.
What makes the climb so unusual is where Allen sits on the broader list. With 90 career rushing touchdowns, he is tied for 14th all-time and stands as the only quarterback in the top 25, putting him in striking distance of territory usually reserved for the games most prolific backs. For Buffalo, it is another reminder that Allens value goes beyond the passing game, and that his place in NFL history is still being written in real time. [Read more 🡒]
Keon Coleman Just Gave Bills Fans Another Reason To Watch This Chase
The latest Topps Chrome Football release has given collectors and Bills fans a fresh subplot to follow, with the 2026 set arriving Nov. 18 and featuring PREM1ERE Patch autographed cards tied to the 2023 and 2024 rookie classes. Because the cards are issued as redemptions from seasons when Topps did not have the NFL license, the chase has a built-in layer of intrigue, and early pulls have already put some of the leagues most recognizable young names on the board.
Keon Coleman is among the rookies whose patch card has surfaced, joining a list that also includes Drake Maye, Caleb Williams and Xavier Legette. For Buffalo fans, it is another reminder that Colemans name is already showing up in one of the hobbys most watched products, and the next question is how many more of these premium pulls are still waiting to be found. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Defense Suddenly Has A New Dolphins Concern This Week
Miamis receiving group is suddenly looking a little deeper heading into its matchup with Buffalo, with Caleb Douglas and Chris Bell both expected to be available after limited practice work this week. The Dolphins official injury report and head coach Jeff Hafley pointed in that direction, which matters for a Bills defense that has already had to prepare for a moving target at receiver.
Jared Waynes status adds another layer of uncertainty after he missed recent practices with a quadriceps injury. Even with two wideouts trending toward playing, Buffalo still has to account for a Dolphins offense that could look different by kickoff, and that kind of late-week ambiguity is exactly the sort of thing defensive game plans have to absorb on the fly. [Read more 🡒]
