In one of the most surprising moves of the 2025 offseason, the Seattle Seahawks traded star wide receiver DK Metcalf to the Pittsburgh Steelers. Metcalf inked a hefty 4-year, $132 million deal with Pittsburgh, leaving fans of the Buffalo Bills wondering what might have been, given their glaring need for a top-tier receiver. Instead, Metcalf found himself in the competitive AFC North.
However, Metcalf's tenure in Pittsburgh might not be as long-lasting as many anticipated. ESPN's Dan Graziano and Ben Solak have pegged Metcalf as a top trade candidate this offseason, with the Bills mentioned as a potential landing spot. The Commanders and Patriots are also in the mix as possible destinations.
A key factor in this trade speculation is Metcalf's contract. When he signed last spring, his $25 million salary for 2026 was fully guaranteed. But an unfortunate two-game suspension for an altercation with a fan voided that guarantee, potentially easing a path for the Steelers to trade him if they choose.
The Steelers made a bold move acquiring Metcalf, subsequently trading away George Pickens to the Cowboys. Currently, Metcalf stands as their primary receiving threat. Despite his undeniable talent, Metcalf posted a career-low 850 receiving yards and six touchdowns in his first year with Pittsburgh, managing only two games with over 100 receiving yards.
From a financial standpoint, trading Metcalf might make sense, but letting go of a receiver in his prime is no easy decision. Just two seasons ago, he racked up over 1,100 yards with the Seahawks, showcasing his game-changing ability.
While the idea of Metcalf joining forces with Josh Allen in Buffalo is tantalizing, it's a long shot given the Steelers' current situation. They lack another standout receiver and are still working on solidifying their quarterback position. Mike McCarthy's arrival as head coach adds another layer of uncertainty to the mix.
Buffalo desperately needs a top target for Allen, and the Allen-Metcalf duo could wreak havoc in the AFC East. Yet, the Steelers are unlikely to part ways with Metcalf without a viable backup plan at wide receiver. As always in the NFL, surprises are never off the table, but this one seems particularly challenging to pull off.