Bills Get An Early Look At Clevelands Quarterback Battle

As the Browns prepare for preseason action, the starting quarterback decision between Deshaun Watson and Shedeur Sanders sparks debate and anticipation.

Deshaun Watson is getting the first turn in Cleveland’s preseason quarterback rotation, with the Browns announcing Wednesday that he will start Saturday’s opener against the Chicago Bears.

It will be Watson’s first game action since he tore his Achilles during the 2024 season, a return that has been a long time coming. The veteran has not taken a live snap since October 2024, when two separate Achilles ruptures ended most of two seasons.

“I’m super excited,” Watson said, according to the team’s website. “All the hard work that I put in with the training staff, with my team, my personal team, to get to this stage has been tremendous for me. So, I’m super excited for those opportunities and can’t wait for it.”

Cleveland’s plan calls for Watson to play the first half against Chicago and get a two-minute drill before handing things over to the rest of the quarterback room. Shedeur Sanders will get the same setup the following week, when he starts against the Buffalo Bills on Aug. 22.

The Browns are treating this as a controlled evaluation, but the outside conversation has already gotten louder. Former NFL quarterback Chris Simms has spent much of this week arguing that Cleveland should simply give Sanders the job, calling more reps for Watson pointless, according to ClutchPoints. ESPN analyst and former NFL executive Mike Tannenbaum also questioned why the Browns would keep prioritizing Watson’s starts over their younger quarterback this deep into camp.

Watson’s time in Cleveland has been defined by setbacks. Since the Browns landed him in a blockbuster 2022 trade and signed him to a fully guaranteed $230 million deal, he has dealt with a season-ending shoulder injury in 2023, the first Achilles tear in 2024 and then a second rupture while recovering. He appeared in just one game last season before that latest injury shut him down again.

Sanders, meanwhile, enters this stretch with momentum from his rookie season. He started Cleveland’s final seven games of 2025, throwing seven touchdowns against 10 interceptions and finishing with a 68.1 passer rating on a team that went 5-12. It wasn’t perfect, but it was enough to make him the fan favorite in this summer’s competition.

Head coach Todd Monken has continued to insist the battle is still alive, even with Watson taking the bulk of the first-team reps in recent days.

“I have my reasons for how it’s going to go, and it’s still a competition,” Monken said. “We’re excited to watch guys practice today, let alone on Saturday, and then next week against Buffalo, and we’ll get a chance to see them both.

Every week we’ll assess it. It’ll be a little bit more difficult with the player that doesn’t play as much this week or the other quarterbacks, right?

We’ll be able to assess the quarterback that started and how he played and when the other quarterbacks came in and then the opposite will be next week against Buffalo.”

That approach gives each quarterback the same basic stage: a first-half audition in one preseason game, plus a two-minute drill, with a joint practice against Buffalo the week of Aug. 20 offering one more chance to sort things out. Monken has said he expects a clearer read after both games, with Cleveland set to open the regular season against Jacksonville on Sept. 13.

For now, the Browns are sticking with their process. Watson goes first against Chicago, Sanders follows against Buffalo, and the competition keeps moving one series at a time.

In Other News...

Bills Injuries Just Created A Training Camp Battle To Watch

Training camp injuries have already forced the Bills to get busy on the defensive side, with Buffalo working out five players as the staff looks for answers before the regular season arrives. The group includes Anthony Kendall, BJ Mayes, Troy Pride, Cam Rice and Evan Anderson, a mix of defensive backs and linemen brought in to help create depth where the roster has been thinned out early.

Cornerback and nose tackle have been the most obvious spots under pressure, which is why these tryouts matter more than the usual late-summer look around. Buffalo is still sorting through which of these players can actually fit the need, and the camp competition now has an added layer with open jobs on the line and the defensive depth chart still taking shape. [Read more 🡒]

Ray Davis Is Pushing For A Bigger Bills Role Behind James Cook

Ray Davis spent his 2025 season making his biggest impact in a role that did not come with many offensive touches, but he still found a way to stand out for Buffalo. The second-year running back turned into one of the leagues most dangerous kickoff returners, leading the NFL in average yards per kickoff return and earning First-Team All-Pro honors, even as his opportunities behind James Cook remained limited.

Now healthy heading into 2026, Davis is trying to turn that special teams success into a bigger piece of the offense. For the Bills, the question is less about whether he has carved out value and more about how much more room there is for him in a backfield that already has a clear lead option. [Read more 🡒]

Brandon Beane Could Make One Tough Bills Roster Call Soon

Brandon Beane has never been shy about reshuffling the Bills roster in August, and that history is part of why this stretch can feel a little different in Buffalo. With the regular season still ahead, the front office is again weighing the kind of decisions that can shape the depth chart before the games count, and a handful of players have come up as possible names to watch based on role, fit and how the roster is built right now.

Among the candidates being discussed are Keon Coleman, Damar Hamlin, Geno Stone and Sedrick Van Pran-Granger, with the conversation leaning more toward roster math than any confirmed move. The Bills also have to account for injuries and shifting responsibilities up front, which makes these late-summer calls trickier than they look on paper. Beanes past August activity suggests he is willing to act if he sees a deal that helps, so this is one of those spots where the Bills may not be done sorting out the bottom of the roster just yet. [Read more 🡒]