Buffalo Bills fans have a clear favorite when it comes to who should take charge of the defense in 2026, and it’s not the player who has held that role the last couple of seasons.
In a recent Reacts poll, 71% of voters picked someone other than Terrel Bernard as the Bills’ defensive leader for the coming season. That doesn’t necessarily mean they think Bernard has lost his place in the leadership mix. It does suggest fans are looking elsewhere for the player they expect to set the tone, make the big play, and carry the most weight in the huddle.
The poll did not include the obvious top voice on the unit: first-time NFL defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard. He’s already one of the central leaders of the group, but the question was aimed at the player who will matter most on the field, whether or not he gets official captaincy.
Leonhard has praised Bernard in recent days, and Bernard has been the team’s official defensive leader under the previous setup. He wore the green dot, handling the play and coverage calls when available.
But with a regime change comes new arrangements, and it’s not yet clear whether Bernard keeps sole captaincy duties. Under Sean McDermott, Buffalo had one captain on offense and one on defense, with other leadership roles spread around.
On offense, that’s been Josh Allen.
The biggest share of the vote went to Bradley Chubb, who checked in at 33%. The free-agent addition arrived this offseason with a résumé built over years in the league, including his early development with the Denver Broncos under Von Miller. For Buffalo, he could end up filling the kind of steady, influential role that fans associate with a defense’s tone-setter.
Ed Oliver and Cole Bishop tied for second at 19% apiece. Oliver has long looked like the kind of defender who can take over a game, and he was off to a strong start last season before injuries wiped out most of his year.
If he can stay healthy, a comeback-player-of-the-year type season is in play. Bishop, meanwhile, is still young but brings elite physical traits.
After a rough start to his career, he picked things up in 2025, and Leonhard will be focused on getting the most out of him.
Bernard landed at 13%, a number that suggests some fans are unsure he’ll remain the central voice on defense. The injury concerns are real, and leading from the sideline is never easy. Still, if Bernard gets the right mix of health and luck, he could do plenty in Leonhard’s scheme.
Below him were Christian Benford at 9% and Greg Rousseau at 4%. Benford’s development after being a 2022 NFL Draft sixth-round pick has been one of the better stories on the roster, especially considering Buffalo was able to move on from Kaiir Elam, the first-round pick from that same draft.
Rousseau, despite finishing at the bottom of the poll, could be headed for a strong year in a system that may suit his size and skill set much better. He may not jump out as the loudest leader, but the Bills will be watching No. 15 closely.
The poll didn’t include C.J. Gardner-Johnson because of limits in the new polling setup, though his voice and reputation have always traveled with his play. Whether he becomes a real leadership presence in 2026 remains to be seen.
There was also a bonus AFC East question, and Bills fans were even more decisive there. Seventy-five percent picked Buffalo to win the division in 2026.
The defending AFC champion New England Patriots received 18% of the vote, a figure that may reflect what many saw as a soft 2025 schedule and some good fortune in last season’s playoff run. They avoided Josh Allen and the Bills in the postseason, though they did beat Buffalo in the regular season.
The Miami Dolphins and New York Jets barely registered in the voting, combining for just 7%. For now, at least in the eyes of fans, the AFC East still runs through Buffalo.
In Other News...
Josh Allen Just Turned A Classic Bills Joke Into Something Bigger
Josh Allen has long been one of the most recognizable faces around the Bills, but his latest off-field role pushes him into a different lane entirely. He is front and center in a New Era commercial for the companys 2026 NFL Sidelines Collection, appearing alongside Matthew Stafford and Micah Parsons, and the campaign fits neatly with a player whose image already carries plenty of weight in Buffalo and beyond.
The bigger wrinkle is that Allens relationship with the brand has moved well past a standard endorsement. He also took part in a charitable cap project tied to Oishei Childrens Hospital, adding a community angle to a partnership that already feels unusually personal. For a player whose name has become part of the Bills identity, this is the kind of off-field development that hints at something larger still taking shape. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Open Practice Put One Roster Concern Back In Focus
The Bills gave fans a first look at their new Highmark Stadium during an open practice that drew more than 41,000 people, a reminder of how much buzz still surrounds this team heading into the preseason stretch. It was also a useful football day, with cornerback Maxwell Hairston and safety Cole Bishop back on the field as Buffalo continued preparing for a joint session with the Browns and the preseason game that follows.
Even with those returns, the injury list kept pulling attention back to one of the rosters lingering concerns. Several notable names were missing, including wide receivers Khalil Shakir and Keon Coleman, along with defensive tackle Ed Oliver, leaving the Bills to work through depth questions while the group gets ready for a week that should offer a clearer read on where things stand. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Secondary Just Got A Break Before Week 1
A major injury in Houston has already altered the early landscape for the Bills AFC competition, with Texans wide receiver Jayden Higgins suffering a torn ACL during a joint practice with the Raiders and set to miss the entire 2026 season. The second-year receiver was a key part of Houstons offense last year after arriving as a 2025 second-round pick, giving the Texans a legitimate downfield option and another piece defenses had to account for.
Now the Texans will have to reshape that part of their passing game before the season even begins, with Xavier Hutchinson among the players expected to absorb more of the workload. For Buffalo, it is a reminder that the road through the AFC can change quickly, even in August, when one injury can force a contender to rethink how it attacks a secondary. [Read more 🡒]