ORCHARD PARK, N.Y. - Highmark Stadium’s first game on its new grass came with a few rough patches, and not just the kind you expect in preseason.
Late in the first quarter of Saturday’s opener against the Carolina Panthers, backup quarterback Kyle Allen was forced toward the sideline, slid, and then took a hard hit from cornerback Chau Smith-Wade. The impact ripped up a huge chunk of turf, roots and dirt flying into the air.
The divot was so severe that four Bills went out to help fix it. Josh Allen, DJ Moore, Dion Dawkins and Spencer Brown all got involved, scooping up the displaced grass and stomping it back down.
One player who didn’t want to be identified didn’t exactly sugarcoat the scene: “The field is ass right now,” he said. “But it’s early.”
That was the mood around Buffalo’s 29-14 preseason win in the $2.2 billion building. Players were careful not to pile on, even though the surface clearly had issues as the game unfolded.
The stadium had already been under a microscope before kickoff. During the Aug. 8 open practice, season ticket holders - who had to pay the first personal seat licenses in Western New York sports history - got their first look at the new place.
Instead of a clean debut, the public got viral photos of obstructed views, complaints about the canopy not fully shielding fans from a downpour, gripes about traffic, the size of the scoreboards and the audio. On top of that, the newly announced 6 percent Erie County sales tax made concession and souvenir prices sting even more.
Buffalo’s grass setup is supposed to be a point of pride. The field is Kentucky bluegrass grown at Tuckahoe Turf Farms in New Jersey, the same company that has handled surfaces at Acrisure Stadium, Lincoln Financial Field, Fenway Park and Citi Field.
It was installed in October 2025, and heating coils beneath the stadium help keep the ground from freezing. The team also stores millions of dollars in agricultural equipment under the lower seating bowl.
Even so, the field was already showing wear before the game started. It looked beaten down before warmups, and Bills tight end Dalton Kincaid had to flag down a staffer to repair a troublesome divot while linebacker Terrel Bernard watched. As receivers worked through route drills on the damaged area, a staffer eventually stood over the spot like a traffic cop.
By the time the game wore on, the surface had gotten worse. Officials had to reset Buffalo’s play clock in the first quarter so umpire Tab Slaughter could press down loose soil in the backfield.
By halftime, the south end of the field - to the right if you’re sitting behind the Bills bench - had started to turn bald between the hashmarks. In the fourth quarter, several small craters had opened up between the 14- and 21-yard lines.
Long snapper Reid Ferguson even had to stomp down one of them before an extra point.
Still, the players weren’t all negative. Dorian Williams said, “The grass looked good,” adding, “It was cool. A couple spots kind of chunked up a little bit, but it’s better than playing on (artificial) turf.
“The kinks will keep getting worked out. You can see some of the grass kind of mound up and guys knocking it back down, but I’ve had no traction problems so far.”
Running back James Cook also seemed comfortable on it. He called the field “smooth” and finished with five carries for 21 yards, including one 13-yard run where he looked like he never missed a beat. Tyler Bass, meanwhile, missed a 46-yard field goal attempt but said he was too quick with his mechanics and didn’t blame the conditions.
Panthers running back Jonathon Brooks also gave the surface a fairly tame review. Buffalo’s last game on real grass - even if it was sparse - came in December 1972 at War Memorial Stadium, known as The Rockpile.
“It was actually pretty good,” Brooks said. “It was a little lumpy out there, but it wasn’t bad. The grass felt good.”
The debate over grass versus synthetic turf has been a major one around the league. Carolina is among 14 teams that play on artificial surfaces, and the NFL Players Association has pushed for grass because of safety concerns. The NFLPA says 92 percent of its players prefer grass, and some stars have posted their views on social media with the hashtag #WorthTheCost.
Buffalo’s old synthetic surface earned an F grade from Bills players in the NFLPA’s annual report card last year.
The issue has only grown louder since the FIFA World Cup used 11 NFL stadiums and forced the seven synthetic-surfaced venues to install natural grass. Those stadiums have since gone back to NFL turf for the regular season. Gillette Stadium, home of the New England Patriots, even had to lay down a second artificial surface after its first World Cup setup failed an independent lab test required by the NFL and NFLPA.
For Williams, though, the preference is obvious. “I think everybody in here loves playing on grass,” he said.
“The body loves playing on grass. Hitting feels a lot better.
I think it’s been great.”
In Other News...
Josh Allen's Response To Joe Brady's First Bills Misstep Stood Out
The Bills preseason win over Carolina offered plenty of signs the offense is moving in the right direction, but one of the quieter moments came on the sideline when rookie head coach Joe Brady had to navigate an early game-management hiccup. It was the kind of misstep that can happen in August, especially for a coach still settling into a new job, and Buffalos strong showing on offense helped keep the bigger picture front and center.
Josh Allens reaction stood out because it kept the focus on accountability rather than embarrassment, a small but telling detail from a game that otherwise went smoothly for Buffalo. Brady still has two more preseason games to sharpen his feel for those moments before the regular season begins, and for the Bills, the episode was a reminder that the learning curve for a new coach can show up even in a win. [Read more 🡒]
Tyler Bass Just Gave Bills Fans A Real Week 1 Question
Tyler Bass was back on the field in a preseason game, giving Bills fans their first real look at the kicker after he spent the entire 2025 season sidelined by hip and groin injuries. The return itself mattered as much as the box score: Bass handled the pressure of game action again, connected on three field goals and two extra points, and showed he could still be part of the teams kicking plans heading into the regular season.
There was still a reminder that this is a work in progress. Bass said he felt good about getting back out there, but also pointed to areas he wants to clean up before the games start counting, and one midrange miss left a little bit of unease in the air. For Buffalo, the larger question is not whether Bass can put points on the board in August, but how close he is to being the steady answer they need once the season opens. [Read more 🡒]