The Buffalo Bills didn’t leave MetLife Stadium with much room for debate after a 31-12 win over the New York Jets, but the national power rankings still found a way to split on them. Heading into Week 11, Buffalo sits in a familiar place near the top of the NFL conversation, with four of the eight tracked outlets putting the Bills at No. 1 and the other four slotting them at No. 2.
That tug-of-war kept Buffalo’s average ranking right where it was a week ago: 1.50.
One of the more notable swings came from ESPN and Sports Illustrated. ESPN moved the Bills down from first to second after Sunday’s win, while Sports Illustrated pushed them up from third to second. So even after a comfortable divisional victory, the Bills still managed to inspire two very different reactions.
ESPN’s drop stands out the most. Buffalo didn’t exactly look shaky in the box score: 31 points, 389 yards of offense, and a defense that kept the Jets out of the end zone. But the Bills also left some meat on the bone, converting just two of 10 third-down chances and allowing New York to string together several long possessions.
Even so, Buffalo found plenty of answers when it mattered. The Bills put together three second-half touchdown drives that covered just seven plays and 2:49 of possession. James Cook led the ground game with 157 rushing yards and a 74-yard touchdown, while DJ Moore added 90 receiving yards and a score.
That’s the kind of performance that reminds you power rankings are never just about the final score. Voters weigh the bigger picture, the quality of the opponent, and how a team stacks up against the rest of the league’s heavyweights. Still, moving a team down after a 19-point divisional win is enough to make people look twice.
USA Today, meanwhile, has been coming around on Buffalo in a big way. The Bills opened Week 8 at No. 9, climbed to No. 6 entering Week 9, then jumped four spots to No. 2 heading into Week 10. After the Jets win, USA Today kept Buffalo at No. 2 for Week 11.
That steady rise says plenty about how the Bills are being viewed now. They may not have unanimous support for the top spot, but they’ve clearly forced their way into the center of the national picture.
The contrast with Miami couldn’t be sharper. Buffalo’s Week 11 opponent is sliding in the other direction, with the Dolphins taking a hit across the rankings.
USA Today dropped Miami from No. 27 to No. 32, FOX Sports had them last, and ESPN, NFL.com, and CBS Sports each put them at No.
That’s the kind of gap that makes this AFC East matchup look lopsided on paper. Buffalo is getting serious top-team treatment. Miami is being treated like one of the league’s bottom-tier clubs.
Of course, divisional games have a way of ignoring all of that once kickoff arrives. The Bills can’t afford to let the rankings do the talking for them.
For now, the bigger question isn’t whether Buffalo belongs among the NFL’s elite. That part seems settled. The real test is whether the Bills can keep proving they deserve to be seen as the best of the bunch.
In Other News...
Bills Suddenly Have A Secondary Concern At The Worst Time
The Bills secondary is suddenly dealing with some late-week uncertainty at exactly the wrong time. Buffalos Wednesday injury report had five players sitting out, and the most notable names were cornerbacks Christian Benford, who is dealing with a groin issue, and Dee Alford, who is in concussion protocol. For a defense that needs to be sharp heading into a Week 11 matchup with the Dolphins, any wobble in the back end is worth watching closely.
There was at least one bit of good news for Buffalo on the roster front, as Tyrell Shavers was activated off the PUP list and is expected to make his season debut. Even so, the bigger storyline remains how the Bills sort through their defensive backfield if the injury situation lingers into the weekend. Against Miami, depth and communication in coverage can turn into a real test fast. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Finally Give A Franchise Legend The Honor Fans Wanted
The Bills are finally giving Andre Reed the kind of long-awaited recognition many fans felt he had earned years ago. Buffalo announced it will retire Reeds No. 83 during the 2027 season, adding the Hall of Fame receiver to a select group of franchise greats who have already been honored in that way. Reed spent his entire Buffalo career from 1985 to 1999 and still stands atop the teams record book in receiving yards and touchdowns.
It is the sort of move that feels overdue for a player whose name is woven into the franchises identity. Reed will join three other Hall of Fame teammates with retired numbers, a reminder of just how central that era was to the Bills history. The timing gives the organization a chance to celebrate one of its most important players in a season that should bring plenty of nostalgia for fans who watched him build his legacy in Buffalo. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Fans Have A New Concern In The Secondary Before Miami
Amani Hookers name on Wednesdays practice report added another layer of concern for a Bills secondary already dealing with plenty of moving parts. The safety was listed as limited because of a knee injury he picked up in Week 10, and Buffalos injury list also included several other players who did not practice for various reasons as the team turned its attention to Miami.
With the Dolphins coming to town in Week 11, the Bills are watching the defensive backfield closely as they try to get through the week without any more setbacks. Hookers availability will be one of the key things to monitor, especially with Buffalo trying to keep its secondary intact against a division opponent that can stress it in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]
