Bills Bubble Players Are Making Buffalos Final Roster Decisions Tougher

In a commanding preseason display, the Buffalo Bills highlighted their depth and strategic prowess, overshadowing the Browns while spotlighting several standout performances and potential roster shifts.

The Buffalo Bills put together another convincing preseason showing Friday, rolling past the Cleveland Browns 31-7 and turning a tight game into a runaway after halftime.

Buffalo led 14-7 at the break, and once the second half opened, the Bills seized complete control. The game had been delayed by weather just two minutes in, but that didn’t slow Buffalo down. After a 29-14 win over the Panthers last week, the Bills are now 2-for-2 in the preseason with double-digit victories and will head into next Thursday’s finale against the Pittsburgh Steelers with plenty to build on.

A handful of players helped drive the win, while a couple others didn’t do themselves any favors.

Kyle Allen kept making his case

Kyle Allen followed up last week’s strong outing against Carolina with another efficient performance. Against Cleveland, he looked the part of a starter, completing 10 of 12 passes for 128 yards and a touchdown late in the first half. With Josh Allen entrenched at the top of the depth chart, these two preseason games have gone a long way toward locking Kyle Allen into the QB2 role.

Joe Andreessen made plays all over the field

Joe Andreessen has already carved out a role on special teams, but he added some real defensive pop against the Browns. He was around the ball constantly, and when he wasn’t finishing the tackle, he was disrupting the play. His pass breakup led to the interception Damar Hamlin turned into the game’s biggest swing, helping Buffalo blow it open.

Damar Hamlin took his chance

Hamlin was in the thick of it on defense, tying for the team lead in total tackles while also intercepting Shedeur Sanders. He may still be viewed primarily as a special teams player with some safety snaps mixed in, but this was the kind of night that strengthens his case in a crowded safety room.

Trent Sherfield and Ja'Mori Maclin kept pressure on the receiver battle

With Skyler Bell and Dante Pettis out, Trent Sherfield stepped up and delivered a solid night, finishing with four catches for 54 yards, including a 20-yard grab from Kyle Allen. He’s still pushing for that final receiver spot, and performances like this help.

Ja'Mori Maclin also made his mark. While it would be a surprise to see him make the final roster, he was Buffalo’s leading receiver on the day and hauled in a 71-yard touchdown from Shane Buechele. If nothing else, he strengthened his case to return to the practice squad.

Tommy Doman Jr. and Tyler Bass got clean nights

Rookie punter Tommy Doman Jr. finally got a chance to show what his leg can do after Buffalo’s first preseason game ended without a punt. He delivered three punts for 129 yards, averaged 43 yards per kick, and placed two inside the Browns’ red zone. That’s a strong step in the competition with Mitch Wishnowsky.

Tyler Bass also answered after last week’s missed 45-yard field goal. He nailed a 52-yard attempt and went 4-for-4 on extra points, giving himself a useful confidence boost heading into the preseason finale.

A couple players left with more questions

Mecole Hardman Jr. did not make a strong push for the 53-man roster. He was targeted five times but caught only two passes for 15 yards and added just four rushing yards. Unless he can separate himself on special teams, he could be in real danger when cuts come at the end of the month.

Rookie offensive tackle Jude Bowry also had a rough day. The Boston College product saw early action, but he gave up several pass rushes that left Kyle Allen chased down or sacked. He still has a long climb ahead before he can be considered a real starting candidate beyond 2026.

In Other News...

Bills Fans Got Another Ugly Reminder About Deshaun Watson

The Browns 31-7 loss to the Bills in their second preseason game of 2026 brought another rough night for Deshaun Watson, and another reminder of how quickly the attention around him can shift from the field to everything around it. Watson completed five of 12 passes for 36 yards with one interception, a line that did little to quiet the scrutiny that has followed him through his time in Cleveland and into another preseason setting.

Bills fans had plenty to enjoy from the lopsided game, but the bigger conversation afterward centered on Watsons reaction to boos from the crowd and the way he handled the moment. His comments about fan behavior drew immediate notice, and the postgame buzz only grew when Shannon Sharpe weighed in on Watsons appearance during a media show, keeping the spotlight on a quarterback who seems to generate reaction wherever he goes. [Read more 🡒]

Josh Allen's Reaction Says Everything About Bills' Ed Oliver Controversy

Ed Olivers personal loss had been kept private through the spring and early summer as the Bills and the defensive tackle tried to give him space to grieve away from the public eye. But after the story of his two-year-old sons death in June was published before Oliver or the team was ready to address it, the news quickly shifted from a private family matter to a public controversy around privacy and timing.

Josh Allens reaction reflected how deeply the situation landed inside the locker room. The Bills quarterback said he was saddened and angry that the news became public before Olivers family could share it on their own terms, while also thanking the people who had respected their wishes. It was a reminder that beyond the football side of Buffalos season, there are still human moments that demand more care than a headline can give. [Read more 🡒]

James Cook Faces A Bills Debate That Could Define The Run Game

Buffalos ground game has become one of the defining parts of the offense, and James Cook sits right at the center of it. The Bills led the NFL last season in rushing attempts, yards and touchdowns, with Cook pacing the league in rushing yards while also setting career highs in carries, rushing yards and offensive snaps. He followed that production by making the Pro Bowl for a third straight season, and after signing a four-year, $46 million extension before last season, he has firmly established himself as a major piece of what the Bills want to do.

The question now is how much more of that load the Bills should keep putting on him. Cooks rising workload comes with real concern about durability after such a sharp increase in touches, especially for a back whose style and importance make him central to the run games identity. And while his contract status gives Buffalo some long-term clarity, the balance between maximizing his production and protecting him from wear and tear could end up shaping not just his season, but the way the entire offense is built. [Read more 🡒]