The Buffalo Bills have spent the summer piling up wins and piling up tough choices, and the roster squeeze is only getting tighter. With cutdown day on the horizon, the most uncomfortable decision may be hiding in plain sight: the running back room.
James Cook III is locked in at the top. Ray Davis and Ty Johnson already give Buffalo proven options behind him.
Add fullback Ben VanSumeren into the mix, and there may be room for only one more traditional back. That has turned the battle between Frank Gore Jr and Ian Wheeler into one of the most important fights on the roster.
Buffalo’s preseason has given the front office plenty to like. The Bills opened exhibition play with a 29-14 win over the Carolina Panthers in their new venue, then followed it with a 31-7 rout of the Cleveland Browns after resting nearly the entire starting lineup.
On defense, the new Base 3-4 has been suffocating, holding opponents to an average of fewer than 200 total yards per game. But all that depth has created a problem: several legitimate NFL-caliber players simply won’t fit.
That’s why the Gore-Wheeler decision has become so thorny. Gore has built real momentum as a fan favorite, but Wheeler’s explosiveness has made this a true two-man race for what may be the final offensive roster spot.
The case for Gore is straightforward. He runs with a decisive, north-south style and looks for the right crease without wasting motion.
He runs low, absorbs contact well, and his vision helps him salvage yards when the blocking isn’t clean. He also brings trust in pass protection, which matters on obvious passing downs.
Coaches know where he’ll be and what he’ll do, and that kind of reliability keeps the whole offense intact.
Wheeler offers a different kind of appeal. His track-level speed can turn a routine carry into something much bigger, especially if he gets a lane on the edge.
He can make the defense cover far more grass than it expected to defend, and that kind of acceleration is hard to create any other way. He also brings a path to special teams, which matters when teams are sorting out the bottom of the roster.
So Buffalo is left with a clean but brutal contrast: Gore brings certainty, Wheeler brings upside.
The problem is that the Bills may not be able to simply tuck the loser onto the practice squad. Both backs have shown enough in preseason to make waiver-wire exposure risky.
Another team looking for cheap backfield help could easily pounce. That would mean Buffalo could lose a real contributor for nothing.
Brandon Beane and Joe Brady have talked about competition and versatility, but cutdown day leaves no room for sentiment. The Bills may have to use that spot on an offensive lineman, a defensive piece, or another special-teams player instead.
If they keep Gore, they know exactly what they’re getting. If they keep Wheeler, they’re betting on a trait that can tilt games in a hurry.
That’s what makes this one so painful. Buffalo has enough talent to make hard calls. The running back room may force the hardest one of all.
In Other News...
Bills May Face An Unpopular Decision On A Local Fan Favorite
The Bills are down to their last preseason test before roster cutdowns, and one of the quieter battles on the depth chart has turned into a meaningful one. ESPNs Alaina Getzenberg recently projected Buffalos final roster, and the linebacker group has one of those uncomfortable decisions teams prefer to avoid: choosing between Joe Andreessen and Keonta Jenkins for what could be the last available spot.
Andreessen brings a different kind of pressure to the conversation because he is a local Buffalo player and a fan favorite, which makes his situation especially easy to follow around Western New York. Since arriving as an undrafted free agent in 2024, he has had to fight for every bit of ground, and the final preseason game could matter a lot for his chances, particularly with special teams work in the mix. [Read more 🡒]
Ja'Mori Maclin Just Made Buffalo's Final WR Decision Much Tougher
Ja'Mori Maclin turned a preseason opportunity into a real conversation for Buffalo, breaking loose for 108 receiving yards and a touchdown on just two catches. For an undrafted receiver trying to carve out a place on a crowded roster, that kind of burst matters, especially when it comes with the kind of attention from quarterback Shane Buechele that points to more than a one-night flash.
Joe Brady has also taken notice of the work Maclin put in during the offseason, even while dealing with injuries, and that matters in a camp battle where every practice rep can tilt the evaluation. The Bills still have decisions to make at receiver, but Maclins performance made the picture a lot less straightforward than it looked before kickoff. [Read more 🡒]
Bills Face Growing New Stadium Backlash From Frustrated PSL Holders
Some Bills fans who bought Personal Seat Licenses for the new stadium are finding out that not every seat comes with the view they expected, and the team is now dealing with complaints about obstructed sight lines in certain sections. Buffalo is handling those concerns case by case, while also pointing out that the seating limitations were part of the original design and were disclosed to buyers before they made their purchases.
Still, the issue has left a subset of PSL holders frustrated enough to keep pushing back, even as the Bills try to manage expectations and smooth things over ahead of the buildings opening. With the architect confirming the obstructions were intentional, the dispute has shifted from whether the views are real to how the team and its fans move forward from here. [Read more 🡒]