Bills Are Riding James Cook Harder Than Fans May Realize

As James Cook becomes the backbone of the Bills' ground game, the team faces a critical decision on balancing his impressive performance with long-term sustainability.

ORCHARD PARK - The Bills have a problem most teams would love to have: their best offensive weapon is doing so much work that the next question is how to keep him fresh.

That’s where James Cook enters Sunday’s matchup with the Miami Dolphins. If Buffalo gets the kind of early cushion it should against the 1-8 Dolphins, the Bills may finally have a chance to ease off the throttle and give their fifth-year running back a lighter day.

Cook has been carrying the load all season, and the numbers show just how heavy that load has become. He ranks second in the NFL behind only Detroit’s Jahmyr Gibbs in rushing yards per game at 107.9, in rushes that produce first downs with 50, and in attempts per game at 20.9. That last figure is the one that should have Buffalo thinking about preservation as much as production.

He has already piled up 187 carries through nine games after finishing with 309 in 2025, a massive jump from his previous high of 237 in 2023. On his current pace, he’s headed for 353 attempts.

That would put him in rare territory. Jonathan Taylor led the NFL in 2025 with 323 carries, and the last back to top 353 was Derrick Henry in 2020, when he logged 378 on his way to 2,027 yards.

Before that, DeMarco Murray had 392 for Dallas in 2014.

The Bills have seen heavy workloads before, but Cook’s usage is still pushing into notable company. Thurman Thomas owns the franchise record with 355 carries in 1993, while O.J.

Simpson had 332 in 1973, the season he became the NFL’s first 2,000-yard runner. Their per-game averages were higher than Cook’s, but the point remains the same: Buffalo is leaning hard on him.

That’s why the Bills would love to get Ray Davis and Ty Johnson more involved if Sunday turns into a blowout. Those two have combined for just 23 rushing attempts this season, and every carry they take is one Cook doesn’t have to absorb. If Buffalo doesn’t start creating those breathers, the question becomes what he’ll have left when January arrives.

Joe Brady didn’t spend much time answering directly when asked about Cook’s workload. He simply said, “We're mindful of a lot of guys” and noted that part of that approach is trimming practice reps for some players and saving them for games.

Cook, who ran for 157 yards on 18 carries against the Jets, was asked in the locker room whether he’s doing anything to handle the extra work. His answer was short and to the point: “Taking care of my body.”

Not everyone around him sounds worried. Left guard Alec Anderson was asked about the Bills’ reliance on Cook and didn’t see a problem with it.

“Man, we'll ride him all the way, dude,” Anderson said with a smile while center Connor McGovern nodded and smiled one locker stall away. “I don't see anything wrong with it.

Stature-wise he’s a little smaller, but he runs physical and he runs hard. I think Jimbo's got some wear and tear, but at the same time, I think Jimbo has that mindset of like, ‘(Screw) it, we ball,’ and I think that’s the mindset that the entire offense has, and so we’re just going to keep on doing it.”

Cook has had 15 career games with at least 20 carries, and six of them have come this season. His 31 carries against the Vikings in Week 9 were one shy of his career high of 32, set in 2025 against the Steelers. Buffalo has won 13 of those 15 games, with the only losses coming against the Eagles last year and the Texans in 2024.

Even in games where the Bills have had room to breathe, Cook hasn’t exactly been resting in the fourth quarter. Buffalo has played only five one-score games, yet Cook leads the NFL by a wide margin in fourth-quarter rushing yards with 378 and also tops the league in yards per carry at 6.9.

If you strip away his 74-yard touchdown run last week in New York, he still has 304 fourth-quarter rushing yards, which is 86 more than Gibbs, who has played one fewer game. Even without that burst, his 5.6 yards per carry would still lead the league.

Josh Allen made it clear the Bills know exactly what they have in Cook.

“He wants it,” Allen said. “There's no doubt about it, he's doing a great job of making sure that he's in the training room, getting extra work, and we got to make sure we're protecting him as well.

The more touches that we can get him, the better we're going to be. Yeah, we’ve got James Cook.

Go run.”

In Other News...

Chiefs Kicking Drama Just Put A Familiar Name Back On Bills Radar

Kansas Citys kicking situation has become a storyline worth watching, and it has a name Bills fans know well. Harrison Butker has missed several field goals this season, including a rough stretch on longer tries, even as the Chiefs have publicly stuck with him and added Justin Tucker to the practice squad.

Now the Chiefs have also worked out free agent Matt Prater, a veteran with a long track record of making kicks from deep range. For Buffalo, that kind of move is the sort of familiar AFC subplot that can matter later, especially if Kansas City decides it needs more certainty at the position. [Read more 🡒]

Bills Just Got An Unexpected Midseason Boost At Wide Receiver

The Bills are getting a midseason lift at wide receiver with Tyrell Shavers set to come off Injured Reserve after missing the season with a torn ACL. Head coach Joe Brady announced the move in a press conference, and it gives Buffalo another healthy option at a position group that always has room for useful, versatile depth this time of year.

Shavers is not being brought back just to fill a jersey. Buffalo expects him to help as a blocker, on special teams and as a receiving threat, which makes his return especially valuable as the team tries to keep its offense and coverage units balanced. For a roster that has had to manage injuries and shuffle roles along the way, getting a player back who can contribute in multiple phases is the kind of quiet boost that can matter later. [Read more 🡒]

Bills Quietly Found Roster Help In Three Crucial Spots

Late preseason additions rarely move the needle this quickly, but the Bills have gotten real mileage out of a few under-the-radar moves. Greg Gaines has settled into the defensive line rotation and is drawing enough attention to force opponents to account for him, while Greg Dortch has given Buffalo a useful spark as both a receiver and return man. Through the first nine games, both have already become part of the weekly plan rather than just depth pieces waiting in the wings.

Amani Hooker adds another layer to that quietly productive stretch, giving the Bills a fresh piece in the secondary after the trade deadline. He has already moved into a full-time role, which is exactly the kind of immediate integration Buffalo needed as the season has worn on. For a team trying to keep its roster balanced across all three phases, those kinds of additions can matter just as much as the bigger headlines. [Read more 🡒]