The loudest criticism after the Yankees finished off the Red Sox on Wednesday, Sept. 30, pointed straight at Boston’s supposed devotion to analytics. But the numbers told a different story.
The move everyone fixated on came in Game 2 of the American League wild-card series, when Red Sox manager Chad Tracy pulled Sonny Gray with two outs in the fifth inning. Boston was clinging to a 1-0 deficit, two runners were aboard, and left-handed reliever Erik Miller was summoned. The next hitter, Cody Bellinger, lined a single that drove in a run and pushed New York ahead 2-0.
That sequence sparked the big question around Boston and beyond: why take Gray out there?
The problem is that question misses the point. By the publicly available data, Gray looked like the right pitcher to leave in the game.
The Yankees had already turned the lineup over, and Bellinger, a left-handed bat, was coming up for the third time against the right-handed Gray in a high-leverage spot. That sort of situation has long been the kind that modern baseball decision-making tries to manage.
But in this case, the analytics didn’t point toward a change. Gray’s curveball and sinker were working well, according to advanced Quality of Pitch data.
He had also used those same pitches against Bellinger in June, and the results then were three swinging strikes and a foul tip. On top of that, Gray’s third-time-through numbers in 2026 were actually his best of the season, with a third-time-through xwOBA of .231, better than his first two trips through opposing lineups.
So the data-backed case was to keep Gray on the mound, not to go to the bullpen. Tracy, by pulling him, was the one going against the numbers.
“We're trailing. We're struggling to score runs,” Tracy said after the game. “And when you get in spots where you’re struggling to score runs and you're already trailing, you feel like you've got to be aggressive and go.”
That was Tracy’s explanation, and he admitted it was a feel-based decision. Still, the aftermath brought a wave of analysis blaming Boston for leaning too hard on analytics, with some coverage also pointing to the influence of Driveline, which consulted the Red Sox on R&D initiatives until earlier this year.
If anything, the numbers say the Red Sox didn’t trust the data enough when the game was on the line.
In Other News...
Red Sox Offseason Depth Faces One Big Test After Likely Departures
The Red Sox are heading into the offseason with a familiar kind of roster question, one that starts with the players they may be losing before it gets to who can fill the gaps. Patrick Sandoval, Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Sonny Gray are all in line to test free agency, and Boston already has some internal answers to lean on, including Anthony Seigler as a possible replacement for Kiner-Falefa and a handful of left-handed arms that could help cover for Sandoval.
Sonny Gray is the one situation that may carry the most long-term weight for Bostons depth chart. His mutual option for 2027 is unlikely to be picked up, which adds another layer to a right-handed pitching picture the Red Sox will have to sort out carefully. Even with some stopgap options in-house, the real test this winter may be whether the organization can keep its pitching depth balanced without leaning too heavily on short-term fixes. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Face A Defining Winter With Adley Rutschman
The Red Sox are heading into a winter that could say plenty about how they see the next phase of the roster, with Sonny Grays mutual option likely to be declined and attention turning to a much bigger piece of business behind the plate. Adley Rutschman, acquired in a trade during the 2026 season, has fit well in Boston and has already given the club the kind of defensive stability teams usually spend years searching for at catcher.
Rutschman is under team control for one more season before reaching free agency, which makes this the kind of offseason that can shape the direction of the lineup for years, not months. If Boston wants to keep him beyond 2027, the safest path is to start extension talks now, because a catcher with his profile and value does not tend to linger on the market once the clock starts ticking. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Could Be Headed For A Major Outfield Reset
The Red Sox are again staring at an offseason that could reshape the balance of their roster, and this one starts in the outfield. Bostons current mix still leaves questions about depth and fit, so the idea on the table is to add a more established presence there while also protecting the bullpen, a department that could use help if the club wants to tighten up late-game innings next season.
One proposed path would have Boston pursuing Seattles Randy Arozarena in free agency while moving Jarren Duran to San Diego for reliever Jeremiah Estrada, with Tyrone Taylor mentioned as another option to bolster defense and give the lineup more flexibility. It is the kind of aggressive reset that would signal real urgency from the Red Sox, but it also comes with the kind of roster tradeoffs that make the rest of the winter worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]