Yankees Catcher Failure Looks Even Worse After This Deadline Decision

Despite interest in Adley Rutschman, the Yankees' caution at the trade deadline allowed the Red Sox to swoop in and snag the highly-touted catcher.

The Yankees left the trade deadline without a new catcher, and that opened the door for the Red Sox to land Adley Rutschman.

New York had interest in the three-time All-Star backstop, but the price tag apparently pushed them in another direction. According to The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal, the Yankees could have blocked Rutschman from ending up in Boston if they were willing to move major league talent.

"The Yankees tried for impact relievers, according to people briefed on the discussions," Rosenthal wrote about New York's trade deadline. "They could have prevented Adley Rutschman from going to the Red Sox if they were willing to part with a package heavy on major-league talent. They even talked to the Toronto Blue Jays about right-handed starter Kevin Gausman."

Boston got the deal done with the Orioles by sending four minor league prospects, a route the Yankees apparently were not eager to take. Rosenthal also noted that "the combination of a thin bullpen market and a depleted farm system compromised the Yankees' pursuits."

Instead of making that kind of splash behind the plate, the Yankees addressed other needs by trading for Luis Garcia Jr. and Heliot Ramos, two bats aimed at strengthening the lineup.

Austin Wells has hit much better over the last few months, but New York still seemed to be weighing the larger picture at catcher. Another option was clearly on the radar, yet the front office couldn’t find the right trade partner.

Rutschman’s start in Boston has been rough so far. In 59 plate appearances with the Red Sox, he is hitting .170/.254/.245 with one home run and a .500 OPS.

In Other News...

Red Sox Suddenly Have A Big Rotation Question Against Seattle

The Red Sox have their first and third starters lined up for the upcoming series against Seattle, with Payton Tolle set for Monday and Patrick Sandoval following on Wednesday. For a team trying to keep its pitching plan steady as the schedule moves forward, that at least gives Boston some clarity at the front and back end of the matchup.

Sonny Gray, though, is still missing from the announced plan for Tuesday, which leaves a familiar veteran-sized question hanging over the middle game. Boston could still slot him in if hes available, or go a different direction altogether, but for now the rotation picture against the Mariners remains only partially drawn in. [Read more 🡒]

Red Sox Rotation Plan Around Sonny Gray Just Got More Interesting

With Roman Anthony and Trevor Story back from the injured list, the Red Sox are trying to sort out the rest of their roster with the postseason in view, and that means the pitching plan is getting careful attention. Boston has been balancing the health of its arms while also trying to make sure the club is in the best possible shape for October, a stretch when every start and every recovery day matters a little more.

Sonny Gray has been central to that thinking. After putting together a career-high 16 wins with a 2.82 ERA, his next start is being pushed back to Sept. 5 as the Red Sox look to preserve his arm and manage workloads across the staff. With roster expansion also giving the team more flexibility, Boston appears ready to use every tool it has to keep its rotation lined up for the games that matter most. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Just Turned To A Familiar Ex-Red Sox Arm Again

The Yankees are leaning on a familiar arm again, claiming right-hander John Schreiber off waivers from the Royals as they continue to patch together their pitching staff. Schreiber, 32 and headed toward free agency, gave Kansas City a solid season with a 3.65 ERA in 55 appearances, and he already has some experience in the division from his time with the Red Sox.

For Boston observers, the move is another reminder of how often useful bullpen pieces can resurface in the AL East in a hurry. New York did not need to clear a spot for Schreiber after designating Justin Topa for assignment, which makes the addition an easy one for the Yankees and a notable one for a former Red Sox reliever whose next stop now comes with a familiar rival. [Read more 🡒]