The Red Sox got a little bit of everything when the Baseball Writers’ Association of America rolled out its award finalists on November 2. Boston has a manager in the mix, a rookie pitcher in the running, an ace who came up just short, and a familiar arm back in the organization after minor league free agency opened.
Chad Tracy is one of three finalists for American League Manager of the Year, joining Tampa Bay’s Kevin Cash and Chicago’s Will Venable. The winner will be announced on November 10.
Tracy’s case is built on a dramatic midseason rescue job. Boston was sitting at 10-17 on April 25 when Alex Cora and five other coaches were dismissed, and the club was back to .500 at 48-48 by July 17 under Tracy. From there, the Red Sox caught fire, ripping off a 15-game winning streak and a 32-5 midsummer run that pushed them into playoff position and carried them into the postseason.
The competition is no joke. Cash remains a constant presence in this race because of what he keeps doing with the Rays’ tiny payroll, while Venable has the most eye-popping turnaround of the bunch after guiding the 2025, 102-loss White Sox to a second-place, 84-win finish with an electric offense.
Boston also has a finalist for American League Rookie of the Year in Payton Tolle. His season earned attention for more than just the personality and flair that made him a leaguewide talking point; the numbers back it up, too. Tolle finished with a 3.03 ERA, 1.10 WHIP, 171 strikeouts and 40 walks across 148.2 innings.
Tolle’s path to the award isn’t easy, either. Detroit’s Kevin McGonigle and Cleveland’s Parker Messick are the other finalists.
McGonigle hit .278/.376/.430 with 28 doubles, five triples and 18 home runs over 156 games, while Messick put together a 2.56 ERA, 1.063 WHIP, 161 ERA+, 193 strikeouts and 49 walks over 186.1 innings. Messick is also a Cy Young finalist.
That Cy Young race did not include Sonny Gray, even after a strong first season in Boston. Gray, the Red Sox’s 2026 ace, posted a 2.72 ERA, 1.148 WHIP and a major league-leading 18 wins over 169 innings in his age-36 season.
He didn’t crack the top three, but he should still pick up down ballot Cy Young votes. Messick, Cam Schlittler and Dylan Cease are the finalists, with Schlittler standing out after a 1.95 ERA, 215 ERA+, 0.919 WHIP, 239 strikeouts and 49 walks over 193.2 innings.
Boston also brought back Yordanny Monegro after he briefly reached minor league free agency. The Red Sox originally signed him as an international free agent out of the Dominican Republic in 2020, and he didn’t really emerge as a notable prospect until 2023. His 2025 season was interrupted by a torn UCL and Tommy John surgery, and he logged only 6.2 innings between High-A Greenville and Double-A Portland in 2026.
Even with that limited workload, the organization chose to keep him in the fold. Monegro could still end up as a reliever in the majors, and the Red Sox clearly value having him back as he gets close to Triple-A.
In Other News...
Red Sox Roster Crunch Just Squeezed Out Two Unexpected Arms
The Red Sox had to make room for a wave of returns from the 60-day injured list, and that meant parting with two arms who were once part of the bullpen picture. Zack Kelly, who had been with Boston since 2022, and Eduardo Rivera were designated for assignment after being activated, a reminder of how quickly roster math can turn even familiar names into casualties when the 40-man fills up.
Kellys time with the club had already been complicated by injury and the squeeze of roster management, while Rivera never got much of a runway to settle in at the major league level. With several players coming off the injured list, Boston now has a full 40-man roster again, but the moves leave open the question of what comes next for both pitchers as the team continues sorting through its depth. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Infield Upgrade Talk Just Got A Lot More Interesting
Reports around Ketel Marte have given the Red Sox another name to watch as they look for ways to strengthen the infield. Martes season in Arizona came with complications, but the offensive track record is still the kind that can change a lineup in a hurry, which is why Bostons interest makes sense if the Diamondbacks are truly willing to listen.
For the Red Sox, the appeal is obvious: a player with Martes bat could help stabilize a position group that has been under the microscope. The fit is still only speculative for now, but the possibility of a trade that helps both sides is enough to keep this one on the radar as the market develops. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Suddenly Have A Familiar Rotation Decision To Make
The Red Sox are back in familiar territory this offseason, weighing whether a former starter who once wore their uniform could help stabilize a rotation that needs right-handed help. Nick Pivetta is now a free agent after San Diego declined his $14 million club option, a move that came after an injury-shortened season limited him to eight starts and turned what had been a player option into a club option.
For Boston, the timing is notable because the club is already sorting through its rotation plans after Sonny Grays mutual option was declined. With few right-handed starters on hand, a reunion with Pivetta would at least make sense on paper, and it adds another layer to a winter in which the Red Sox are trying to piece together a staff that still has obvious holes. [Read more 🡒]