Red Sox May Have An Obvious Rotation Reunion To Consider

The Boston Red Sox could fortify their pitching lineup by re-signing former standout Nick Pivetta, leveraging his recent success and potential cost-effectiveness to bolster right-handed depth.

The Red Sox may already have a rotation that looks crowded on paper, but the deeper issue is hard to miss: it leans heavily left-handed. If Boston wants to be built for 2027, adding another right-handed starter this offseason makes a lot of sense, and Nick Pivetta stands out as the name at the top of that list.

Right now, a 2027 rotation would likely include Garrett Crochet, Payton Tolle, Ranger Suarez, Jake Bennett and Brayan Bello. That leaves Boston with four lefties and only one righty. Whether the Red Sox want balance or simply more depth, the case for a right-handed starter is strong.

Pivetta fits that need, and he also fits the “buy-low with upside” profile. Boston fans know him from his time with the club from 2020 through 2024, when he was known for his intensity on the mound.

But the version of Pivetta the Red Sox saw then was not the best version of Pivetta. Since leaving for the San Diego Padres ahead of the 2025 season, he has been far better.

Red Sox analyst Scott Neville laid out just how strong that stretch has been on the latest edition of the ITM Podcast.

"He has a 2.87 ERA in 39 starts since he left," Neville said. "He has a 6 WAR since he left, including that 2025, 5-WAR season.

As much as injury was a concern, when he was pitching in 2026, he was exactly what he was in 2025. It's not like there was any regression."

That 2025 season was especially impressive. Pivetta posted a 2.87 ERA in 31 starts, struck out 190 and walked 50 over 181 2/3 innings, and finished as a 5-WAR player. For comparison, Sonny Gray’s 2026 season in Boston came with a 2.72 ERA, a 149-to-46 strikeout-to-walk ratio in 169 innings, and 4.3 WAR.

The injury concerns from 2026 could work in Boston’s favor financially. Pivetta, who is 33, may not command a huge deal and could end up settling for a short-term pillow contract. Gray, by contrast, could be the pricier option this offseason.

Even with the missed time, the bigger point is that Pivetta did not show signs of fading when he was healthy. Neville noted that there was no real regression in 2026, and the right-hander was still electric when he took the ball. He was also healthy down the stretch.

For a Red Sox team that could use another righty and another arm with front-of-the-rotation upside, Pivetta looks like the kind of target Boston should be chasing. Craig Breslow ought to be making that call quickly.

In Other News...

Four Former Red Sox Just Reopened A Complicated Cooperstown Debate

The Hall of Fame ballot for the Class of 2027 has put four former Red Sox back in the spotlight, and it is the kind of list that naturally sends Boston fans back through a decade of October memories. Dustin Pedroia and Jon Lester headline the group after helping drive multiple World Series runs in Boston, while Andrew Miller and Pablo Sandoval add two very different kinds of Red Sox chapters to the mix.

Pedroias case has already shown how complicated this debate can get, with his support still sitting well below the level needed to build real momentum after his second year on the ballot. Sandoval, meanwhile, appears to be on a short leash as far as ballot staying power goes, which leaves this class with an especially familiar Red Sox twist: four names tied to the same era, but not four careers that will be judged the same way when Cooperstown voters weigh them. [Read more 🡒]

Red Sox Take A Flier On A Power Arm With One Big Hurdle

The Red Sox added another arm to the mix by signing right-hander Michael Arias to a minor league contract with an invitation to major league camp. Arias, 25, has spent time in the minor league systems of the Cubs and Yankees, and while he has yet to make his big league debut, his profile has long been built around one thing teams keep chasing: velocity.

For Boston, it is the kind of low-risk move that can pay off if a pitcher with live stuff finds a cleaner path to the strike zone and stays healthy enough to keep developing. Arias has been pitching professionally since 2021, and the invitation gives the Red Sox a closer look at a power arm that has bounced through two organizations without getting the call to the majors just yet. [Read more 🡒]

Red Sox Face Two Huge Rotation Calls Before 2027 Really Opens Up

Garrett Crochets injury-shortened 2026 season has already pushed the Red Sox into a familiar spot: trying to sort out the top of the rotation while also thinking a step ahead. Boston spent the year with the kind of pitching uncertainty that can ripple through everything else, and the front office now has to weigh how much of the current staff it can count on as the next season approaches.

The bigger question is what 2027 looks like once the market opens up and the roster picture gets clearer. Sonny Gray is part of that conversation, but so are possible alternatives like Payton Tolle, Michael King and Ranger Suarez, with Jacob deGrom looming as a more intriguing name if he ever becomes available in trade. For a club trying to build a truly strong staff, the challenge is not just finding innings, but deciding which arms fit the long view and which ones merely keep the rotation afloat for now. [Read more 🡒]