Sonny Gray’s future is suddenly one of the bigger offseason questions hanging over the Red Sox, and the answer may come down to who’s willing to pay the most.
Gray just turned in one of the best seasons of his career at age 36 in Boston, but his $30 million mutual option with the club was declined, sending him into free agency. His exit also carried a little extra edge after he and Red Sox manager Chad Tracy ended the 2026 season on shaky ground, with Gray being pulled after 70 pitches in Game 2 of the AL Wild Card Series, a game Boston lost to finish the year. Right after that defeat, Gray gave no hint that he wanted to come back in 2027.
Still, a reunion is not off the table. As MassLive’s Chris Cotillo noted this week, "Gray is certainly a candidate to return - the icy ending to his season won’t matter if the Red Sox make the right offer." Cotillo also pointed out that "there’s a chance a bidding war that includes teams that are more pitching-needy than Boston could price the Sox out," and he mentioned the Atlanta Braves as one of the clubs that could get involved.
That makes Atlanta an obvious place to start. Gray grew up in Tennessee and pitched at Vanderbilt, and the Braves have been tied to him for a while.
They even checked in on him as a trade possibility at the 2026 deadline. With Tyler Mahle headed for free agency and not guaranteed to return, plus the injury issues surrounding Spencer Strider and Spencer Schwellenbach, Atlanta has a rotation that needs answers.
Gray would give them the same thing he gave Boston in 2026: durability and 20-plus quality starts at ace level.
The Chicago Cubs also fit the profile of a team that could jump in and push Boston higher than it wants to go. At least five Cubs starters are entering free agency or have options that could put them on the market this winter, including Kevin Gausman and Shota Imanaga. That kind of turnover makes Gray a natural target, and Chicago has shown it is willing to spend.
Then there’s Toronto, which has a different kind of motivation. The Blue Jays could use Gray to strengthen their own rotation while taking one of Boston’s best arms off the board.
He would slot in next to Dylan Cease as a strong No. 2 and help Toronto rebound from a disappointing 2026. And if spending is the question, the Jays have already shown they’re comfortable doing it, with Cease’s contract last offseason standing as the clearest example.
In Other News...
Red Sox Are Suddenly Linked To A Move That Could Shake The AL
The Red Sox have already shown they plan to stay busy as the offseason opens, and the trade market is expected to remain part of their plan as free agency gets underway. With Boston looking for ways to keep improving, the club is now being mentioned in connection with one of the sports most electric young talents, a possibility that would instantly change the conversation around the roster.
Chris Cotillo of MassLive.com has floated the idea that Boston could pursue a trade for Cincinnatis Elly De La Cruz, a name that would bring plenty of attention anywhere it lands. It is still only speculation, but it underscores how aggressively the Red Sox are being discussed this winter and why any move involving a player of that caliber would be viewed as one of the most significant swings in the American League. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Defense Just Sent A Powerful Message About This Roster
The Red Sox got a clear reminder of how much value they can squeeze out of run prevention when Caleb Durbin, Ceddanne Rafaela and Wilyer Abreu were all recognized for their work in the field. Durbin picked up the first Gold Glove of his career at third base, while Rafaela continued to establish himself as one of the leagues steadiest center fielders with a second straight award.
Abreus latest honor was just as notable, giving him three Gold Gloves in a row in right field and reinforcing what Boston already knew about its outfield defense. Put together, the three awards say plenty about the shape of this roster, with the Red Sox now able to point to elite gloves across the diamond as a real part of their identity. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Just Made An Important Garrett Whitlock Decision
The Red Sox have made one of their more important offseason decisions already, exercising Garrett Whitlocks club option for the 2027 season and keeping a versatile arm in the organization for the long haul. It is the kind of move that signals confidence in a pitcher who has been a valuable piece for Boston, especially at a time when the club is sorting through its pitching plans for the years ahead.
The deadline for these calls came right after the World Series, and Boston also had a notable decision on the other side of the ledger, declining Sonny Grays $30 million mutual option and sending him into free agency. For the Red Sox, Whitlocks return gives them certainty in a key spot, while the Gray move underscores how quickly the roster picture can shift once the offseason starts to take shape. [Read more 🡒]