The Red Sox may not have the front-runner for any of baseball’s biggest individual prizes, but ESPN’s latest Awards Watch makes one thing clear: Boston has talent spread all over the roster.
Five Red Sox players showed up across three award races in the rankings, with Willson Contreras and Ceddanne Rafaela both landing inside the top five in the American League MVP conversation. Payton Tolle and Jake Bennett cracked the top 10 for AL Rookie of the Year, while Sonny Gray checked in eighth in the AL Cy Young chase.
The list was built using AXE, ESPN’s system that blends several value measures, including Baseball Reference WAR, FanGraphs WAR, win probability added and championship probability added. It is not the official voting picture, but it does give a strong snapshot of which players are piling up the most value.
Contreras came in fourth in the AL MVP race with a 129.5 AXE rating, just ahead of Rafaela at 129. Only Houston Astros slugger Yordan Alvarez, Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. and Detroit Tigers rookie Kevin McGonigle were ranked above them.
For Boston, Contreras has been exactly the kind of pickup the club wanted when it brought him in from the St. Louis Cardinals during the offseason.
The 34-year-old has supplied middle-of-the-order pop while handling first base well enough to avoid becoming a defensive problem. That blend has made him one of the most important pieces on the roster.
Rafaela brings a different kind of impact. The 2026 All-Star offers power, speed and Gold Glove-caliber defense at one of the game’s toughest positions. He helped reinforce that value on Sunday, going 3 for 5 with two RBIs in Boston’s 5-4 win over the San Francisco Giants as the Red Sox finished off a sweep and moved to 71-59.
Neither Contreras nor Rafaela is likely to catch Alvarez if the Houston star finishes his push for the Triple Crown, but their spots near the top of the board tell the same story: Boston is still very much in the playoff mix.
The same goes for the rookie pitchers who have helped stabilize the rotation. Tolle ranked fifth in the AL Rookie of the Year standings at 117.7, while Bennett came in 10th at 110.1.
Both left-handers have become important answers for a staff that has been tested by injuries all season. Bennett moved to 8-6 after throwing seven innings in Sunday’s win over San Francisco. He gave up three earned runs, struck out six and threw 65 of his 84 pitches for strikes.
Tolle, meanwhile, has brought swing-and-miss stuff and kept earning bigger assignments as the year has gone on. Gray also remained in the Cy Young picture, sitting eighth with 16 wins when ESPN compiled its rankings. Yankees starter Cam Schlittler and Blue Jays ace Dylan Cease were leading that race at the time.
Boston could still finish without an individual award winner. Even so, the ESPN rankings underline how much quality the Red Sox have across the board. Two MVP-level position players, two of the league’s best rookies and a veteran Cy Young candidate is a pretty formidable mix for a team chasing October.
In Other News...
Garrett Crochets Rehab Just Changed Bostons Long-Term Outlook
Garrett Crochets rehab is starting to look more substantial, even if the Red Sox are still being patient with the left-hander. He has been on the injured list since April 25 with shoulder and lat issues, but he is now throwing out to 90 feet with intensity, a sign that his return-to-play process is moving forward after a long stretch away from game action.
The bigger twist for Boston arrived with the calendar, not the mound. On his 120th straight day on the injured list, a provision in Crochets six-year, $170 million deal kicked in, wiping out his opt-out after the 2030 season and adding a club option for 2032. If he does pitch again this year, the Red Sox are expecting that to come in a bullpen role, leaving the team to balance the immediate need for his arm with a contract that now carries even more long-term weight. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Roster Crunch Could Be About To Get Real
Roman Anthony is set to continue his rehab assignment with Triple-A Worcester on Tuesday, keeping one of the Red Soxs most closely watched young players on the comeback track. Meanwhile, Trevor Story and Isiah Kiner-Falefa are both slated for evaluations Monday as the club tries to determine whether either is ready to return, adding another layer to a roster situation that has been building for days.
Chad Tracy said the team should have more information after its upcoming games, which means the picture could shift quickly depending on how those rehab checks go. For Boston, the interest is less about the rehab assignments themselves than what they might trigger next, since a few decisions could be coming in short order once the evaluations are complete. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Have A Bigger Chad Tracy Decision Waiting After This Run
Since Chad Tracy took over in April, the Red Sox have played well enough to make his status one of the quieter but more important storylines hanging over the rest of the season. He is still the interim manager for now, but the way Boston has responded to him has already pushed him to the front of the conversation about the clubs long-term direction, and he has earned a level of trust inside the clubhouse that managers do not build overnight.
The Red Sox are reportedly leaning toward giving Tracy the job full time before the 2027 season, though no final call has been made. For now, the club plans to let the season finish and then weigh his work as a whole, even as he has emerged as a leading AL Manager of the Year candidate and given Boston a much steadier footing than it had when he first stepped in. [Read more 🡒]