The Red Sox may be staring at a thin free-agent market and a trade-heavy offseason ahead, but that doesn’t mean Franklin Arias is suddenly up for grabs.
Boston’s top prospect - ranked No. 2 overall by MLB Pipeline - could bring back a huge haul if the club ever decided to move him. The Red Sox already showed at the trade deadline that they were willing to explore that kind of blockbuster, reaching out to the Cincinnati Reds about a deal for star shortstop Elly De La Cruz that would have included Arias and others. Cincinnati wasn’t interested.
Still, that doesn’t mean Boston is ready to shop Arias broadly. In Jen McCaffrey’s October 26 mailbag with The Athletic, she wrote that the Red Sox would have to be “blown away” to deal him.
That’s the right standard, especially with the way Arias finished 2026. The 20-year-old shortstop put together a breakout season, hitting .323/.400/.557 with 28 doubles, a triple and 25 home runs in 117 games.
Before that, he had never hit more than nine home runs in any of his first three minor league seasons. This year, he looked ready for the next level.
Boston’s shortstop picture also matters here. The club is one year removed from the end of Trevor Story’s contract, which should finally loosen the restrictions it has dealt with at the position over the last five years. Arias may not be an easy fit on the roster in 2027 unless something unexpected happens in the middle infield, but his long-term value is obvious.
That’s why the Red Sox should keep the bar sky-high. De La Cruz, or a player with that kind of talent and team control, is the level this would have to reach.
Zach Neto and CJ Abrams didn’t qualify before, and a weak free-agent class shouldn’t change that. Arias has the look of a future All-Star shortstop, and Boston shouldn’t move him unless the return is every bit as special.
In Other News...
Red Sox Offseason Fix Could Force A Tough Choice In The Outfield
The Red Sox are already being connected to a possible offseason swing at Randy Arozarena, a move that would be aimed at giving the lineup more punch and a little more speed heading into the 2027 season. It is the kind of fit that makes sense on paper for a club that could use help in the same areas it fell short a year earlier, especially if Boston wants to keep pace in a tougher offensive landscape.
Arozarena would not come cheap, and that is where the conversation gets interesting for the Red Sox. Adding a player with that kind of profile could force the front office to make other roster decisions to make the pieces fit, particularly in the outfield, where a major addition tends to ripple through the rest of the depth chart. If Boston is serious about pursuing him, the bigger question may be less about whether he helps and more about what else has to change to make room. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Hold A Luis Robert Decision That Could Help Boston
The Red Sox are already weighing how to add more offense for the next stage of their push toward contention in 2027, and one name worth keeping in view is Luis Robert Jr. The former All-Star now sits with Baltimore, where his future could soon become a decision point if the Orioles pass on his 2027 option.
Roberts appeal is obvious for a Boston club looking for impact talent, even with the obvious health questions that have followed him in recent seasons. His mix of power and speed has long made him the kind of player teams monitor closely, and if Baltimore lets the situation move toward free agency, the Red Sox could have a real opening to explore. [Read more 🡒]