Red Sox Free Agency Regret Looks Even Worse After Alonso Honor

The Boston Red Sox may have missed out on a game-changing acquisition as Pete Alonso's Silver Slugger victory underscores the difference he could have made in their lineup.

Pete Alonso’s Silver Slugger win over Willson Contreras is the kind of result that can sting a front office long after the trophy is handed out.

Contreras put together the best offensive season of his career in his first year with the Boston Red Sox, turning in a .275/.386/.516 line with 12 doubles, three triples, 27 home runs and 81 RBI across 130 games. That production put him among the game’s elite bats, and he was one of just three qualified hitters to finish with an OPS above .900, joining Yordan Alvarez and Pete Crow-Armstrong.

Even with that kind of season, Contreras came up short in the American League Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger race at first base. Alonso, now a division rival, took the award instead. For the second straight year, FanSided and Louisville Slugger handled the unveiling of the 2026 finalists and winners.

That result only sharpens the Red Sox’s regret over last offseason’s free agency chase. Boston and Baltimore were both in the mix for Alonso, and the Orioles ultimately landed him. In an AL East that already punishes mistakes, Alonso has quickly become the sort of bat you’d rather not have to face 13 times a year.

There had been talk that Boston held back because of Alonso’s age and his long-term fit, especially with the possibility that he could end up as a full-time designated hitter later in his career. The Red Sox have been reluctant to roster that type of player in recent seasons. But those whispers were later pushed back on by Jared Carrabis, who said an unnamed team source told him the Red Sox were “very close” to landing Alonso.

On the field, Alonso’s case is obvious. Contreras reached base more often and posted the steadier overall line, but Alonso brought the louder power. He piled up 24 doubles and 48 home runs, the second-most in MLB this season, and it’s fair to wonder how many more he might have launched with half his games at Fenway Park.

His value goes beyond the bat, too. Alonso has been one of the most durable players in the sport, never playing fewer than 152 games in a season outside the shortened 2020 campaign.

He also showed improvement at first base, finishing with zero outs above average and defensive runs saved, even though those numbers have usually leaned negative for him. And like Contreras, he brings a fiery presence that could have mattered in Boston’s clubhouse.

That doesn’t make Contreras any less important to the Red Sox. He was one of Craig Breslow’s best additions as chief baseball officer, and his career year in Boston came as a surprise.

He even drew MVP votes for it. Red Sox fans have every reason to be excited about what he can do next season.

But the larger point remains: when a team needs power and Pete Alonso is available, that’s the time to go big. The Orioles did.

In Other News...

Red Sox Face One Huge Adley Rutschman Question After Blockbuster

The Red Sox did not just make a splash by landing Adley Rutschman from the Orioles, they also took on a bigger question that will hang over the move well beyond the initial buzz. Rutschman arrives with one year left on his contract, and Boston had already been weighing the possibility of an extension when it completed the trade, a sign the club sees this as more than a short-term rental.

What happens next is the part that matters most for the Red Sox. The front office also had to consider how a potential lockout could complicate any deal, and the ongoing discussion now centers on whether Boston is willing to pay Rutschman at the top of the catching market. For a team that just made a major swing, the real test may be how far it is prepared to go to keep him in place. [Read more 🡒]

Red Sox Just Created An AL East Problem Theyll Regret

The Red Sox had a chance to keep Allan Castro in the organization after his 2026 season, but instead left the Triple-A outfielder off the 40-man roster and watched him become a free agent. For a club that has spent plenty of time trying to build and protect its depth, it was a notable decision, especially with a player who had just spent the year in Worcester and showed some real pop with 15 home runs and a .722 OPS.

Now the Yankees have stepped in with a minor league deal, which gives Boston an unwelcome reminder of how quickly a roster decision can turn into an AL East headache. Castro was never a finished product, but he was close enough to the big-league picture to matter, and the Red Sox may end up seeing his progress continue in the division if New York can turn that opportunity into something more. [Read more 🡒]

Red Sox May Finally Have A Path Out Of The Yoshida Dilemma

Masataka Yoshidas place on the Red Sox roster has been one of the more awkward fits on the teams books, with the outfielder struggling to carve out a consistent role and only one year left on his contract. For Boston, that has turned him into a lingering roster question: useful enough to matter, expensive enough to complicate things, and not quite settled into a lane that makes the decision easy.

A possible shift in the broader baseball economy could make that calculus a little more favorable. MLBs proposed salary floor, if implemented in 2028, would give clubs more incentive to absorb higher salaries in order to reach payroll minimums, which could help create a market for players like Yoshida. The Houston Astros, Los Angeles Angels and Toronto Blue Jays have been floated as possible fits, though no club has publicly confirmed interest, leaving the Red Sox with a path that is clearer in theory than it is in practice. [Read more 🡒]