Trade talk between the Red Sox and Bryce Harper surfaced quickly after Bob Nightengale floated the idea that Philadelphia could shop one or both of its stars this offseason.
Speaking on 97.5 The Fanatic, Nightengale said the Phillies are likely to explore moving either Harper or Trea Turner after another early postseason exit, while adding that he did not think Kyle Schwarber would be on the move. When the conversation turned to which player would be the more likely trade candidate, Nightengale landed on Harper.
“You’d think probably Harper in the sense that Turner doesn’t have that [contract] value,” he said. “You’d have to eat a lot of that contract to move him. Harper’s contract is very reasonable.”
Harper’s average annual value over the next five seasons is about $25.4 million per year.
That was enough to send Red Sox fans spinning, even if the fit is far from simple. Boston already has an All-Star first baseman in Willson Contreras, and moving Harper back to the outfield would create another problem because the Red Sox already have a crowded group out there.
Some fans even started floating Roman Anthony as part of the solution, which tells you how quickly the speculation got rolling. Harper will turn 34 this October.
If Boston ever got serious about a deal, it would only work if Harper agreed to waive his no-trade clause and the Red Sox truly wanted him. In that case, the more realistic path would likely involve Jarren Duran going the other way, with Harper spending most of his time at DH while Anthony, Ceddanne Rafaela and Wilyer Abreu kept their outfield jobs intact.
Even then, the price would be steep. Harper is no longer in his MVP-level peak, but he would still be the kind of player who brings back an MLB-ready prospect and another highly regarded younger prospect with plenty of upside.
The Red Sox just parted with major prospect capital in the Adley Rutschman deal, though they still have some pieces to work with. If the Phillies were open to a package that did not include Franklin Arias - who would be off-limits - Boston could at least have a chance.
There’s another layer, too. If Harper were open to coming to Boston, he might also want an extension beyond his current deal, which would create yet another complication for the Red Sox.
For now, Harper-to-Boston looks like a long shot. But in October, that’s how a lot of these conversations start: with a big name, a loose idea, and fans filling in the rest.
In Other News...
Red Sox Offseason May Hinge On What Happens With Familiar Names
The Red Sox are heading into the offseason with a fairly tight runway for maneuvering, because there are not many contracts expiring to naturally open up space on the roster. That matters in a winter when Boston wants to keep improving, since new additions may depend on trades or on non-tenders rather than a simple wave of free-agent departures clearing the deck.
Two familiar names are part of the picture on the pitching side, with Sonny Gray and Patrick Sandoval both expected to reach free agency, while the club is also expected to bring back Garrett Whitlock and Chapman on team-controlled deals. Grays situation looms especially large because his option looks headed for the open market, and Chapmans future has a different layer after he met the requirements to lock in his option, leaving Boston with some clarity but not necessarily much more flexibility. [Read more 🡒]
Curtis Mead Could Be The Red Sox Bat Theyve Been Missing
Curtis Mead arrived in Boston carrying the kind of offensive track record that can make a lineup look different in a hurry. In 87 games with Washington last season, he hit .254/.352/.500 with 17 home runs and 48 RBIs, production that suggested a bat with enough thump to matter in a bigger role.
The Red Sox have barely gotten a look at him since the trade, though, because a wrist injury cut short his first stint with the club after just one game. He is now back on the active roster for the wild-card series against the Yankees, and if he can stay on the field, Boston may finally have the middle-of-the-order boost it has been searching for heading into next season. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Get A Quiet Caleb Durbin Update With One Lingering Concern
Caleb Durbins season never really slowed down, even after the injury that has now required a closer look. The Red Sox infielder stayed at third base through the rest of the regular season and postseason, handling the position with solid defensive metrics while providing average offense, all without missing any playing time after the issue first surfaced in June.
Now comes the quiet update: Durbin underwent a procedure last week to reconstruct the PIP joint in his left pinky, a reminder of just how much he played through over the summer. The lingering concern is less about what he gave Boston this year than what comes next, since the injury traces back to the partial dislocation he suffered in late June and leaves one more checkpoint before the club can fully move on from it. [Read more 🡒]