The Red Sox may already be facing an uphill battle if they want Sonny Gray back.
Gray is headed for free agency after a strong season at age 36, and the fit in Boston is complicated before the bidding even really starts. His mutual option would need to be worked out with the club, but those deals rarely get done, and a one-year salary around $30 million looks steep for a 37-year-old arm.
There is still a path to a reunion, though. Gray was unhappy when Red Sox manager Chad Tracy pulled him in the fifth inning of Wild Card Game 2, but he has apparently moved past that and even floated Boston as a possible landing spot while talking about winning a championship before he retires. He also said he would be done with baseball "in a heartbeat" if his family wanted him to be.
That family factor may be the real hurdle. Mark Feinsand reported that the Red Sox will be among Gray's "primary suitors" this offseason, but there is a belief that he could prefer a team closer to his home in Tennessee.
For Boston, the interest makes sense. Gray was one of the American League’s best pitchers last season and is expected to finish near the top five in Cy Young voting.
The Red Sox, meanwhile, do not have another right-hander on the staff with the same kind of appeal. Brayan Bello had a wild, inconsistent year, and there is no certainty about what comes next.
Tanner Houck and Kutter Crawford missed the entire season because of injuries, leaving their outlooks murky as well.
The Braves could also make life difficult for Boston. Tyler Mahle is set to hit free agency, Spencer Strider spent much of last season dealing with elbow inflammation and has regressed from his early-career peak, and Spencer Schwellenbach missed the entire 2026 season because of injury. With that kind of picture, Gray may see Atlanta as a better championship bet, which would only strengthen their case as a serious contender.
Boston’s top offseason goal remains improving the offense, but bringing Gray back would still give the rotation a major lift. If the Red Sox want to keep him in the northeast, they may have to beat out clubs with a Tennessee advantage.
In Other News...
Red Sox Face A Risky Pitching Choice After Sonny Gray Misses Out
With the offseason approaching, the Red Sox are already looking at ways to reshape a pitching staff that could use more balance. One area of focus is the rotation, which leans heavily left-handed, and Boston has been weighing a few right-handed options who could help even things out and add a different look for opponents.
Michael King and Casey Mize have both surfaced as potential free-agent fits, giving the club two very different paths to consider. King finished the 2026 season strongly as the Padres ace, while Mizes year was much shakier after a midseason trade and he is still working back from an ankle injury, leaving Boston with a choice between steadier production and a bet on upside. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Power Search Just Put Craig Breslow In A Tough Spot
The Red Sox may be chasing power this winter, but the market is already setting up some awkward choices for Craig Breslow. Boston does not have a qualifying-offer candidate of its own this offseason because of eligibility and contract situations, which gives the club a little more flexibility than some rivals, but it also means the front office has to navigate a free-agent class where several obvious fit types could come attached to draft-pick compensation.
Randy Arozarena, Seiya Suzuki and Brandon Lowe are expected to receive qualifying offers, and that is where the challenge comes in. If Boston wants to stay aggressive in the search for offense, it may have to decide how much it values those bats against the cost of losing draft capital, with the state of the farm system hanging over the conversation as another reason every offseason move could carry extra weight. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox May Finally Have A Real Path To Fixing The Outfield
Bostons outfield plans have been one of the bigger questions hanging over the roster, and Jarren Duran has become part of the conversation after a rough offensive season and some off-field issues. The Red Sox are exploring ways to clear space and reshape the lineup, with an eye toward adding more power and getting the mix in the outfield closer to what they want moving forward.
One possible avenue remains a familiar one, with San Diego still in the market for outfield help as it braces for possible free-agent departures. For Boston, the appeal is obvious: if there is a way to turn Duran into a cleaner fit elsewhere, it could open the door to a more balanced roster. The question now is whether the market brings the kind of return that makes the Red Sox comfortable finally moving on. [Read more 🡒]