The Red Sox have a shortstop call to make this offseason, and the choice could shape the way Boston opens the 2027 season. For now, the lean is still Trevor Story.
That answer comes with a few moving parts. The biggest one has nothing to do with Boston’s roster at all: labor talks.
The current collective bargaining agreement expires in December, and there could be a lockout that affects the 2027 season. If the game gets back on track and the Red Sox get a normal offseason, they’ll have room to continue reshaping the roster.
Shortstop remains one of the spots with real uncertainty.
Story has handled the position over the last few weeks when healthy, and the Red Sox know exactly what he can do when he’s right. He played only 54 games in 2026, but when he came back from injury on Aug. 30, he was productive right away. In 23 games, he hit .291/.322/.442 with two home runs, 10 RBIs, seven doubles and eight runs scored.
The bigger issue is availability. Story has only topped 100 games once in his five seasons in Boston.
That’s the risk. The upside is obvious, too: in 2025, he stayed on the field and delivered a big season, posting 25 home runs, 96 RBIs and 31 steals across 157 games.
That kind of track record is why Story would draw interest if Boston ever made him available. He’ll make $25 million in 2027, and he also has a $25 million club option for 2028. A team could talk itself into betting on the talent, but it would be exactly that - a bet.
The wild card here is Franklin Arias. The top prospect could move into the picture quickly in 2027, and if the Red Sox believe he’s ready to open the season in the majors, that changes everything. If Boston sees Arias as the better option at shortstop, then Story becomes movable.
There are a few different ways that could play out. The Red Sox could trade Story, or they could move him around the diamond.
Another possibility is making room elsewhere, such as trading Jarren Duran to open the designated hitter spot. That would allow Arias to take over at shortstop while Story shifts to DH or even second base.
If Story ended up at second, Curtis Mead could land at DH, though Mead would likely still be in the infield in that setup.
Boston’s decision isn’t just about who is ready now. It’s also about how much pressure the team wants to put on a rookie.
The Red Sox are expected to enter 2027 as World Series contenders on paper, and that makes the calculus tougher. Plugging one of the top prospects in baseball into an Opening Day job at one of the game’s most demanding positions would be a serious leap.
Arias’ turn will come, and maybe it should come right away. But the safer prediction is that Story is still there when 2027 begins.
He carries clubhouse weight, he’s tied to significant money, and his trade value likely isn’t enough to force Boston’s hand. If the Red Sox don’t land a major bat, he still looks like the best bet to be the Opening Day shortstop.
In Other News...
Red Sox Just Lost Another Trusted Voice In A Risky Spot
Taylor Smith is headed to Oakland after being hired as the Athletics new president of baseball operations, a move that once again chips away at the Red Sox front office tree. Smith had served as Bostons assistant general manager, and his departure comes on the heels of another familiar loss in the department, with Paul Toboni previously leaving for Washington. It is the kind of personnel churn that does not show up on the field right away, but can reshape an organizations depth behind the scenes.
Jared Banner, another former Red Sox executive, has now also landed a major role with Baltimore as the Orioles new general manager. For Boston, the pattern is hard to miss: trusted voices in baseball operations keep getting poached for larger opportunities elsewhere. The Red Sox have had no shortage of turnover in recent years, but losing multiple familiar evaluators and decision-makers in such a short span is the sort of development that can leave a real imprint on how the next wave of roster calls gets made. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Power Search Just Took One Trade Option Off The Board
The Red Sox have been connected to another possible trade target in the search for more offense, but one of the cleaner fits appears to be off the table. Colorado catcher Hunter Goodman had surfaced as a name worth watching because of his upside and team control through 2029, yet Jon Heyman has dismissed Boston as a likely landing spot after the club recently brought in Adley Rutschman.
That leaves the Red Sox looking elsewhere as they continue sorting through power options that better match their current roster needs. Goodman is still the type of player other clubs could covet, but for Boston the more realistic path seems to run through other free agents and trade candidates who fit the lineup and defensive picture more naturally. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Offseason Plans May Hinge On One October Free Agent
As the postseason keeps reshaping the market, the Red Sox are already sorting through a few names that could fit their offseason plans. Jake Bauers has put himself on the radar with a strong run in October and a solid regular season behind him, while Austin Hedges stands out as a possible backup catching option if Boston wants more depth behind the plate.
Jos Berros is the more intriguing fit because his value could rise or fall depending on how the Red Sox approach the rest of their offseason. If Boston decides it needs another starter, he looks like the kind of arm worth tracking, but the final call may depend on how the rest of the playoff picture and the market unfold. [Read more 🡒]