Major League Baseball moved quickly after Tuesday’s bench-clearing brawl between the Nationals and Red Sox, handing out suspensions to four players tied to the incident.
Washington starter Cade Cavalli was hit with the heaviest penalty from the league, a seven-game suspension for initiating and taking part in the fight. Rotation mate Miles Mikolas received a five-game ban for his role in the scrum. On the Boston side, first baseman Willson Contreras was suspended seven games for his actions during and after the altercation, while backup infielder Nate Eaton drew a three-game suspension for his part in the brawl.
All four players were also fined an undisclosed amount. They can appeal, and that’s expected to happen, since that’s the usual move in cases like this. If the suspensions stand, they would begin tomorrow, with both clubs off tonight.
Chris Cotillo of MassLive reported that Contreras’ punishment was increased because the three-time All-Star broke a league rule by using social media during the game. After being ejected, Contreras went on Instagram and replied “come meet me at Fenway” to a fan who had insulted him while the game was still in progress.
The incident started after Cavalli punched out Contreras looking in the fourth inning Tuesday. As Contreras headed back toward the dugout, Cavalli shouted “sit down, boy,” and that set off the confrontation that brought both benches onto the field.
Contreras threw his helmet during the melee. The bad blood apparently had some earlier roots, too, with Cavalli taking issue in the first inning when Contreras brushed past him as they headed to their dugouts at the end of the frame.
Eaton and Mikolas weren’t part of the game itself, but both were ejected for fighting once the benches emptied.
Cavalli was not thrown out, and he stayed in to carve up Boston over seven scoreless innings with 13 strikeouts, the best outing of his career. Red Sox interim skipper Chad Tracy took issue with the umpires’ decision to keep Cavalli in the game, and the league’s discipline suggests the office felt the same way.
Contreras, who is Venezuelan, and Tracy both declined to say whether they believed Cavalli’s use of the word “boy” carried a racial meaning, per ESPN. Cavalli addressed the controversy in a statement yesterday, saying that wasn’t his intent while also expressing regret over his choice of words.
“I’m extremely torn up about the way that things were perceived,” Cavalli said. “Obviously, there was no ill intention behind that.
My teammates know me, my family knows me, this organization knows me. I couldn’t sleep because of it.
It hurt my heart, knowing that if there’s a 13-year-old Black kid in D.C. that sees that - that looked up to me and thinks that he perceived it in a way that wasn’t intended the way that it came out, and then he’s not looking up to me anymore - that hurts my heart.”
In Other News...
Red Sox May Finally Have Their Answer At Second Base
Boston has spent years trying to stabilize second base, and the search has only become more urgent as the season has worn on. Anthony Seigler has quickly turned himself into a name worth watching, giving the Red Sox a jolt at a spot that has lacked consistency since the Dustin Pedroia era and has not been solved by Marcelo Mayers uneven play.
A former first-round pick of the Yankees who arrived in Boston this offseason, Seigler has made a strong first impression in limited time, hitting .350 across 13 games while also looking steady defensively at second. For a club still sorting through a difficult season, that kind of early return matters, especially when it comes from a player who was not necessarily supposed to become part of the conversation this quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Top Prospects Deliver A Much Needed Bright Spot
For a Red Sox farm system that has spent plenty of time under the microscope, the futures-game nods for Anthony Eyanson and Franklin Arias offer a welcome bit of optimism. Arias has been turning heads at Double-A Portland with a strong offensive showing, while Eyanson has moved quickly through High-A and Double-A by missing bats and limiting damage, giving Boston two of its better-positioned prospects a stage that tends to signal real organizational momentum.
The appeal here is not just that both players are regarded highly inside the system, but that they are doing it in different ways and at different spots on the developmental curve. Arias has added impact to his profile at the plate, and Eyanson has paired results with a rise that has only accelerated since his midseason jump. For a club always trying to balance the present with the future, having both on the American League side of the 2026 All-Star Futures Game is the kind of update that matters, even if the bigger questions around how soon each can help are still very much open. [Read more 🡒]