Four Former Red Sox Just Reopened A Complicated Cooperstown Debate

The Hall of Fame journey begins anew for a quartet of former Red Sox players, including standout Dustin Pedroia, as they seek baseballs highest honor on the 2027 Cooperstown ballot.

The Hall of Fame conversation is back on, and four former Red Sox are part of the 2027 BBWAA ballot.

The National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum announced the ballot on Monday, with 27 former players eligible for induction into Cooperstown next year. For Boston fans, the list includes Dustin Pedroia, Jon Lester, Andrew Miller and Pablo Sandoval.

Pedroia and Lester are the obvious names at the top of the Red Sox group. Pedroia spent his entire career in Boston and built a résumé that includes the 2007 AL Rookie of the Year award, the 2008 AL MVP award and World Series titles in 2007, 2013 and 2018.

Over 14 seasons, he posted a .805 OPS, won three Gold Gloves and added a Silver Slugger. On last year’s ballot, his second time through, he drew just over 20 percent of the vote.

Lester’s case is tied closely to what he did in Boston and beyond. He spent his first 8.5 seasons with the Red Sox, helped the club win championships in 2007 and 2013 and finished his Red Sox run with a 110-63 record and a 3.64 ERA in 242 games.

He also threw a no-hitter in Boston during the 2008 season. Even after being traded during the 2014 season, he still logged more time with the Red Sox than with any other team.

If he gets serious Hall consideration, it will come from his years in Boston and his work with the Cubs.

Andrew Miller is on the ballot as a reliever who completely changed the shape of his career in Boston. After earlier struggles as a starter with the Tigers and Marlins, he became a dominant bullpen arm with the Red Sox.

From 2011-14, he posted a 3.79 ERA over 3.5 seasons, and his move to the bullpen full-time in 2012 sparked the turnaround. He was an important part of the 2013 World Series team before Boston traded him to the Orioles for Eduardo Rodriguez.

As a reliever, Miller faces a tough path on the ballot.

Pablo Sandoval is the fourth former Red Sox name on the list, though his Boston tenure did not go the way the team hoped. After winning three World Series with the Giants, he signed a five-year deal with the Red Sox in 2014, but he only appeared in 161 games across parts of three seasons and hit .646 OPS. The source material notes that he had issues both on and off the field, and he is not expected to stay on the ballot beyond this year, despite a strong Giants career.

The ballot features 14 first-timers and 13 returnees overall, and the four former Red Sox now get their shot at Cooperstown.

In Other News...

Red Sox May Have An Obvious Rotation Reunion To Consider

The Red Sox are already looking ahead to how their rotation might need to balance out this winter, and the conversation naturally starts with the right side of the mound. Bostons current mix leans heavily left-handed, which makes the search for a proven right-handed starter feel less like a luxury and more like a roster fit the club may need to address if it wants more stability going into next season.

Nick Pivetta is the obvious reunion candidate hovering over that discussion. After leaving Boston, he has pitched well with the Padres, and his recent run has only strengthened the case that he could be a useful addition for a team that knows him already. With his performance trending up and his contract expectations appearing manageable, he fits the profile of a move the Red Sox could seriously weigh as the offseason unfolds. [Read more 🡒]

Red Sox Take A Flier On A Power Arm With One Big Hurdle

The Red Sox added another arm to the mix by signing right-hander Michael Arias to a minor league contract with an invitation to major league camp. Arias, 25, has spent time in the minor league systems of the Cubs and Yankees, and while he has yet to make his big league debut, his profile has long been built around one thing teams keep chasing: velocity.

For Boston, it is the kind of low-risk move that can pay off if a pitcher with live stuff finds a cleaner path to the strike zone and stays healthy enough to keep developing. Arias has been pitching professionally since 2021, and the invitation gives the Red Sox a closer look at a power arm that has bounced through two organizations without getting the call to the majors just yet. [Read more 🡒]

Red Sox Face Two Huge Rotation Calls Before 2027 Really Opens Up

Garrett Crochets injury-shortened 2026 season has already pushed the Red Sox into a familiar spot: trying to sort out the top of the rotation while also thinking a step ahead. Boston spent the year with the kind of pitching uncertainty that can ripple through everything else, and the front office now has to weigh how much of the current staff it can count on as the next season approaches.

The bigger question is what 2027 looks like once the market opens up and the roster picture gets clearer. Sonny Gray is part of that conversation, but so are possible alternatives like Payton Tolle, Michael King and Ranger Suarez, with Jacob deGrom looming as a more intriguing name if he ever becomes available in trade. For a club trying to build a truly strong staff, the challenge is not just finding innings, but deciding which arms fit the long view and which ones merely keep the rotation afloat for now. [Read more 🡒]