Dustin May’s latest outing was a sharp reminder of how quickly the good can turn back into something far less certain.
After leaving the Boston Red Sox and landing with the St. Louis Cardinals in free agency, May authored a complete game shutout on June 15 - the kind of performance that looked like a reset button.
But the momentum didn’t last long. In his one start since then, he lasted just two innings, exited with back tightness, and was tagged for six earned runs on six hits.
May also skipped his last scheduled start, though he is reportedly ready for his next one. Even so, the back issue and the rough follow-up fit the same troubling pattern that has followed him in recent years.
Health has been the recurring theme. May spent time on the injured list with the Red Sox because of an elbow injury and never pitched in the postseason.
He missed all of 2024 after suffering an esophagus while rehabbing from a 2023 arm injury. When he’s right, he can be a solid arm.
The problem has been staying available long enough to show it.
That’s what made the complete game shutout so striking. It offered a brief look at the pitcher May was before the injuries piled up.
Plenty of people thought it could be the start of something. Instead, he hit another roadblock.
Now the Cardinals, who are battling for a postseason spot, need more than flashes. They need May to be sharper than he has been overall. Through 15 starts, he owns a 4.30 ERA, and those numbers tell the same story the Red Sox already saw: talent is there, but consistency keeps slipping away.
In Other News...
Red Sox Suddenly Face A Tough Deadline Call On Resurgent Veteran
The late-July trade market has a way of turning every contending club into both a buyer and a potential seller, and the Red Sox are suddenly in a more complicated spot than they were a week ago. Bostons recent surge has pushed its playoff outlook in a better direction, which is exactly why a veteran reliever who looked like a possible movable piece now comes with a lot more second-guessing attached to him.
Aroldis Chapman is the name drawing attention, and the fit is easy to understand from Texas side. The Rangers are still hanging around the top of the AL West, but their bullpen profile leaves plenty to be desired, especially in the strikeout department, and MLB.coms Mark Feinsand has pointed to that as a reason they could still chase bullpen help. For Boston, the real question is whether a club that has climbed back into the race can justify parting with a resurgent arm before the deadline pressure really starts to bite. [Read more 🡒]
Franklin Arias Is Making Red Sox Fans Wonder How Long This Wait Lasts
Franklin Arias has moved from intriguing name to the prospect Red Sox fans are tracking most closely, and it is not hard to see why. With Payton Tolle already ahead of him in the pipeline, Arias has taken over at the top of Bostons farm system by backing up the hype at Double-A Portland, where he has paired production with the kind of offensive line that forces a front office to pay attention. He has shown enough to make the next step feel less like a question of if than when, with Triple-A Worcester looming as the logical next stop.
Arias rise also comes at a time when Boston is sorting through a deeper wave of young talent, from Anthony Eyansons fast-moving path to Kyson Witherspoons recent rebound to Jake Bennetts place in the pitching mix. That only sharpens the focus on Arias, because the more he keeps hitting, the more the conversation shifts from prospect rank to roster fit. For a club still looking for long-term stability up the middle, his progress is starting to feel like one of the more important timelines in the organization. [Read more 🡒]
Chris Sale Just Matched Another Red Sox Pitching Legend
Chris Sale was at it again against the Giants, piling up 10 strikeouts in another dominant outing and adding one more line to a resume that keeps stacking up in Red Sox history. The performance gave him his 93rd career start with at least 10 strikeouts, tying Curt Schilling for seventh-most all-time and underscoring just how long Sale has lived in that upper tier of power pitchers.
Sales season has been every bit as sharp, with a 2.10 ERA and 109 strikeouts, and the next benchmark is sitting right in front of him. He is also closing in on Sandy Koufax on the left-handed leaderboard, and another double-digit strikeout start later this week against the Mets would move him past Schilling and keep the chase moving. [Read more 🡒]