The Red Sox’s deadline gamble on Adley Rutschman is already carrying a heavy dose of bad news.
Boston swung one of the biggest moves of the MLB trade deadline with its intra-division deal for the Baltimore Orioles star, but the early returns have been rough. Rutschman hasn’t found his footing since arriving, and now there’s added concern that his elbow injury is still limiting him.
According to Tim Healey of The Boston Globe, Red Sox manager Chad Tracy said on WEEI that Rutschman’s hyperextended elbow remains an issue and is likely to stay that way through the rest of the 2026 MLB season. Healey also noted that Rutschman is out of the lineup for a second straight day, per Tracy.
"Chad Tracy said on WEEI that Adley Rutschman's hyperextended elbow is still an issue and probably will be for the rest of the season," Healey shared. "He is out of the lineup today for a second day in a row, per Tracy."
That’s a frustrating update for Boston, especially after paying up to land a three-time All-Star catcher at the deadline. The Red Sox were expecting a difference-maker, but right now they may not have him at full strength.
The timing isn’t ideal, either. Boston is 75-53 and chasing a postseason spot while trying to reel in the Tampa Bay Rays atop the AL East. Getting Rutschman healthy would be a major boost for a club in the thick of the race.
Instead, the Red Sox are left waiting while the injury lingers.
In 15 games with Boston since the August 3 trade deadline, Rutschman has a -0.2 bWAR, a .170 batting average, and a .500 OPS. His 43 OPS+ is far below his usual level and sits at less than half of his previous career low.
It’s a small sample, and there’s still time for him to turn things around in September and October. But for now, the more immediate reality is that the elbow issue appears to be hanging over both Rutschman and the Red Sox for the rest of the season.
In Other News...
Red Sox Pitching Reinforcements Are Near But One Return Just Got Murkier
Help is lining up for Bostons bullpen as September approaches, with Garrett Crochet and Tanner Houck both moving toward returns after injury rehabs. Crochet could start bullpen sessions soon and is slated to come back in a relief role, while Houck has already thrown a simulated game and is expected to fill long relief once he is ready.
Justin Slatens path has become less straightforward. His rehab was recently adjusted because of lingering elbow soreness, which pushes back his timetable and leaves the Red Sox with one more uncertainty in a relief mix that already figures to be in flux as the calendar turns. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Already Have A Painful New Question About Adley Rutschman
The Red Sox made a hefty bet when they brought Adley Rutschman over from Baltimore, sending three top prospects, including pitcher Anthony Eyanson, to the Orioles in the deal. Boston had to expect an adjustment period, but the early returns have been uneven: Rutschman has played only 15 games for the club and, before the injury, had not exactly found a groove at the plate.
Now the bigger issue is less about the price tag and more about what comes next. Rutschman is sidelined with a hyperextended elbow, leaving Boston to wait on both his availability and his production while the prospects it gave up have looked strong in the minors. For a team that moved real talent to get a proven name, that is the kind of comparison that can start feeling uncomfortable quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Deadline Verdict Centers On One Newcomer Delivering Fast
The Red Sox spent the deadline making two of their biggest bets in very different ways, and the early returns have already started to shape how the move is being judged. Adley Rutschman arrived from Baltimore in a four-prospect deal that also sent Carlos Narvaez the other way, giving Boston the kind of established catcher it rarely gets without paying a heavy price. Since the trade, though, Rutschman has not provided much at the plate, leaving the move in the early stages of a wait-and-see phase.
Erik Miller has given the front office a much cleaner first impression. The left-hander came over in a separate deal for Marcelo Mayer and has been excellent out of the bullpen, pairing a low ERA with a strong strikeout-to-walk ratio. With team control running through 2029 and a track record that now stretches back to his 2024 debut, Miller already looks like the kind of arm Boston can build around while the bigger questions around the deadline haul keep unfolding. [Read more 🡒]