Notre Dame Keeps Winning But One Playoff Concern Is Getting Harder To Ignore

Notre Dame's dominant win over Boston College highlights their defensive prowess, but quarterback CJ Carr's Heisman hopes face complications.

SOUTH BEND, Ind. - Notre Dame didn’t need a dramatic finish Saturday. It needed to keep stacking wins, keep the scoreboard moving and keep the season pointed toward the same place it has been aimed since the start.

The No. 5 Irish did exactly that in a 41-7 rout of Boston College, a game that was already tilting Notre Dame’s way while Marcus Freeman was speaking to NBC at halftime.

Behind him, the Notre Dame Stadium video board was running a trailer for “Here Come The Irish,” the program’s in-house docuseries set to release next month. The clip opened with an ESPN voice cutting right to the point: “Everyone is going to remember Notre Dame did not get into the College Football Playoff” last season.

Notre Dame clearly remembers too.

With SMU and Syracuse left on the regular-season slate, the Irish are in position to finish the job and find out where they land next, presumably in the CFP. Against Boston College, they looked every bit like a team trying to remove any doubt.

The defense set the tone and hardly let Boston College breathe. The Eagles’ only rushing touchdown came from Bo MacCormack III, who became the answer to a trivia question after his 3-yard score early in the third quarter.

It was the first rushing touchdown Notre Dame had allowed all season, coming on the 289th carry the defense faced. The Irish had already given up four rushing touchdowns to quarterbacks before that point.

That was the lone real crack. Boston College managed only 136 yards of offense and finished with minus-10 yards in the second quarter, a stretch that included Boubacar Traore’s strip-sack and Jaylen Sneed’s recovery in the end zone. Traore, once a Boston College verbal commitment, is now looking like a potential All-American for Notre Dame.

The Eagles were never built to be a serious stress test for this defense. Their offense runs through quarterback Mason McKenzie, a Division II transfer who leads the team in both passing and rushing.

Even so, Notre Dame made life miserable. If not for CJ Carr’s interception and Jordan Faison’s fumbled punt return in the second quarter, Boston College would not have run a play in Notre Dame territory until the fourth quarter.

It also looked like a continuation of last week, when defensive coordinator Chris Ash leaned into a more aggressive approach than some of the more reactive game plans Notre Dame had used earlier this season. The Irish finished with only two sacks, but McKenzie rarely had time to settle in. Notre Dame did it without defensive tackles Francis Brewu and Jason Onye, both of whom had been questionable after knee injuries against Navy before being scratched.

On offense, Carr’s day was solid, but not the kind of performance that changes the Heisman conversation. After his best outing of the season against Miami, he went 20-of-28 for 217 yards, two touchdowns and one interception - his second pick of the year.

That’s a good afternoon. It just wasn’t the sort of box score that tends to sway voters.

And maybe that’s fine.

As Boston College defensive back KP Price threw Carr to the turf early in the fourth quarter, it was fair to ask why Notre Dame was still leaving its quarterback in the game at all. Freeman had already pulled the rest of the offensive starters, including the linemen protecting the projected first-round pick. Another touchdown against a struggling ACC opponent probably wasn’t going to move the needle much anyway.

Carr still has a shot to reach New York, where he’d likely be sitting alongside presumptive favorite Jeremiah Smith. The Ohio State receiver had 11 catches for 117 yards and a touchdown against Northwestern on Saturday, pushing his season totals to 69 receptions, 1,200 yards and 14 touchdowns. He has six 100-yard games and has gone over 200 yards twice.

Carr, meanwhile, has only one 300-yard passing game this season. Fernando Mendoza also had just one 300-yard game last year for Indiana, but unless Carr puts together something eye-popping over the final stretch, Notre Dame’s first Heisman winner since Tim Brown in 1987 still feels like a long shot.

That doesn’t really change the bigger picture. Carr is trying to be Notre Dame’s first national championship-winning quarterback since Tony Rice.

The other issue hanging over the Irish is the schedule, and it’s not helping. Boston College offered little resistance, Wisconsin lost to Maryland, and Wake Forest handled SMU. When the Mustangs come to Notre Dame next weekend, they’ll arrive unranked and no longer carrying the kind of national weight they once did.

That leaves Notre Dame with just two ranked opponents on the regular-season resume: Miami and BYU. It also wouldn’t be a surprise if eight Irish opponents finish with losing records.

That matters only in the sense that it could make the climb to No. 4 in the final rankings tougher, and that’s the spot Notre Dame would need for a first-round bye. Win the last two games and the Irish should at least secure a first-round home game, which is the same kind of launch point they used on their run to the national championship game two years ago.

There’s also an argument that a first-round game might be preferable. Notre Dame won’t have to play on conference championship weekend, so a bye would mean a five-week layoff before the playoffs begin.

A first-round game would still leave a three-week break before postseason play. Teams that played in the first round of the past two CFPs are 7-1 in the quarterfinals, with Alabama’s loss to Indiana last year in the Rose Bowl the only exception.

For now, Notre Dame looks safely headed to the postseason. But as the schedule continues to lose its shine, Saturday was also a reminder of how valuable that win over Miami really was.

In Other News...

Boston College Has One Response Test After That Notre Dame Loss

Boston Colleges trip to South Bend ended in a lopsided 41-7 loss to No. 3 Notre Dame, a reminder of how steep the climb can get against one of the countrys best teams. Mason McKenzie finished 8 of 21 for 51 yards, and the Eagles struggled to generate much offense as Notre Dame kept stacking touchdowns and field goals to seize control early.

Still, there were a few small signs for Boston College to build on as it turns the page. The Eagles did get a rushing touchdown from Bo MacCormack III, and the offense will need more of that kind of production if it wants to make the next response test a more competitive one. [Read more 🡒]

Boston College Just Got Another Brutal Reality Check

Boston Colleges trip to South Bend brought another harsh reminder of how steep the climb remains. The Eagles fell 41-7 to No. 5 Notre Dame, a loss that extended their skid to three straight and left little doubt about the gap between the two programs on this afternoon.

The game was effectively settled long before the final whistle, with Notre Dame in control from the start and able to lean on its depth late. For BC, the bigger concern was the offense, which never found any rhythm and was overwhelmed by a defense that kept the Eagles pinned down for most of the day. [Read more 🡒]

Boston College Fans Witnessed A Notre Dame Moment Bigger Than The Game

The atmosphere around Boston Colleges trip to Notre Dame carried an added layer of emotion before the ball was even kicked, with NBC Sports broadcaster Jason Benetti stepping in behind the microphone after the unexpected death of longtime Notre Dame play-by-play voice Dan Hicks at 64. Hicks had been a fixture on NBC since 1992, and his reach went well beyond college football, with memorable work on PGA Tour events and the Olympics helping make him one of the networks most familiar voices.

For Boston College fans watching the game, the broadcast became part of the story in a way few regular-season matchups ever do. Benettis presence brought a different voice to a familiar setting, but the moment also underscored how much Hicks meant to Notre Dame and to NBCs larger sports audience, with his absence felt far beyond South Bend. [Read more 🡒]