Stephen A. Smith didn’t waste much time after Boston’s season-opening collapse before turning the spotlight on Jayson Tatum and the move that sent Jaylen Brown out the door.
On First Take, Smith praised Tatum first, then went straight at the decision to trade Brown to the Philadelphia 76ers after the Celtics blew a 22-point lead in a 121-103 loss to the Detroit Pistons.
“I don’t care anything about this game other than Jayson Tatum. Jayson Tatum is a superstar in this league.
He is class personified and one of the best people you could ever find. Boston loves him.
The Celtics love him. And whether they want to admit it or not, the die has been cast.
It clearly compromised your love for Jaylen Brown.”
Smith pointed to Brown’s production last season as the kind of proof he believes should have made a trade impossible.
“Jaylen Brown last year, without Jayson Tatum for the most part, led the Boston Celtics to 56 wins and a number two seed in the Eastern Conference. There is no way in hell that Jaylen Brown is gone, let alone traded within the division to the Philadelphia 76ers, if Jayson Tatum cares for that not to happen.”
He went even further, arguing that Tatum could have put a stop to it if he had pushed back.
“If Jayson Tatum stands up, ‘I don’t want to lose him. What do you mean you’re trading him?
He ain’t going nowhere. I want my man here,’ Jaylen Brown is still a Boston Celtic.
The fact that he is gone is because they wanted to make it clear it was Jayson Tatum’s team, and Jayson Tatum clearly did not mind.”
“Here is where Jayson Tatum may have miscalculated.”
That was Smith’s read on the situation, not proof that Tatum privately approved the move or had direct authority to block it.
Still, the optics are brutal for Boston after that opener. Tatum finished with 13 points, four rebounds, and 11 assists, but he shot 6 of 23 from the field and missed all seven of his three-point tries as the Celtics wilted down the stretch.
Paul George, the player Boston got back in the Jaylen Brown deal, was a bright spot in his Celtics debut. He scored 38 points and knocked down seven three-pointers, yet even that wasn’t enough to save Boston from the Pistons’ surge. Detroit owned the glass 49-39 and kept pounding the ball inside, while a 23-0 run flipped the game and left the Celtics chasing.
Brown, meanwhile, got his Philadelphia tenure started with a win. He posted 19 points, eight rebounds, and six assists on 7-of-14 shooting as the Sixers beat the defending champion Knicks 106-100.
It’s only one game, so nobody is going to settle the verdict on Boston’s choice just yet. George’s outing showed the Celtics still have firepower, but Smith’s criticism adds another layer of pressure on Tatum.
And with Brown now in Philadelphia, every big performance he puts together will keep dragging the Celtics back to the same question: why was this the split they chose?
In Other News...
Celtics Already Have A Payton Pritchard Problem They Promised To Fix
After the offseason trade of Jaylen Brown and a contract extension for Payton Pritchard, the Celtics entered the season with a clear expectation that his role would grow. Instead, the opener offered a familiar look. Pritchard came off the bench and was on the floor for 27 minutes, but his place in the offense never really changed in a way that suggested a new level of responsibility.
He still managed to score 17 points, tied for second on the team, but the way he got there looked more like last season than the next step Boston seemed to be promising. With limited involvement in the half-court and only one assist to show for the night, the question is already less about whether Pritchard can produce and more about how the Celtics plan to use him moving forward. [Read more 🡒]
Kendrick Perkins Just Turned Up The Pressure On The Celtics
Boston looked sharp in its first game against Detroit, a reminder that even with offseason changes, the Celtics still project as one of the leagues upper-tier teams. But the early-season vibe around this group has been complicated by the usual Boston standard: good regular-season play is expected, and the conversation always drifts quickly to whether the roster is truly built for June.
Kendrick Perkins added to that pressure with a blunt assessment of where the Celtics stand right now. The former Boston center drew a hard line between being good and being a real title threat, pointing to the roster as part of the concern and putting the spotlight squarely on Jayson Tatum in the process. For a team that has spent years being measured against championship expectations, it is the kind of outside criticism that lingers until the Celtics prove otherwise. [Read more 🡒]
Celtics Already Have A Starting Lineup Debate After Opening Loss
The Celtics opened their season with a loss to the Pistons, and it didnt take long for the first lineup question to surface. Boston got useful bench minutes from Baylor Scheierman and Sam Hauser, two forwards who brought some pop to the offense after checking in, which only sharpened the conversation about how the rotation should be shaped going forward.
There is already a case to be made for one of those shooters moving into the starting five to help create more spacing early in games, especially if the Celtics want a cleaner offensive rhythm out of the gate. The tougher part is figuring out who comes out to make room, and that decision will say plenty about how Boston wants to balance defense, energy and shot-making in the games ahead. [Read more 🡒]