Bill Simmons has stirred up an old Finals MVP argument again, and this time Jaylen Brown is back at the center of it.
On the latest episode of “The Bill Simmons Podcast,” the conversation turned to Brown after Joe House pointed out that the 2024 Finals MVP is no longer with the Boston Celtics. Simmons didn’t hold back from there, saying Brown should not have taken home the award.
"That was ridiculous," Simmons said. "One of my things that I would change about the NBA is more than five people should vote on the Finals MVP.
You should not be able to win Finals MVP by a 3-2 vote. Have 15 people.
You have a million reporters there."
Once the clip started making the rounds, Simmons took to X to soften the blow, while still standing by his larger point.
"I shouldn’t have said 'ridiculous,'" Simmons posted. "But I thought Tatum should have won and said it at the time - esp. after what he did in Game 5.
I’m always gonna think the best guy on a champ should win Finals MVP unless something insane happened. 2007 Duncan, 2010 Kobe, 2015 Curry Etc."
The numbers from the 2024 NBA Finals show why the debate never really died. Eleven media members voted, and Brown got seven of them while Jayson Tatum picked up four.
Brown finished as Boston’s second-leading scorer in the series at 20.8 points per game, shooting .440/.235/.733, and added 5.4 rebounds, 5.0 assists, 1.6 steals and 0.8 blocks. He also handled the Celtics’ primary defensive assignment on Luka Doncic.
Tatum led Boston in scoring at 22.2 points per game on .388/.263/.926 shooting, and he chipped in 7.8 rebounds, 7.2 assists, 1.0 steals and 0.6 blocks.
Simmons specifically pointed to Game 5, where Tatum put up 31 points, 11 assists and eight rebounds. Brown had 21 points, eight rebounds and six assists in that game, though he went just 7-for-23 from the floor.
Two years later, the Brown-Tatum Finals MVP debate is still hanging around.
In Other News...
Neemias Queta Could Give Celtics A New Option They May Need
Neemias Quetas next step with the Celtics is less about simply holding down the paint and more about stretching what Boston can ask of him. He said he wants to become more versatile and improve his mobility entering the season, with an eye toward taking advantage of favorable matchups as a kind of mismatch killer. For a team that is always looking for another dependable wrinkle, that sort of growth could matter.
Joe Mazzulla has already noticed signs of progress in Quetas confidence with the ball and his decision-making, and that gives Boston a reason to keep watching closely. Training camp will be the test case, the first real chance to see how much of that expanded role Queta can handle and whether it turns into a usable offensive option for a team that values versatility at every spot. [Read more 🡒]
Celtics New Duo Could Become An Awkward Clippers Reminder
Paul Georges arrival gives Boston a new kind of wing-heavy look, and it also invites an uncomfortable comparison to the franchise that once leaned into that same blueprint with great confidence. The Celtics have built around Jayson Tatum for years, but adding another proven perimeter star changes the conversation from simple depth to whether Boston now has the kind of two-wing core that can dictate playoff matchups the way the best modern contenders do.
There is a twist in the background, though, because the Clippers own history with that approach is part of the lens here. If Tatum and George click, it would only reinforce the idea that pairing elite wings was the right bet all along, even if Los Angeles never got the clean version of it to fully cash in. Georges age and the possibility of minutes limitations make the fit worth watching closely, and for Boston, the upside is obvious enough to keep the comparison lingering in the background. [Read more 🡒]
Bill Simmons Just Reopened A Celtics Debate Fans Never Escaped
Bill Simmons has a way of dragging old Celtics arguments back into the light, and his latest podcast comments did exactly that. He said Jayson Tatum should have been the 2024 NBA Finals MVP over Jaylen Brown, who took home seven of the 11 votes, then softened the phrasing a bit while still pointing back to Tatums Game 5 performance as the reason he felt the honor should have gone the other way.
Browns Finals case was always going to be measured against the bigger picture of Bostons title run, which is why the debate never really disappeared. It has only gotten stranger since the offseason trade that sent Brown to the Philadelphia 76ers, turning what used to be an internal Celtics conversation into one of those what-if discussions that still hangs around long after the confetti is gone. [Read more 🡒]