Bill Simmons doesn’t hide how ugly the Jaylen Brown trade felt to him, but he does think he understands why the Boston Celtics did it.
On SiriusXM Radio, Simmons said the Celtics may have looked at Paul George as the cleaner fit next to Jayson Tatum at this stage of Tatum’s career. He also pointed to the chance for Boston’s younger wings to take on more minutes and responsibility.
“I think one of the reasons they made the trade is they felt like he might be a better fit at this point in Tatum’s career. I think I agree with that.
As you guys know, I didn’t like the trade. I wish they didn’t do it.
But I think they were feeling like it was a better basketball fit, and I think they wanted some of their other younger swings to play more.”
That gives a pretty clear window into one of the summer’s most debated moves. Brown was never just another rotation piece in Boston.
He spent his whole career with the Celtics and grew into a franchise centerpiece alongside Tatum. Sending him to the Philadelphia 76ers, an Atlantic Division rival, was always going to demand a strong basketball explanation.
Simmons’ read is that Boston wasn’t questioning Brown’s ability. Instead, the team may have decided the Tatum-Brown pairing had already gone as far as it was going to go, and that the roster needed to be reshaped around Tatum.
George brings a different kind of value. Even now, he can supply shooting, length, and off-ball scoring without needing the same kind of offensive workload Brown required. In that version of the roster, Tatum becomes the clear focal point while the younger wings get a bigger slice of the action.
Whether that actually makes Boston better is another matter.
Simmons made it obvious how hard the deal was for him to stomach from the start. After the trade became official, he reacted with an NSFW line and said, “I think I died.”
It only got worse for Celtics fans after the move. Brown landed on a Philadelphia team that already had Joel Embiid and Tyrese Maxey, and because of Brown’s signing, the Sixers were able to add LeBron James in free agency too.
Simmons’ view was that Brown went from being a star in Boston to possibly becoming the fourth offensive option behind LeBron, Embiid, and Maxey.
Still, everything in Boston comes back to Tatum. If George proves to be the better fit and the younger wings grow into larger roles, the Celtics could stay in the championship mix. That’s the gamble behind the front office’s thinking.
But the cost was enormous: they sent a superstar to a direct conference rival to chase that vision. That’s what makes Simmons’ explanation so telling.
He can follow the logic. He can even see why the Celtics thought it might work.
He still wishes they never did it.
In Other News...
Celtics Are Back In The East Race For One Big Reason
The Celtics are back in the East conversation largely because they found a way to address the kind of frontcourt issue that can quietly cap a teams ceiling in the postseason. Adding Mitchell Robinson gives Boston another layer of interior presence, and for a team trying to stay in the mix with the conferences deeper contenders, that kind of move can matter just as much as a splashier name. In a season where several clubs are being floated as dark horse threats, the Celtics fit the profile of a team with enough talent to be taken seriously again.
Boston is hardly alone in that category. The broader league picture includes Minnesotas new-look ceiling with LaMelo Ball, Detroits rise with Cade Cunningham playing at an MVP level, and Indiana getting Tyrese Haliburton back from injury, all of which help explain why the East and West could both feel more open than expected. The Spurs surprise run to the 2026 NBA Finals is the reminder hanging over all of it: once the season starts, the teams nobody circles in advance can become the ones everyone else has to chase. [Read more 🡒]
Celtics Fans Have Every Reason To Debate This NBA Cup Draw
The NBA has already started laying out pieces of the 2026-27 calendar, and for Celtics fans, the early read is a familiar one: a season that will ask plenty of Boston before the games even start to matter in the standings. The leagues partial schedule includes an opening-night matchup with the Pistons and a Christmas Day slate featuring the Heat and Giannis Antetokounmpo, but the first real debate for Celtics watchers may come in the Emirates NBA Cup, where Boston landed in Group C with the Wizards, Hawks, Hornets and Bulls.
Group play begins on Oct. 30, and on paper it gives Boston a mix of rebuilding clubs and teams that have spent the summer trying to sharpen their edges. Washington, Charlotte and Chicago all come with their own roster questions, while Atlanta remains the most recognizable obstacle in the group. It is the sort of draw that invites instant arguments about who has the clearest path and who might spoil it, and for Celtics fans, the intrigue is less about the bracket itself than whether this set of opponents will turn out to be manageable or more annoying than it looks right now. [Read more 🡒]
Giannis Just Added Real Heat To Celtics Christmas Showdown
Giannis Antetokounmpo has a way of turning already-big games into something sharper, and now his new setting in Miami only adds another layer to an old Celtics-Heat rivalry that never really needs much help. Bostons Christmas Day matchup with the Heat was already going to draw attention, but the presence of a player with Antetokounmpos profile and track record gives the meeting a different kind of edge, the sort that usually comes with playoff-level grudges and a little extra noise.
The comments also fit the broader history between these teams, which has become one of the leagues most familiar sources of tension. For the Celtics, it is one more reminder that even a holiday showcase can carry real stakes when the opponent knows the rivalry, embraces it, and now has a star in the middle of it willing to publicly lean into the moment. [Read more 🡒]