Colby McCalister arrives in Waco with a reputation Baylor can use right away. The transfer safety followed defensive coordinator Joe Klanderman from Kansas State to Baylor this offseason, and the redshirt senior comes in as one of the highest-rated additions the Bears made over the past offseason.
That pedigree is exactly why McCalister checks in at No. 21 on the list of Baylor’s 25 most important players for 2026. He brings Big 12 experience, familiarity with Klanderman’s defense, and the kind of veteran presence that can matter in a secondary.
The biggest question, though, is simple: what does McCalister look like after nearly two years away from competitive football?
He missed the entire 2025 season with a knee injury suffered against Cincinnati in the final home game of his 2024 breakout year at Kansas State. Since then, the Houston native has been rehabbing and working to get back to full strength before Baylor opens its season.
McCalister’s 2024 season showed why Baylor wanted him. He played in 12 games for the Wildcats and started the final three, coming on against Colorado, Arizona State, and Cincinnati before the injury shut him down.
Over his time in Manhattan, Kan., he posted 61 tackles and seven pass breakups across two seasons. He also became a steady special teams contributor and a prominent leader on the kickoff team.
For Baylor, that background matters. McCalister is not just another transfer body in the secondary; he arrives with a clear understanding of how Klanderman wants his defense to function and with the kind of football maturity that comes from having already seen plenty of Big 12 action.
There is still uncertainty because he has not played in so long, but the upside is obvious. After more than 18 months of recovery, the 5-foot-10 safety enters his final college season with high expectations and a chance to make a real impact for the Bears. His speed, athleticism, and conference experience give him a strong case to be one of the most important players to watch on Baylor’s defense this fall.
In Other News...
Two Baylor Standouts Just Gave Bears Fans Another Reason To Celebrate
Baylor baseball got another dose of draft-day recognition when Lucas Davenport and Tyce Armstrong heard their names called in the 2026 Major League Baseball Draft. Davenport, a starting pitcher throughout his Baylor career, and Armstrong, one of the most productive bats in the programs recent history, both added pro baseball milestones to resumes that already made them fixtures in Waco.
The selections also underscored just how far both players had climbed in their time with the Bears. Davenports work on the mound gave Baylor a dependable arm, while Armstrong left campus with the schools single-season home run record after a huge year at the plate. For a program that prides itself on developing talent, seeing two standouts reach the draft is the kind of payoff that keeps the momentum rolling. [Read more 🡒]
ESPNs New Baylor Projection Feels Safe And Frustrating For Bears Fans
ESPNs updated Football Power Index landed on June 30 with a pretty familiar kind of Baylor outlook: respectable, bowl-adjacent and just vague enough to leave fans wanting more. The Bears check in 37th nationally with a 6.5 rating, good for sixth in the Big 12, and the projection pegs them at 6.6-5.5 with a 68.8% shot at reaching bowl eligibility.
The frustrating part is how crowded the middle of the league looks around them, with Baylor sitting only a sliver behind Houston and barely ahead of TCU in the model. Texas Tech is the clear conference favorite in ESPNs eyes, and that only sharpens the sense that Baylor is being slotted into the same old range of competitive but not quite threatening, unless something changes in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]