TCU returns from its bye week with the season hanging in a familiar kind of tension: enough talent to make you squint at the possibilities, but not enough offensive consistency to trust what comes next. That’s the setup as the Horned Frogs head down I-35 for the annual Revivalry against Baylor on Saturday at 6 p.m. CT at McLane Stadium.
The standings tell you plenty. TCU sits at 2-3 overall and 0-2 in Big 12 play after dropping its first two conference games.
Baylor comes in at 4-1 and 2-0, riding a four-game winning streak. On paper, that gives the Bears the clearer edge.
In a rivalry game, though, the comfort level never stays put for long.
That uncertainty is reflected in the KillerFrogs staff picks, even if the majority leaned Baylor’s way. Eleven staff members picked the Bears, while three went with TCU. Every TCU pick had the Frogs winning by seven points or fewer.
Aiden Reed went with Baylor 27-14.
JD Andress picked Baylor 20-13.
Ryann Zeller had Baylor 24-17.
Tom Burke selected Baylor 27-13.
Tori Couch went Baylor 24-10.
The logic behind those picks was rooted in the same concern: TCU’s defense has a chance to keep things competitive, but the offense has not shown nearly enough punch. As one prediction put it, “TCU’s defense should keep this close, but the Frogs have averaged just 11 points against Power Four opponents. Baylor has won four straight and enters with the more productive offense, so I’m picking the Bears to make one more scoring drive at home.”
Another staff view had a similar tone, noting, “I think TCU is going to look better after its bye week, but I don’t think the offense will create enough positive plays to win. The defense should stand out, though, and give Baylor’s offense some problems.”
A third forecast leaned on the possibility of a strong defensive showing but still doubted the offense would supply enough help: “It’s hard to find much belief that TCU wins this one without the offense finding a way to finish drives and establish some consistency. If Lagway plays like he did against Arizona State, it’s a tough matchup. But if he plays like he did against Auburn, the Frogs’ defense could make him pay.”
Other staff picks circled the same themes - a defense that can hold up for a while, an offense that still has to prove it can finish, and a Baylor team with enough balance to control the game if TCU doesn’t find rhythm early. One pick put it this way: “TCU continues to struggle on the road.
If the offense can’t put together quality drives, the Frogs’ defense will be worn out by the second half. Baylor’s offense has a well-rounded approach and could ultimately control the entire game.”
Another said, “If TCU finds an offensive rhythm, we could see a completely different outcome, but we have yet to see signs of one. Baylor blew out Arizona State on the road before the bye week and has the momentum.”
And one more forecast kept the emphasis on the opening stages: “TCU needs to start strong in the first half. Otherwise, coming back will be difficult, especially on the road. Baylor has a decent defense that could limit TCU’s rushing attack.”
The staff confidence chart has Seth Dowdle sitting on top at 4-1 entering the Baylor game. Everyone else is either 3-2 or 2-3, which is probably not the kind of separation anyone wants to brag about for long.
There is at least one thing TCU can point to heading into Waco: history. The Horned Frogs lead the all-time series 60-54-7 and have won nine of the past 11 meetings. That doesn’t solve the offense, but it does give TCU something tangible to carry into a rivalry that rarely behaves like the records suggest.
For the Frogs, that matters. This season has already pushed the optimism around the program around quite a bit, and a win here would be a clean way to put some of it back in place.
In Other News...
Baylor Could Benefit From A CFP Shift Fans May Not Love
The College Football Playoff is again on the verge of a major makeover, and for Baylor the possible ripple effect cuts both ways. A larger field has been discussed as a path to giving more programs from the Big 12 a real postseason lane, which would be a welcome development for a league that has often had to fight for access against the sports traditional powers.
For Bears fans, the upside is obvious because more spots should mean more chances to stay in the hunt deep into November. But the broader concern is harder to ignore, since a wider playoff can also dull some of the urgency that makes the regular season matter so much. Baylor would likely see the benefits of the shift, yet the sport may have to decide whether the extra inclusion is worth what gets lost along the way. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Faces Its Biggest Test Yet Against A National Power
Week 7 in the Big 12 brings a slate that should tell us a lot about where the league is headed, with a top-10 BYU-Notre Dame matchup grabbing the national spotlight and rivalry pressure hanging over Kansas and Kansas State. There is also a ranked meeting between Oklahoma State and Houston, the kind of game that can reshape momentum quickly in a conference where every week seems to carry bigger stakes.
For Baylor, the most relevant subplot is the continued rise of the quarterback play that has given the Bears a real pulse in league play. The offense has leaned on a young passer who has settled in quickly, and after his last outing he has started to look like someone defenses have to account for every snap. How he handles the next step will matter not just for Baylor's immediate ceiling, but for how seriously the rest of the Big 12 has to treat the Bears in the weeks ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Baylor Faces A TCU Showdown With Real Pressure On Aranda
The 122nd meeting between Baylor and TCU arrives with the familiar edge of a rivalry game, but this one carries extra weight because both sides have built early identity around defense. The matchup is expected to be a tight, low-scoring grind, the kind of Saturday that can hinge on one turnover, one field position swing, or one possession late.
For Dave Aranda, the stakes around this game go well beyond the rivalry banner. Baylor has shown enough to make fans believe there is something real to build on, and this trip into a major Big 12 measuring stick has only sharpened expectations. A win would give the Bears a strong early footing in the league race and a jolt of momentum in a season where every step forward matters. [Read more 🡒]