Natalie Vatter Became A Baylor Standard At The Perfect Time

After transferring from Ole Miss, Natalie Vatter has transformed into a cornerstone of Baylor's soccer success, demonstrating remarkable growth both on the field and in her personal journey.

Natalie Vatter arrived at Baylor in January 2023 with a fresh start in front of her and plenty to sort through behind her.

After a first semester at Ole Miss that ended with no game action, she came to Waco as a redshirt freshman on a team she barely knew. Four years later, she’s a fixture on Baylor’s back line, a fifth-year senior who coach Michelle Lenard calls the “most humble, hard-working, dedicated, team-first player you could ever possibly ask for,” and one of the reasons the Bears are hosting Lamar in the first round of the NCAA Tournament on Friday night.

“She works so hard, she plays so many hard, relentless minutes for us,” Lenard said of the second-seeded Bears, who are 17-4-1 and will face Lamar, 12-2-5, at 7 p.m. Friday at Betty Lou Mays Field. “She’s such a tough, lockdown defender, and she has given so much to this team.”

That growth didn’t happen instantly. Vatter said confidence was hard to come by when she first stepped into a Baylor program that was still digging out from a four-win season in Lenard’s first year.

“But the team, the coaches and the whole program being so welcoming definitely helped me with that,” she said. “Having the coaches pour into me in a leadership way and challenge me to lead both on and off the field, I’ve become a lot more confident.

I’ve grown not only as a soccer player but also in my leadership. It’s super neat being able to lead all the younger girls and be a fifth-year, which is kind of crazy.

I feel so old.”

Vatter’s own story mirrors Baylor’s rise. The Bears missed the NCAA Tournament in her first two seasons in Waco, then reached the Sweet 16 a year ago, advanced to the Big 12 Championship finals this season and earned one of the top eight national seeds.

“We’ve grown a lot,” she said. “The program has grown, and it’s definitely grown me as well.”

Her path to Baylor started with a redshirt year at Ole Miss that changed her outlook on everything. The all-state defender from Mountain Vista High School in Highlands Ranch, Colo., said that decision “changed how my whole semester went.”

“As the season went on, I learned that the style of play and what I was being taught as an outside back wasn’t really how I like to play,” she said. “I just felt like if I want to be somewhere for four years and make an impact, I didn’t think this is the right fit for me.”

Baylor wasn’t a school she had circled for years, even though she had been to a camp in Waco in eighth grade. Her dad saw it as a chance for a reset and told her it was a “great opportunity to be part of a rebuilding program and have a fresh start somewhere.”

She kept looking elsewhere, but Baylor kept pulling at her.

“I was looking at other schools as well,” she said, “but all along, there was just something in my heart that Baylor was where I was supposed to be. I committed in December, and these have been the best four years I could have asked for.”

On the field, Vatter has been part of a Baylor defense that has changed shape around her. Last season, she played alongside twins Hallie and Hannah Augustyn and Blythe Obar in front of All-Big 12 goalkeeper Azul Alvarez, helping the Bears pile up 12 shutouts.

“I was so used to playing with the twins and Blythe,” Natalie said. “That was a group that had been at Baylor for a couple years. We knew each other, and we knew how to play together.”

This year’s back line looks very different, with first-year transfers Sydney Miller from Tennessee and Bella James from Texas A&M and second-year transfer Nyela Calnek from Vanderbilt joining the mix. The shutout total has dropped to five, but Baylor still carries a 1.13 goals-against average through 22 games.

“With all new girls, it took us a little bit at first to learn our strengths, our weaknesses and how we played with each other,” Natalie said. “Obviously, having Azul back there really helped, too, as that safety net.

But I’m so proud of the way we’ve grown in our confidence and in all aspects of the game. I thought our center backs, in particular, had a fantastic tournament.

I’m super proud of all three of them.”

For a defender who has started 75 of her 83 career games, goals haven’t exactly come in bunches. But her second career score might be the one she remembers most. In the Big 12 quarterfinals, she lofted what looked like a cross and watched it find the net in Baylor’s 1-nil win over 25th-ranked Houston.

“Getting that game-winning goal felt surreal,” she said. “I’m not sure how much time was left, maybe eight minutes, but I knew we had to get something across.

I was just trying to get something in front of the keeper, back post. If it goes in, great.

And if it’s a cross, (freshman Grace White) was going to be right there to score.

“Even the Texas Tech game (2-1 win in semifinals), they beat us earlier in the season, so getting two wins like that, I honestly can’t even describe the joy we felt after those two games.”

The biggest change for Vatter, though, may have come off the field. She said her faith has deepened in a major way during her time at Baylor, and she now leads the team Bible studies.

“I’m grateful that God brought me here, because my faith has completely taken off,” she said. “I lead our team Bible studies now. Which, honestly, if you had asked me a couple years ago, I’d have said there’s no way I’d do that.

“When you get to college, you really get to take your faith and make it your own. Especially over the last couple years, I think our team has grown a lot in our faith. I’ve been so lucky to lead the team in that way, and it’s challenged me to dive deeper into the word and grow my faith, so that I can make an impact on my team as well.”

Vatter is set to graduate in May with a degree in health science studies. She hopes to pursue physical therapy school eventually, but first wants to see where soccer can take her.

“I was still going back and forth, asking God what do you want me to do with my future,” she said. “With PT school, at this point, I would have already applied and made that plan.

But I kept being called to at least pursue it. If a door opens, great.

If a door is closed, that’s how it’s meant to be. I hope to play for a couple years and then maybe do PT school.

But pro soccer is what I’m going to try first.”

In Other News...

Baylor Just Tied Its Momentum To A Massive New Athletics Vision

Baylor has spent the fall stacking momentum across the board, with recent success showing up in volleyball, womens and mens basketball, and soccer, while the football team has already pushed itself into bowl eligibility with one home game left under interim coach Joe Klanderman. It is the kind of across-the-department lift that athletic directors like to point to when they talk about culture, and Baylor is now putting a major financial marker on that moment.

The school announced Fueling Greatness, a four-year, $200 million initiative designed to expand resources, scholarships, facilities and faith-based formation for student-athletes. For a program already trying to turn on-field and on-court progress into something more durable, the size and scope of the plan signal that Baylor wants its recent run of success to be the start of a longer push, not just a good stretch in one season. [Read more 🡒]

Texas Techs Postseason Outlook Just Got A Lot More Interesting

With two weeks left in the college football regular season, the Big 12 bowl picture is still shifting, and that means there is plenty for Baylor fans to keep an eye on beyond their own teams finish. CBS Sports latest projections have the conference spread across a range of postseason destinations, with Utah pegged for the Rose Bowl and Texas Tech slotted into the College Football Playoff opening round.

For the rest of the league, the forecast is just as fluid, with Big 12 teams scattered through projections for the Alamo Bowl, Liberty Bowl and Texas Bowl. Those matchups are still tied to rankings and how the final stretch plays out, so there is no shortage of movement left before the postseason field settles in. [Read more 🡒]

Baylor Faces A Huge Defensive Test In Final Home Game

Baylors final home game of the season comes with a familiar sort of urgency, only this time the challenge is coming from a Texas Tech offense built to stress a defense in every direction. The Bears have spent the week zeroing in on open-field tackling and perimeter defense, two areas that will be tested immediately by the Red Raiders speed and the way they can stretch a game horizontally.

Head coach Joe Klanderman also pointed to Texas Techs recent quarterback change to Thomas Castellanos as another wrinkle Baylor has to sort through before kickoff. With the No. 2 team in the Big 12 coming to Waco, the Bears will need to lean on both sides of the ball if they want to make their last home date count. [Read more 🡒]