Week 1 always sells hope first. Then the games start, and for a few fan bases, the rug gets pulled out before September even settles in.
Rutgers took the hardest hit of the opening weekend. The Scarlet Knights came into Thursday night as heavy favorites over UMass, only to fall 37-21 at home in a result that left their supporters sounding less frustrated than broken.
Rutgers was supposed to cruise; instead, the loss sent fans spiraling, with one post likening the reaction to Titanic passengers abandoning ship. Another fan called it “the single saddest thing l've ever seen,” pointing to Rutgers paying UMass $1.5M to play them Week 1 as 30-point favorites only to lose and then set off a pre-planned fireworks show postgame.
Even the most loyal backers were venting that they’ve spent years showing up, believing, and getting little back.
Baylor’s pain was different, but no less sharp. The Bears were underdogs against Auburn and stayed alive long enough to take a shot at the win, going for a two-point conversion with nine seconds left.
They came up inches short, and that was enough to turn a competitive night into a gut punch. The frustration wasn’t just about losing; it was about how familiar the ending felt.
One fan said the defeat brought an overwhelming sense of depression, while another argued the pattern has become too familiar under Dave Aranda to inspire much confidence. There was also anger over the final play itself, with one post blaming DJ Lagway and calling it “Great play call.
Terrible throw.”
Vanderbilt also gave its fans a strange kind of misery: a win that didn’t feel all that reassuring. The Commodores beat FCS Austin Peay 28-9, but life without Diego Pavia looked messy enough to leave plenty of supporters uneasy about what comes next.
Some fans left the game feeling worse about the season, not better, and one pointed out that the bigger story may be how much the last two years depended on Pavia. There was also noise from the stands about five-star quarterback Jared Curtis mostly watching from the sideline, which only added to the unease around a win that was supposed to calm things down.
Michigan escaped with a 13-12 win over Western Michigan, but it took a deeply controversial, or more accurately deeply errant, timing call to make it possible. The Wolverines survived on a Hail Mary and then stormed the field, a scene that split the fan base between relief and embarrassment.
Some were thrilled to get out alive, but others couldn’t get past the fact that this was the shape of the night in Week 1. One fan said, “I’m filled with so much disgust from that game last night.
Cannot get over it. What a shameful product to put on the field” Another simply wrote, “storming the field for Western Michigan wasn't on my bingo card”
Then there was Clemson, which may have had the bleakest final score of all. LSU was on the road, yes, but that doesn’t make a 51-10 loss any easier to swallow for a fan base that spent the offseason waiting for better things.
Instead, the Tigers looked overmatched, and the reaction was immediate and brutal. Some fans were already talking about the next week, the attendance, and what Dabo should do after what one poster called “this 4-8 season.”
Others said they were disappointed but not shocked, with one declaring the program “officially a dead program” and another calling for a reset.
For a week built on possibility, these fan bases got something else entirely: a reminder that September can be cruel.
In Other News...
Dave Aranda Just Put Baylors Biggest Preseason Concern Back In Focus
Dave Aranda spent part of his latest injury update doing what coaches at this point in the season usually do: sorting out who can go, who is close, and who is still waiting for a little more time. DJ Lagway is day-to-day and was available for a walkthrough, while Kaden Sieracki, Kolton Sieracki and Jadon Porter are also listed as day-to-day with lower leg injuries. For a Baylor team still trying to settle into a rhythm, the health of that group matters because every practice rep and every available body starts to carry a little more weight once September gives way to the games that count most.
Aranda also addressed the loss of safety Jacob Redding, who was lost for the season with a torn ACL before it even began, and it is the kind of setback that keeps a preseason concern from ever really going away. He stressed the need to keep stacking wins in the upcoming stretch and said he believes in what this team can become, but the broader picture is still easy to see: Baylors margin for error depends heavily on how quickly those injured players can return and how much stability the Bears can regain on that side of the ball. [Read more 🡒]
Baylor's Week 2 Suddenly Hinges On DJ Lagway's Mobility
DJ Lagways right ankle injury turned Baylors Week 1 into a much different kind of game than the Bears likely expected, and now the ripple effects are carrying straight into Week 2. Head coach Dave Aranda called the quarterback day-to-day after Lagway was limited in his mobility for the rest of the contest, a situation that immediately changed how Baylor could operate on offense.
The biggest concern is less about the label attached to the injury than what it means for the Bears game plan if Lagway still cant move freely. Baylor had to cut back on running plays that depend on his legs, and Aranda said the team will keep evaluating him throughout the week before deciding how much of the offense it can fully open up again. [Read more 🡒]
Aranda's Gamble Just Fueled A Bigger Baylor Debate
Dave Aranda kept leaning into the same trait that has defined plenty of his biggest calls in Waco: he trusts aggression over caution. Against Auburn, Baylor put itself in position to leave with a tie, and Aranda opted for the more daring path late instead of settling for the extra point. It fit a pattern that has shown up before, whether on fourth down or in short-yardage moments, and it once again put the Bears in a spot where one decision became the story.
The play itself moved Baylor close enough to make the building hold its breath, with the pass to Matt Klopfenstein finished but not quite reaching the line Baylor needed. From there, the rest became familiar and frustrating for a team that has lived through the consequences of these gambles before. The onside kick failed, Auburn escaped 17-16, and the bigger debate around Aranda's instincts only got louder. [Read more 🡒]