Ravens Backup Quarterback Debate Just Got A Lot More Interesting

With strategic missteps placing the Colts in a precarious position, Carli Irsay-Gordon's management decisions, particularly involving Daniel Jones, cast a long shadow over the franchise's future.

The Colts have turned their quarterback room into a blank slate, and Daniel Jones is the latest piece to disappear from it.

Indianapolis cut Jones with seven games left in the regular season, even though he still had another year on his contract. That move came after the team had already dealt Quenton Nelson and DeForrest Buckner before the trade market could fully develop, then passed on offers for Jonathan Taylor and Jones. Taylor is now in a backfield by committee, while Jones is gone entirely, leaving the Colts with nothing in return for a quarterback they paid $60 million for and played in 11 games.

That’s the part that makes this so hard to ignore: Jones was not some throwaway backup. He was the fifth-best quarterback in EPA per play over the first 10 games of the 2025 season.

In 2025, the Colts were operating with a strong running game, a good-enough offensive line, three warm bodies at wide receiver and a gifted play-caller, and the offense was humming at a level the source compared to the Greatest Show on Turf. Jones also had a strong 2022 season, when he was good enough to help the Giants reach the playoffs under first-year coach Brian Daboll.

None of that makes him a star, and the source is clear about that. “Jones is Jones.”

But the argument here is that even that version of Jones is still better than what most teams are forced to live with at backup quarterback. As the source puts it, this is “a marked improvement over, like, 75% of the backup quarterbacks in the NFL.”

With quarterback injuries and turnover piling up across the league, that matters more than ever. Since 2020, no more than 14 teams have made it from Week 1 to the end of the season with their starter still in place.

The Colts’ handling of the position looks even stranger when stacked against what other teams have done. The Ravens traded real draft capital for Jacoby Brissett, and the Vikings sent the Raiders a third-round pick for Kirk Cousins.

Meanwhile, Indianapolis has emptied out its depth chart and is now staring at the 2027 season “below ground zero” at the most important position, all without adding draft capital to help move up for a starter. That is especially awkward because the Colts do not own their 2026 first-round pick.

Owner Carli Irsay-Gordon is at the center of it all. She has become a visible presence on game days, and the source says that can be admirable and useful when things are stable.

But once the front office starts making decisions like this, that same visibility starts to look a lot more frustrating. Irsay-Gordon fired the team’s general manager, and Ed Dodd now has to prove himself to stay in the job.

The result, in the source’s view, is a front office mess: trading a great offensive lineman but keeping the running back with no one to run behind, trading the wide receiver and keeping the quarterback with no one to throw to, then cutting the quarterback anyway.

The source also notes that Irsay-Gordon is now on the hook for paying Jones and, likely, the remainder of Shane Steichen’s contract if he ends up coaching somewhere else next season. That’s the price of the reset.

There is a defense for the approach, of course. Maybe Irsay-Gordon is simply finished with the “bulls---” after an underperforming roster failed to deliver.

A scorched-earth response can feel justified after a bad prime-time showing. But even in that kind of teardown, the Colts’ path still looks thin compared with other teams that have burned things down and at least collected enough draft capital to soften the blow.

Indianapolis does have 12 picks in the upcoming draft, but only three sit inside the top 100. Riley Leonard is under contract at quarterback only for next season, and the team still needs a new head coach and, likely, a new general manager. That leaves the Colts with a lot of work and not much margin for error.

Right now, the picture is bleak. The source’s final image says it best: it’s dark, and Irsay-Gordon is wearing sunglasses.

In Other News...

Ravens Face One Lamar Jackson Decision Tied Closely To DeCosta

Eric DeCosta is taking heat as the Ravens sit at 4-6, and the pressure around his job is starting to spill into one of the most important decisions on the roster. His relationship with Lamar Jackson has long been one of the organizations biggest assets, and now it sits at the center of the conversation as Baltimore weighs how to steady the franchise moving forward.

Jacksons next contract extension is already a complicated matter, with a significant cap hit and no agent in the picture, so continuity matters here more than usual. If the Ravens decide to make a change at general manager, it could add another layer of uncertainty to talks with their quarterback, which is why DeCostas standing inside the building may wind up being tied closely to how Baltimore handles its most important player. [Read more 🡒]

Ravens May Need Adam Randall Sooner Than Anyone Expected

The Ravens are running into the kind of offensive problems that can force a team to rethink its depth chart on the fly. With the line struggling and the running game losing some of its punch, Derrick Henry has not been as effective as Baltimore would like, and that has created a need for answers beyond the usual ground-and-pound formula.

Adam Randall is suddenly part of that conversation after being activated from Injured Reserve, and the rookie could see more snaps sooner than expected as Baltimore looks for ways to keep its offense moving. Broncos coach Sean Payton has already highlighted Randalls receiving ability and versatility, projecting him as a hybrid piece who can fill multiple roles, which makes him an intriguing option for a Ravens team searching for flexibility. [Read more 🡒]

Ravens May Be Headed Toward A Painful Marlon Humphrey Decision

Marlon Humphreys season has already taken an uneasy turn, and the Ravens are now facing a conversation that would have sounded unlikely not long ago. The veteran cornerback has struggled, and his recent inactive status, reportedly tied to comments made on a podcast, only added to the sense that Baltimores secondary is in a delicate spot as the team looks ahead.

One possible answer may not arrive until the 2027 NFL Draft, where ESPNs Jordan Reid projects Baltimore to target Georgia cornerback Ellis Robinson IV. It is still early, but the idea of the Ravens using premium draft capital on a cornerback underscores how much uncertainty surrounds Humphreys future, and whether the team could be preparing to move on after this season. [Read more 🡒]