Ed Reed had a way of making quarterbacks second-guess everything, and Eli Manning learned that lesson the hard way.
On The Colin Cowherd Podcast, the two-time Super Bowl MVP said he never really looked at the Hall of Fame Baltimore Ravens safety and saw a player he could pick apart from the film room. In fact, Manning thought the tape suggested a chance to attack Reed.
.@EliManning tells @colincowherd the NFL player who was much better in game than on film pic.twitter.com/89bhqpFepW
— The Volume (@TheVolumeSports) October 31, 2026
“You kind of saw it on film that he was smooth, {but} you're kind of watching it and you're like, ‘well, I don't think Ed's doing the right thing here. Maybe that was a bust and we can take advantage of it,'” Manning recalled while appearing on The Colin Cowherd Podcast.
“Then you realize he's just smarter. He just knew how to read eyes, and he was just such a natural, attracted to the ball.
He was like the scariest person.
“I just didn't want to throw near him, because I knew if a ball wasn't perfectly thrown and hit my guy right in the numbers, then somehow he was going to end up with it.”
That kind of reaction fits Reed’s reputation. He wasn’t just confusing on Sundays; he was the kind of defender who made even a prepared quarterback feel like the game was moving faster than the film suggested.
Manning’s rookie season in 2004 provided one of the clearest examples. In a December meeting with the Ravens, he completed only 4 of 18 passes for 27 yards and two interceptions, with Reed grabbing one of them. The Giants were beaten 37-14, and New York even pulled Manning in the second half.
The rough afternoon didn’t define Manning’s career, but it did serve as a warning sign about what happens when Reed is on the other side. The Miami Hurricanes product finished that season with nine interceptions for 358 yards and won Defensive Player of the Year, the first of five First-Team All-Pro nods.
So much for the idea that the film had Reed figured out. Manning’s takeaway was simple: Reed was smarter, faster in his reads, and always closer to the ball than it looked. Watching the tape, in this case, only made the trap harder to see.
In Other News...
Ravens Playmakers Could Feast In Buffalo For One Big Reason
The Ravens head to Buffalo with playoff stakes hanging over the matchup, and the timing could be just right for Baltimores passing game to make noise. Lamar Jackson is expected back after missing three games with an ankle injury, which changes the complexion of the offense immediately and gives the Ravens a much different look than theyve had lately. Against a Bills defense that has had trouble holding up against the pass, Baltimore has reason to believe its playmakers can find space in the red zone.
Zay Flowers is among the names to watch most closely, especially with the Ravens likely needing efficient production through the air to keep pace in a game that should matter deep into the AFC race. Dalton Kincaid and JaKobi Lane also fit into the broader picture of a matchup where touchdown opportunities could come from several directions. For Baltimore, the appeal is simple: if the passing game is clicking and Buffalo keeps leaking yardage through the air, the Ravens have multiple ways to turn that into points. [Read more 🡒]
Ravens Red Zone Problems Are Raising Bigger Questions Entering A Critical Week
The Ravens red zone issues have become hard to ignore, and they arrive at a moment when the offense is still trying to find its footing around Lamar Jacksons return. Baltimore has shuffled through multiple offensive line combinations, and the lack of consistency has shown up in the way the unit has operated near the goal line, where the passing game has been used sparingly and the margin for error has shrunk.
Vega Ioanes knee injury only adds another layer to the problem, pushing the Ravens into yet another starting line setup as they head into a critical week. The timing matters because the offense is not the only concern, either. Baltimores defense has also been under pressure, with the numbers pointing to trouble generating heat on the quarterback and getting off the field on third down, which leaves the team searching for answers on both sides of the ball. [Read more 🡒]