Tyler Wells has spent his career taking the long way into the picture, and now he’s suddenly in the middle of Baltimore’s ninth-inning conversation.
The Orioles right-hander was never the obvious bet to become a late-game weapon. He came into pro ball as a 15th-round pick by the Twins in 2016, taken 453rd overall out of Cal State San Bernardino. He got as far as Double-A in 2018 with a 2.49 ERA and 121 strikeouts in 119⅓ innings, then everything changed: Tommy John surgery in May 2019, the wiped-out 2020 minor league season, and a Rule 5 draft move that sent him to Baltimore after Minnesota left him unprotected.
For a 6-foot-8 pitcher with a rebuilt elbow and a fastball that didn’t exactly scream certainty, the odds were steep from the start. Rule 5 picks have to stay on the active roster all season or be offered back, and most never make it.
Across the 2018 and 2019 drafts combined, only seven of 25 picks - 28% - cleared that hurdle. Wells did more than survive it.
He stuck with the Orioles in 2021, made 44 appearances, and turned in a 4.11 ERA with a .192 average against and a 0.91 WHIP.
That was enough to move him into the rotation in 2022, and by 2023 he had become one of Baltimore’s best starters. The first half of that season was a revelation: through 18 starts, Wells posted a 3.18 ERA and an MLB-best 0.93 WHIP.
But the workload caught up with him. By late July, he had reached 113⅔ innings, a career high, and the next stretch went sideways fast - an 11.00 ERA over his following nine innings, three rough starts in a row, and a trip down to Double-A Bowie.
He worked his way back and finished 2023 with eight scoreless outings between the regular season and the playoffs, but the durability questions never really went away. Elbow inflammation sent him back to the injured list in 2024, and after three starts it was announced he needed right elbow UCL surgery. He made just four starts in 2025.
So when 2026 arrived, Wells was not a sure thing for anything. Mike Elias had said in the fall that the plan was for Wells to start, but with Shane Baz, Zach Eflin, Chris Bassitt, Kyle Bradish, Trevor Rogers and Dean Kremer in the mix, nothing was guaranteed. Baltimore opened the year with Wells in the bullpen instead, using him as its top right-handed setup man ahead of new closer Ryan Helsley.
Even before the ninth-inning turn, the season was going well. From his March 26 debut through July 1, Wells made 30 appearances and looked healthy again.
He also pitched well, posting a 3.18 ERA in 39.2 innings while working mostly in the sixth and seventh. Then Helsley felt discomfort warming up against the White Sox in early July and went on the 15-day injured list with right elbow discomfort.
He avoided structural UCL damage, but the opening was there, and Wells got the call.
He has run with it. In nine games since moving into the higher-leverage role, Wells has a 1.93 ERA and has allowed just one run over his last five appearances.
He was scoreless in six of seven outings that month. Craig Albernaz has not named him the permanent closer, saying Andrew Kittredge and Yennier Cano are still in the mix and that “everything is on the table.”
But for now, the ninth inning belongs to Wells.
It’s an unusual path, but not an unearned one. Baltimore never drew this up, and Wells certainly didn’t arrive with the profile of a future closer. Yet after everything his career has been through, he’s the one standing there when the Orioles need the last three outs.
In Other News...
Orioles Cannot Let This Rotation Fix Slip Away At The Deadline
The Orioles are heading into the deadline with a rotation question that could shape the rest of their season, and the next stretch will help determine how aggressively they act. If the club decides it needs help, the market may offer a rare chance to add a controllable starter with years of team control left, which matters for a Baltimore team trying to balance the present with a deeper run ahead.
Los Angeles could be willing to move controllable pitchers as it starts a rebuild, but that kind of opportunity usually comes at a real cost. Baltimore has the farm depth to make a serious offer, yet landing a pitcher with strong underlying indicators despite an ordinary ERA will likely require giving up more than a low-level flier, and the Orioles will have to decide how much future talent they are willing to spend to keep this rotation fix from slipping away. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Top Prospect Ike Irish Faces A Brutal Injury Setback
The Orioles player development pipeline took a hit this week when Ike Irish landed on High-A Fredericks injured list after a knee injury, a tough turn for the clubs first pick in the 2025 draft and its No. 2 prospect. Irish had been one of the most closely watched young players in the system, so any extended absence immediately changes the conversation around Baltimores next wave of talent.
The setback was part of a rough stretch across the lower levels, with Delmarva infielder Cobb Hightower also undergoing ACL reconstruction and meniscus repair. Baltimore did make a pitching move to help cover the roster, recalling left-hander Josh Walker from Triple-A Norfolk, but the bigger concern for the organization is how much development time it stands to lose with two notable infield prospects suddenly sidelined. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Ownership Just Weighed In On Mike Elias Before The Deadline
The Orioles used Kyle Bradishs five-year, $90 million extension as more than just a celebration of a homegrown arm. At a press conference announcing the deal, president of baseball operations Mike Elias and control owner David Rubenstein both tried to reinforce the bigger message around the organization: the club believes in where it is headed, and it is willing to keep investing in that direction as it builds around its core.
Rubenstein also made clear that the front office is not treating this as a one-off move, saying the team is open to more long-term deals with players who want to stay. With the Trade Deadline approaching, that matters for a club still trying to keep its season on track, and it puts a little extra weight on the next stretch of games as Baltimore sorts out whether its future is best served by adding, extending, or simply standing pat. [Read more 🡒]