Orioles Suddenly Face A Real Samuel Basallo Question Behind The Plate

Baltimore Orioles' interest in Hunter Goodman highlights a potential shift in their catcher strategy, sparking questions about Samuel Basallos role next season.

The Orioles went into the offseason with a clear need behind the plate, but the name that surfaced in their search is a lot bigger than the kind of stopgap most people expected.

According to Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic, Baltimore has called the Colorado Rockies to check in on All-Star catcher Hunter Goodman. Talks apparently haven’t gone far yet, but the mere fact that the Orioles are in the mix for a bat like that raises the obvious question: what does it mean for Samuel Basallo?

At first glance, it looks like the kind of move that could crowd the picture at catcher. But the more you dig into it, the less this feels like a repeat of the Adley Rutschman situation.

Basallo is coming off his first full season in the majors, and the offensive line was uneven: .222/.291/.406 with 18 homers in 112 games. The bigger issue was his work behind the plate, where the finer points of catching at the big-league level still need polish. Even so, it would be strange to treat him like a finished product after one season.

The Orioles already made the pivot from Rutschman to Carlos Narvaez at the trade deadline, and that didn’t go smoothly. Narvaez hit just .104/.198/.117 with Baltimore and finished at .187/.260/.275 overall in 2026. He still has options and won’t reach arbitration until next offseason, which makes him a logical third catcher to keep in Norfolk if he can sort things out in Triple-A and rebound from a rough year.

That’s part of why the Goodman report stands out. Baltimore was widely expected to shop in the Carson Kelly range or below - the kind of catcher who could share time, step in if Basallo faltered, or take over in a pinch.

Kelly would fit a timeshare, though he might prefer a clearer route to a starting job. Austin Hedges and players in that mold seemed more like the Orioles’ lane.

Goodman is a different level of target because the bat is the draw. He hit .245/.310/.529 with 41 homers in 2026, and it wasn’t just a Coors Field boost.

He posted an .882 OPS on the road and a .791 OPS in Colorado. For a lineup that already has Pete Alonso, adding another 40-homer threat would be a serious jolt.

Defensively, though, Basallo still looks like the better player in the physical tools department. He ranked in the 73rd percentile in pitch blocking and the 69th percentile in throwing out basestealers, helped by a 1.92-second pop time.

Framing was the glaring weak spot, with Basallo landing in the ninth percentile. Goodman, meanwhile, checked in at the 40th percentile in framing, the 29th percentile in blocking, and the 17th percentile in controlling the running game.

That’s why the most logical version of a Goodman addition wouldn’t have to push Basallo aside. The idea would be to use Goodman mostly at DH, with the flexibility to catch when needed. In that setup, Basallo wouldn’t be blocked, and Baltimore would still get the extra power it’s chasing.

The Orioles need offense, and Mike Elias would be trying to land a cost-controlled slugger who remains under team control for three more years. That kind of move could also free up money to address the starting rotation. While many have assumed the outfield is the likeliest place to find a major bat, Goodman’s power is stronger than what Baltimore is likely to find in free agency.

Scott Boras said the Orioles “have the ability” to add big this winter, as they do every year with Rubenstein, Arougheti and more in that ownership group.

“Everything we’ve heard from the Orioles every offseason is that they’re trying to add, trying to advance,” he said

The real question is whether Baltimore is willing to pay the prospect price. Elias could probably put together enough from the farm system to get Colorado’s attention, especially with the Rockies’ ongoing need for talented young pitching. Whether he wants to spend that capital is another matter.

In Other News...

Orioles Revisit A Risky Reunion That Could Split Fans

Luis Robert Jr.s time in Baltimore got off to a rough start when a hamstring strain interrupted his early run with the club, and the Orioles later declined his $20 million club option. Even so, his name is back in the conversation this offseason, with Baltimore among several teams reportedly interested in the veteran center fielder as he weighs his next move on the free-agent market.

The fit is easy to understand, even if the reaction might not be. Robert still brings the kind of upside that can tempt a front office looking for center-field help, but his recent production has been uneven because of injuries, which is exactly why this reunion would come with real risk. He may not land a major long-term deal, but he is expected to look for a chance to rebuild his value and put himself in position to bounce back in 2027. [Read more 🡒]

Orioles Suddenly Have A Real Chance At The Upgrade They Need

The Orioles have spent much of the season looking for a jolt in the middle of the lineup, and Ketel Marte has emerged as a name worth watching. Baltimore has engaged in discussions with the Diamondbacks about a possible deal, a sign the club is at least exploring a more aggressive path to address an obvious need. Martes all-around profile makes him the kind of player who can change the look of an offense quickly, which is why interest in him has spread beyond one front office.

What makes this one especially interesting is the price Baltimore may have to consider if it wants to stay in the conversation. Reports suggest the Orioles could be willing to discuss infield prospect Jordan Westburg along with pitching prospects Joseph Dzierwa and Caden Hunter, a reminder that meaningful upgrades rarely come cheap. With Martes situation in Arizona already viewed as unsettled and several teams involved, the Orioles are suddenly in a real race for a player who could alter their roster construction in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]

Orioles Just Locked In Key Pieces During A Crucial Offseason Week

The Orioles spent a busy offseason week tightening up the edges of their roster while making sure a few core pieces stay in place. Baltimore signed closer Flix Bautista to a one-year contract and tendered deals to Gunnar Henderson, Jordan Westburg and Colton Cowser, a sign the front office is intent on keeping its young talent intact as it moves through the winter. The club also added seven players to the 40-man roster to shield them from the Rule 5 draft, part of the usual housekeeping that can shape a teams depth before camp opens.

There was plenty of other roster churn around the margins, with the Orioles making several releases and claims as they continue to sort out the back end of the roster. The business side moved along too, as the team announced ticket sales for next season and spring training, which is scheduled to begin in February, even if a potential lockout could complicate the start of camp. [Read more 🡒]