Orioles Season Fell Apart For Reasons Fans Still Havent Forgotten

Struggling with roster changes and player setbacks, the 2026 Orioles aim to end their season on a balanced note against the Yankees.

With the Orioles already done in terms of any real push beyond this weekend, the final stretch has turned into a small race against the calendar. There are three games left against the Yankees, and Baltimore can still finish at .500 if it sweeps them. That would mean winning six straight to close out the year, after the club last pulled off a similar finish in 2015 by winning its final five.

Weather has already reshaped the schedule. Because Saturday’s forecast in New York looked so poor, the Orioles and Yankees moved that game up and will play a doubleheader on Friday starting at 4:05 p.m. Even with Sunday’s outlook also looking rough, they’re still expected to try to get game No. 162 in.

The roster that finishes this season barely resembles the one that opened it on March 26. Only eight players from Opening Day stayed with the team continuously: first baseman Pete Alonso, shortstop Gunnar Henderson, third baseman Coby Mayo, outfielders Colton Cowser and Leody Taveras, starter Shane Baz and reliever Rico Garcia.

Baltimore used 60 players overall, which is 10 fewer than the franchise-record 70 from 2025. And while this season will go down as one of the most disappointing in club history, it wasn’t empty.

Alonso hit 41 home runs, good for ninth in team history. Mayo showed real power.

And the bullpen quietly uncovered some useful arms.

But the list of what went wrong is longer. Henderson underperformed.

Jackson Holliday’s season is on the verge of ending with left wrist surgery early next week. Samuel Basallo faded in the second half before a concussion ended his year Monday night.

Colton Cowser was one of the bright spots in a season ravaged by injuries. He held up physically in center field and flashed enough skill to matter.

His game-saving catch in Colorado on August 31 helped push the Orioles to .500, but the team dropped its next six after that. Offensively, Cowser also showed some promise, though he still needs regular work and more consistent production against left-handers.

The injury list kept growing. Jordan Westburg never got on the field this year, and after May Tommy John surgery he says he should be ready for spring training, whenever that begins.

Ryan Mountcastle managed only eight games because of a broken foot and then an oblique injury that added to a rough stretch. Tyler O’Neill played in 85 games, but his season was interrupted by a right shoulder injury that cost him the last five weeks after a diving catch on August 22.

The rotation was in much better shape than most of the roster. Baz, Kyle Bradish, Trevor Rogers and Brandon Young each made at least 27 starts.

Bradish will finish the season on the injured list because of a sports hernia. Zach Eflin’s year ended almost as soon as it began; his first start lasted only four innings before Tommy John surgery became necessary.

Westburg needed the same operation.

There was more stability at the back end of the pitching staff, even with some big names missing. Alonso delivered in the first season of his five-year, $155 million deal.

Ryan Helsley was healthy enough to appear in only 17 games. Félix Bautista returned from rotator cuff and labrum surgery and has pitched in two games.

The bullpen still found ways to hold up. Garcia is third among AL relievers with 75 appearances, which is sixth-most in team history. Yennier Cano was rewarded with a two-year extension that buys out his remaining arbitration years, and the Orioles also extended Baz and Bradish.

A few other relievers stood out as well. Josh Walker has strung together 21 straight scoreless relief outings, the longest such run on the team since Zack Britton’s 25 in 2016.

Alex Hoppe has been quietly effective in his 17 appearances. Luis De León, the club’s No. 7 prospect, impressed in eight relief outings, though his long-term role - starter or reliever - is still undecided.

If there’s one moment that may define this season more than any other, it’s the trade deadline shocker. Adley Rutschman, the cornerstone of the rebuild, was dealt to the Boston Red Sox for four highly ranked prospects.

Baltimore also moved outfielder Taylor Ward, whose power vanished, and longtime favorite Tyler Wells. The Orioles received Hoppe from Seattle for Ward, while Wells’ move to Tampa Bay opened a bullpen hole that helped create opportunities for De León, Hoppe and Walker.

Longtime starter Dean Kremer was also sent to Minnesota just before the deadline.

With Rutschman and Basallo gone, the Orioles will finish the season with Carlos Narváez, who came over in the big trade, and Yohel Pozo behind the plate. The final roster also includes infielder José Barrero and outfielders Christian Franklin and Rece Hinds.

Westburg’s absence also gave Blaze Alexander a chance to show he can handle a utility role in the majors and bring energy to the clubhouse. Like Basallo, whose left shoulder sidelined him for a month, Alexander was limited in the second half. He broke his left hand after being hit by a pitch just before the All-Star break, then came back only for his back to flare up and send him back to the injured list.

The Orioles used Christian Encarnacion-Strand to fill that spot, and he’s had a strong second half.

There’s plenty more to sort through, but that can wait. For now, most fans are ready to leave this discouraging season behind and start looking ahead to 2027.

In Other News...

Orioles May Have Their Future Shortstop If One Question Holds Up

Wehiwa Aloy has moved quickly enough to make the Orioles think seriously about what comes next at shortstop. After being taken 31st overall in the 2025 draft, he put together a strong 2026 across High-A and Double-A, posting a .288/.358/.506 line with 25 home runs and earning the Brooks Robinson Minor League Player of the Year award in the organization. For a club that always seems to be balancing the present with the pipeline, that kind of production is the sort that gets attention.

The question now is less about whether Aloy can drive the ball than whether the rest of his game holds up well enough to keep him on a shortstop path. Strikeouts remain part of the evaluation, even as scouting reports point to a player who projects as at least an average defender at the position. If that defensive baseline proves real, the Orioles may have something more than a power-hitting prospect - they may have a long-term answer at one of the games most important spots. [Read more 🡒]

Pete Alonso Just Gave Orioles Fans A Reason To Twist The Knife

Pete Alonso is settling in with Baltimore in a way that would have been hard to imagine not long ago, and hes not shy about saying it. After the Mets decided not to bring him back, the franchises all-time home run leader signed a five-year deal with the Orioles and has been productive for his new club, even as the season has gone sideways for both teams.

Alonso recently said he believes he was always meant to be an Oriole, and he made a point of thanking Baltimore fans for sticking with him through a difficult year. For Orioles supporters, its the kind of comment that feels both flattering and just a little sharp, especially with the sting of missing the postseason still fresh and the sight of Alonso doing well in orange and black now impossible to ignore. [Read more 🡒]

Orioles Could Be Headed For A Painful Offseason Shakeup

The Orioles are already staring at a winter built around tough calls, with the roster carrying several players whose situations could quickly force the front offices hand. Pending free agents and arbitration-eligible pieces have put the club in a familiar spot for a team trying to balance immediate competitiveness with longer-term flexibility, and the names floating through that conversation underscore how much can change in a single offseason.

Chris Bassitt, Andrew Kittredge, Leody Taveras and Zach Eflin are all among the players viewed as likely to be on the move after the 2026 season, depending on performance, contract status and where Baltimore sees itself going next. None of that is a final verdict from the organization, of course, but it does frame the kind of shakeup that can catch a contender in between eras if the results and the spending dont line up just right. [Read more 🡒]