The Orioles may have just watched one of their pitching targets disappear, but the real story is what that says about the market.
Dustin May is headed to the Chicago White Sox on a three-year, $52.5 million deal, according to FanSided MLB insider Robert Murray. That works out to $17.5 million per season, a number that instantly changes the conversation for Baltimore as it looks to upgrade its rotation before the 2027 season begins.
May had been one of the mid-range starters linked to the Orioles, a fit on paper for a club that has generally avoided the bigger-ticket free-agent arms in recent seasons. But if this is the going rate for a pitcher in that tier, Baltimore may need to rethink the lane it’s driving in.
The 29-year-old right-hander is coming off a second straight season with a mid-to-high-4.00s ERA split across four teams. In 2026, between the St.
Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers, he posted a 4.70 ERA and a 1.32 WHIP in 31 starts after finishing 2025 with a near-5.00 ERA. Those numbers don’t make him untouchable, but they also don’t scream bargain at $17.5 million a year.
There is still some appeal in the profile. May’s underlying metrics include an 85th percentile fastball velocity, and in theory he could have fit in the lower half of Baltimore’s rotation behind Kyle Bradish and Shane Baz. Even so, the price tag feels steep for a pitcher who has been more solid than special.
That’s where the Orioles’ dilemma gets interesting. If a mid-tier starter costs this much, is it really worth paying up for that kind of arm at all? Or does this push Baltimore toward a more aggressive move for a true front-end starter instead of settling into the same middle ground?
Tarik Skubal would be the dream, though he sits in a class of his own and would draw a crowd of contenders. But he’s not the only name out there. Trevor Rogers, Michael King, Kevin Gausman and Sonny Gray are all on the market, and each would bring the kind of impact Baltimore may need more than another expensive, ordinary rotation piece.
With a lockout all but inevitable on Dec. 2, the Orioles don’t have forever to sort this out. If they want to make real progress before the uncertainty of a new CBA takes over, Mike Elias and Jared Banner may have to move faster now that the first notable pitching domino has already fallen.
In Other News...
Orioles Just Sent A Clear Message With This Roster Shuffle
The Orioles used the Rule 5 protection deadline to make a fairly decisive statement about the shape of their system, adding seven players to the 40-man roster and trimming six to get to 38. The group protected included Enrique Bradfield Jr., Aron Estrada, Braxton Bragg, Michael Forret, Nestor German, Patrick Reilly and Levi Wells, a mix that shows Baltimore was focused on keeping a broad cross-section of its talent pool intact as the offseason begins to take shape.
Roster moves like this do not always grab attention outside the organization, but they can tell you plenty about which players the front office views as worth safeguarding. Baltimore now has a little more breathing room heading into the winter, while the decisions it made here also hint at how it sees the next wave of depth developing behind the big league club. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Just Drew A Telling Line With Their Latest Roster Decisions
With an expected MLB lockout looming, the Orioles spent the week making a clear statement about where they see their roster headed. Baltimore added seven prospects to its 40-man roster while removing six players, a flurry of moves that reflected both the urgency of the calendar and the organizations desire to protect young talent as the offseason turns uncertain.
The decisions came alongside a few other notable Orioles developments, including Trevor Rogers declining the clubs qualifying offer and Pete Alonso earning his second straight Silver Slugger Award. Off the field, Camden Yards is also set for upgrades, with the Mascot Zone slated to open by Opening Day and the Kids Zone following after the All-Star break, giving the ballpark a little extra life even as the roster picture continues to shift. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Just Sent A Clear Message About Yaqui Rivera
The Orioles watched a familiar kind of roster churn unfold this week when the Athletics came calling for right-hander Yaqui Rivera, a move that says plenty about how other clubs view Baltimores pitching inventory. Oakland sent minor league righty Josiah Romeo back the other way and immediately put Rivera on its 40-man roster, a sign the As did not want to risk losing him in the Rule 5 draft.
For Baltimore, it is another reminder that the organizations lower-level arms continue to draw outside attention, even as the club keeps sorting through its own pitching depth. The Athletics also made room for catcher Cole Conn on their 40-man and designated Yunior Tur and Hayden Juenger for assignment, a flurry of roster moves aimed at balancing protection, depth and flexibility. [Read more 🡒]
