The Orioles have a rotation problem to solve, and Nick Pivetta keeps coming up as the kind of arm that could help them patch it.
Baltimore is looking at a 2027 starting staff that currently includes Kyle Bradish, Shane Baz, and Brandon Young, with two more pitchers needed to round things out. The group wasn’t the weakest part of the 2026 club, but losing Trevor Rogers would be a major blow. That leaves the Orioles shopping for help, and the free-agent market doesn’t exactly look loaded.
Pivetta, who turns 34 on Valentine’s Day, is one of the more interesting names in that mix. He’s coming off two seasons with the San Diego Padres after spending five years with the Boston Red Sox, and his path to free agency has been a study in contrasts.
In Boston, Pivetta flashed the kind of stuff that keeps teams interested. The strikeouts were there, the fastball velocity was solid, and the underlying numbers looked decent enough.
But the damage came in the form of walks and home runs, and the ERA never escaped the 4’s. He left the Red Sox after the 2024 season with a 4.29 ERA in 131 games, and over those five seasons he surrendered 103 home runs - 1.5 per nine innings.
San Diego saw a different version of him. Before the 2025 season, the Padres signed Pivetta to a four-year, $55 million deal with the final two years set up as options. The club declined his 2027 option a couple of weeks ago, sending him back to the market.
That move wasn’t about poor performance. Quite the opposite.
In 2025, Pivetta made 31 starts and posted a 2.87 ERA, trimming the home run total, tightening up the walks, and simply keeping fewer runners on base. His WHIP was just under 1.
Then 2026 turned into a stop-and-start year. Pivetta missed most of the season with a flexor strain in his right elbow, making four starts in March and April before sitting out five months.
He returned in September and didn’t look diminished, allowing three earned runs in 18.2 innings for a 1.45 ERA. He also made two postseason starts, one against the Cubs and one against the Brewers, and the Padres won both games.
There was some initial surprise when San Diego declined the option, but the reporting pointed to concern over the elbow and a desire not to lock in too much risk. The Padres were also said to be open to a new deal that would give them more protection if the injury flared up again.
MLB Trade Rumors projects Pivetta for a two-year, $26 million contract, though they also noted he could wind up settling for a one-year deal because of his age and the injury question.
That’s where Baltimore enters the picture. The Orioles need multiple starters, and a short-term deal for Pivetta could fit alongside a longer commitment for another arm. They’re not in a spot to stack up a bunch of expensive long-term pitching contracts, especially with other roster needs still on the table.
If Pivetta can be had on a two-year deal, the upside is obvious. He pitched like a top-half rotation starter in San Diego and would immediately raise the ceiling of the Orioles’ staff.
If the elbow becomes an issue again, or if he drifts back toward his Boston form, the financial hit would be more manageable. That kind of flexibility matters.
There’s also the veteran angle. Pivetta has pitched for winning teams, and while that doesn’t show up in a box score, it can matter in a clubhouse that’s hearing plenty about chemistry and how to win.
The most likely outcome still seems to be a return to San Diego. He found success there, and the Padres are reportedly interested in bringing him back.
But until a deal is done, Baltimore has reason to stay in the conversation. For the Orioles, a pitcher like Pivetta would check one important box on a winter to-do list that’s getting longer by the day.
In Other News...
Red Sox Just Won A Catching Battle Orioles Fans Will Hate
The Red Sox have filled a need behind the plate by landing veteran catcher Nick Fortes from the Rays, a move that also cost them 17-year-old reliever Angel Roa in the deal. Fortes is expected to back up Adley Rutschman, and Boston cleared the roster spot by releasing Connor Wong after the trade came together.
For the Orioles, the more frustrating part is that they were in the mix for Fortes too before Boston got the deal done. Baltimore has been looking at ways to shore up its catching depth, so watching a division rival beat them to a player they wanted only adds another layer to an already familiar AL East annoyance. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Are Taking Another Chance On Two Intriguing Pitching Arms
The Orioles kept working the margins of their pitching depth by adding two arms with some real intrigue attached. Baltimore claimed right-hander Braden Nett off waivers from the Athletics, then brought back right-hander Carter Baumler from the Rangers and optioned him to Triple-A Norfolk, another reminder that this front office is still hunting for upside wherever it can find it.
Nett has not yet reached the majors and was designated for assignment by Oakland, while Baumler already got a taste of the big leagues earlier this year before injuries interrupted his progress. He had been selected in the 2025 Rule 5 draft and later traded to Texas, so Baltimore is clearly willing to take another look at a pitcher it once had in the system. For a club trying to keep building pitching inventory, these are the kinds of moves that can quietly matter later. [Read more 🡒]
Orioles Just Lost One Possible Westburg Path At The Worst Time
The Royals six-player deal with Seattle, sending third baseman Maikel Garcia to the Mariners for pitcher Bryce Miller, has a ripple effect that reaches Baltimores offseason planning. The Orioles had been among the teams viewed as possible trade partners with Seattle for third baseman Jordan Westburg, and any movement around the Mariners infield picture naturally mattered to a club still trying to map out ways to upgrade before the lockout.
Westburg remains in recovery from Tommy John surgery, with his goal still to be ready by Opening Day, so Baltimores timeline is tied to both health and market conditions. With the Orioles continuing to explore different roster paths, the latest trade only narrows the field a bit more at a moment when they would rather have more options, not fewer. [Read more 🡒]
